The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 23: After Locker 12

Gabriel lived in a third-floor walk-up on Rue Saint-Denis, above a shop that sold hand-thrown ceramics. He made tea without asking whether she wanted any, and she let him, because her hands were still cold from the gallery and the radiators in his apartment ticked like a slow clock.

The diary sat on his kitchen table between them. Cloth-bound, the color of weak coffee, a ribbon marker frayed at the end. Anh's handwriting was small and leaning, the letters of someone who'd learned English and French in the same decade and had made a truce with both.

"I should do this alone," Sophie said.

"No."

"Gabriel."

"You said you weren't counsel. So you're not doing anything official. You're just reading." He pulled out the chair across from her and sat. "I'm not leaving you with it."

She opened to the last third. Most of it was ordinary — a list of gallery supplies, a fight with a landlord, a notation that her mother had called on a Tuesday. Then, in October, the tone changed.

*He came to the storage again. He doesn't knock. He says a collector in Westmount wants "authentic material," meaning the worst photographs of families. I told him those aren't mine to sell, they're family archives. He said the families signed them away when they donated. Maybe true. Doesn't make it right.*

Sophie turned the page.

*He offered 8,000 for the box. I said no. He came back with 12,000. Then he said something I didn't understand — that eventually the gallery will need him more than it needs me, and I should decide which side of that I want to be standing on.*

She read that sentence twice. Underlined it with her thumbnail, a crease she'd have to smooth later.

Gabriel hadn't moved. "What does it say."

"Money first. Then a threat with no edges on it." She kept reading. "He wanted the box. What box, Gabriel."

"The donation from the Marchetti estate. Nineteen-sixty-something. Half of it's in the permanent collection, half was never catalogued." He rubbed his jaw. "We call it the basement box because nobody has opened it since my father."

"There's a name."

"Vittorio Marchetti. A photographer. He shot weddings, mostly. And one summer he shot something else."

Sophie kept her eyes on the page. *I said I would take it to the director. He laughed and said the director is a chair, not a person. He asked if I knew what happened to Gabriel's father. I said no. He said, ask him. And then he left.*

The radiator ticked. Outside a car went by with the drag of wet tires.

"He knew," Gabriel said. "Before you told me anything. Before I told you anything."

"He wanted Anh to ask you."

"He wanted Anh to be afraid of me."

Sophie set the diary flat and turned to face him. "Was she right to be?"

The question sat there. He didn't answer it. She hadn't expected him to.

She read on. November entries were short, compressed, the writing smaller — as if Anh were rationing paper. A reference to a meeting at Henri's office on Sherbrooke. A line about needing to make copies before anything happened. A line she read three times: *If I disappear, the negatives are the only reason.*

The last full entry was dated six weeks ago.

*Went to H's office. He had a folder with the torn photo in it. Photocopy, not the print. He said this is already in circulation and you can't put the genie back. He said the show will be pulled or it will be a scandal and either way I lose. He said there is a clean exit. Sign the transfer on the Marchetti material and the photo gets withdrawn quietly. I said no. He said take the weekend.*

Then the last line, in a hand that had stopped being careful.

*He has the negatives.*

Sophie closed the diary. Her mouth was dry.

"She went to him," Gabriel said quietly. "She went to him alone and said no."

"She said no and then she vanished."

They sat with that.

It was nearly one in the morning. Sophie stood and walked to the sink, ran the tap, drank water straight from a glass that had a chip on the rim. She looked out the window at the alley below, where a cat sat on a recycling bin refusing to move for anyone.

"Who else knows about the basement box," she said.

"Me. My mother, maybe, in the abstract. The chair of the board, in theory. Henri, obviously." He paused. "And now you."

"Has anyone seen inside it."

"No."

"Then tomorrow that changes." She turned around. "There's a process for uncatalogued donated material. You inventory it. That's not an investigation, that's housekeeping."

"That's a reason to open a lock anyone can accept."

"Correct." She picked up her phone. "I'm going to photograph the relevant pages."

"Sophie—"

"The originals stay with you. Hidden, and I mean actually hidden — not in your apartment, not in the gallery, not in a car. If Henri comes looking, he should find nothing he can hold." She squared the spine of the diary and began photographing, page after page, flat under the kitchen light, the small blue glow of her screen lighting her chin. She caught the October entries, the Westmount collector, the Marchetti offer, the question about Gabriel's father, the meeting on Sherbrooke, the line about the negatives. Seventeen photos. She checked the focus on each one before moving on.

Then she opened her mail app and sent them to her personal account with no subject line and no message.

"That's discoverable," Gabriel said. "If this ever becomes a case."

"It's my personal account, not the firm's, and there is no case. There's a missing woman and a folder I wasn't supposed to see."

"You're building a file."

"I'm keeping a record." She put the phone face down. "There's a difference, and it's the difference between me having a job on Monday and me not."

He nodded slowly. He didn't look convinced, and she didn't need him to be. She needed him to stay quiet about it, which was a different kind of trust and one he seemed to understand without being told, because he got up and put the diary in a canvas bag behind a stack of framing wood, and then moved the framing wood somewhere else, and did not narrate where.

Julie's number was in her phone. Sophie looked at it for a long moment while Gabriel filled the kettle again.

If she told Julie, it would be right. It would be clean. It would also hand the entire thing to the firm, and the firm had a donor problem, and Julie was two weeks into a file she didn't ask for and might not yet know what the edges of the firm's loyalties were. Rousseau had been careful when he'd told her to transfer the file. He had said *prudent,* not *right.*

She put the phone back in her bag.

Not yet. Tomorrow she would know more. Tomorrow she would be in the gallery with a legitimate reason to open a door, and whatever they found would be a fact rather than a suspicion, and facts were a different currency. Facts were something Julie could act on without having to be brave.

"I'm not telling her," Sophie said.

Gabriel turned from the counter. "Why not."

"Because she'll have to decide something before she has enough to decide it with. And she'll decide it the way lawyers decide things when they're new and scared, which is to say she'll cover herself and call it caution." She sat back down. "I've been her."

He brought over two cups and put one in front of her. It was the same tea he'd made earlier and reheated, which she found, for reasons she didn't examine, almost unbearably tender.

"When's your memo due," he said.

"Nine." She looked at her watch. "Eight hours."

"You haven't written it."

"I know."

"So we'll write it in the morning and open a box in the afternoon."

"Something like that."

He sat down across from her, and for a while neither of them said anything. The building settled. Somewhere above them a neighbor's television murmured through the floor and then went off. Sophie drank the reheated tea and felt the long day fold itself up, panel by panel, the way a wall of panels folds at the end of a show.

"Why didn't you tell me in the stairwell," she said. "About your father."

"Because it wasn't about him yet."

"It's about him now."

"It's about Anh now." He turned the cup in his hands. "When I was eighteen my father walked into the Lachine Canal in November with his coat on. Everyone said accident. My mother said accident in a way that made it clear she'd decided what to say and would keep saying it. I believed her because I was eighteen and because the alternative had no floor under it."

"Henri knows something."

"Henri knows *about* the photographs. The ones from that summer. My father printed them, Sophie. Not Marchetti. My father took Marchetti's negatives and printed them in the darkroom at the gallery, which was a favor and which became something else." He stopped. "If the torn photo is one of them, then it's not Anh's. It's his. And Henri has known that since before I met you."

Sophie didn't reach for him. She sat with her hands around the cup and let the sentence stand in the room at full height, because it was the kind of sentence that needed the space.

"One thing at a time," she said finally. "Tomorrow we write the memo. Tomorrow we inventory a donation."

"And Henri."

"Henri gets the memo."

Gabriel almost smiled. "You're very calm."

"I'm a divorce lawyer. Calm is the only thing nobody can take away from me." She stood and found her coat on the back of the chair. "Walk me down."

He walked her down the stairs and out onto Saint-Denis, where the air had gone sharp and the shop awnings dripped in a slow irregular rhythm. She turned up her collar.

"You could stay," he said. Not hopeful. Just offering.

"I could. I'm not going to." She zipped her bag with the phone inside it. "Ask me again when there isn't a lock I need to open."

"That's a very lawyer answer."

"It's the only honest one I've got tonight."

She walked to the corner and turned back once. He was still in the doorway, hands in his pockets, under the weak yellow porch light. She lifted a hand and he lifted one back, and that was all of it, and she kept walking until the metro swallowed her.

At home she did not sleep well. She lay in the dark and ran the diary's last line over and over in her head — *he has the negatives* — and each time she heard it in Anh's voice, which she had never actually heard, so she assembled one from the tapes Linh played in the office, a low steady voice arguing for the truth about a building. She thought about Gabriel's father walking into the canal with his coat on. She thought about her own divorce, which had been loud and nothing like drowning, and yet had the same quality of wanting to leave a room without using the door.

Near four she got up, opened her laptop, and started the memo. Not the version the meeting would see. The other one, the one she would keep. She wrote for an hour and then stopped and went back to bed, and when the alarm went off at six-thirty she felt like a woman who had made a decision in her sleep and only needed the morning to explain it to her.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 23: After Locker 12 · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads