Julie had claimed the corner office with the good light, the one that had been empty since Maître Binoche retired, and she had already covered half of it with her own things: a standing desk, three framed photographs of a rescue greyhound, a whiteboard where she had drawn the file's timeline in four colors.
Sophie read the board from the doorway. Red for Anh. Blue for the funder. Green for the hotelier. Black for Henri.
"You've been busy," Sophie said.
"Ninety hours." Julie capped her marker. "Bélanger's insurer called twice this week. The hotelier—Perreault, the one with the Saint-Sauveur property—has new counsel as of Monday. He wants to talk settlement."
"Counsel who?"
"Ferland."
Sophie sat down without being asked. "Ferland doesn't do settlement talks. Ferland does pressure campaigns."
"That's what I said. He's already sent a demand letter with a number on it. Two hundred and thirty thousand, plus a retraction of the loaned works and a written acknowledgment that the gallery failed to secure his privacy."
"For a photograph nobody has proven he's in."
"He says he's in it. He says the back of his head is identifiable." Julie pulled up the letter on her screen and turned it toward Sophie. "His wife sits on the Van Hoorn acquisition committee. That's in the letter too. Not as a threat. Just as a fact he thought we should have."
Sophie read it twice. The letter was competent and nasty, which meant Ferland had drafted it himself before putting his associate's name at the bottom. "What did you tell Bélanger?"
"That we have thirty days to respond and I'd take instructions." Julie paused. "Then I told him we should consider whether the gallery even has standing to defend a photograph it can't authenticate. He didn't enjoy that."
"Most directors don't enjoy accurate questions."
"I'm not sure it was accurate."
Sophie looked up. Julie was standing behind her chair with her arms crossed, and there was something in her posture that Sophie recognized from her own first years — the specific stiffness of a lawyer who has decided to say the true thing and knows it will not be thanked for it.
"Say it," Sophie said.
"The photograph. If it's Marchetti's work, the gallery's right to exhibit it is clean. If it's Anh's, we have a signed release problem. If it's neither—" Julie stopped. "If it came from somewhere else, we have a provenance problem, and provenance problems in this city tend to lead to Henri Vachon."
"Which is why we should depose him."
Julie didn't answer immediately. She walked around to her own side of the desk and sat, and then she did something Sophie had not seen from her before: she closed the door from her chair using the long wooden ruler the previous tenant had left behind.
"That's why I wanted to talk to you and not email," Julie said.
"Email would have been fine."
"Nothing about Henri Vachon is fine in email." Julie set the ruler down. "He's a founding donor. Not just a donor. The Van Hoorn endowment is named for his wife's family, and his name is on the plaque in the lobby of this building. Which building we occupy at a discount, I should add, because his foundation owns it."
"I know what he is."
"Then you know what deposing him looks like from the partnership's point of view."
Sophie leaned back. "It looks like a lawyer doing discovery."
"It looks like a lawyer accusing a donor of something she can't name yet, under oath, on the record, in a case where the subject of the photograph may or may not be identifiable and the artist may or may not have signed a release. If it goes badly, the gallery loses its endowment, Bélanger loses his job, and the firm loses an institutional client that has been with us since 1988."
"You've thought about this."
"I've read the file. That's what you asked me to do."
Sophie nodded slowly. She liked Julie. That was the problem, or part of it. Julie was careful and quick and she had the kind of conscience that made her say the difficult thing in a closed room rather than the easy thing in an open one. Sophie had been that lawyer once. She was not certain she still was.
"Here's what I know that isn't in the file," Sophie said, and she told her about Anh's diary — not everything, not the photographs in her personal email, but enough. The last entry. The name. The sentence about the negatives.
Julie listened without moving. When Sophie finished, she said, "That's evidence."
"It's a missing woman's private diary, which we obtained by opening a locker with no warrant, no consent, and no lawful basis, and which I have already read."
"She could be in danger."
"She could be in danger, or she could be in Portugal. That's why we do this by the book from here. We depose Vachon on the provenance of the loaned works, which the gallery has an unquestioned right to ask about. If he lies about the negatives, we have something. If he doesn't lie, we have the truth."
"And the diary?"
"Stays where it is until we know more." Sophie said it flatly, and did not look away, and did not think about the seventeen photographs in her personal account.
Julie chewed the inside of her cheek. "A document request first."
"Yes."
"Targeted. Loan agreements, insurance schedule, all correspondence with Anh Trinh, all correspondence with Henri Vachon and any of his entities regarding the Marchetti donation."
"And his foundation's communications with the gallery about the acquisition."
Julie's pen stopped. "That's the part that will get me a phone call."
"It's the part that will get you an answer."
The phone on Julie's desk rang, a single short buzz, and she glanced at it and did not pick up. "I'll draft the request tonight. But I want it on the record that I think this is a mistake, and I want your name on the memo saying you advised it."
"Put my name on it."
"I will." Julie opened her laptop and started typing, and then stopped again. "Sophie. Your friend—Linh. Is she going to talk to the police eventually?"
"Soon. I think soon."
"Because if this diary surfaces through the police instead of through us, after we knew—"
"I know what it looks like."
"I'm not sure you do." Julie said it without heat. "That's the thing. You say you know what it looks like and then you go further in."
Sophie stood. She had no good answer to that, and she had learned long ago that a bad answer delivered confidently is worse than no answer at all. At the door she turned. "Send me the draft before you send it to Bélanger."
"I will."
"And Julie. When you write the request, include the gallery's historical insurance schedule. All years. Not just the current one."
Julie looked up. "Why?"
"Because a photograph that doesn't have a provenance in the catalogue still has to be insured by somebody." Sophie put her hand on the doorframe. "Somebody paid a premium on it. That leaves a paper trail, and paper trails don't have names on plaques in the lobby."
She walked back to her own office through a corridor of glass and muted carpet, past the conference room where a junior was annotating a settlement agreement, past the photograph of the founding partners that had been hanging there since before she was called. In her office she sat down and opened the private draft again. She read the last line she had written the night before. Then she deleted it and wrote a new one, and did not send it to anyone.
At four-fifteen, Julie forwarded the draft document request with two words in the subject line: *for review.*
At four-forty, Sophie approved it without changes.
At five, Henri Vachon's assistant called the front desk to confirm his attendance at the firm's spring fundraiser, in eleven days, at the museum.
Sophie put down her pen and looked at the phone for a long moment. Eleven days was not a deadline. But it was the first date anyone had given her since this started, and dates, in her experience, had a way of becoming the only thing anyone remembered.