Sophie was three blocks from Julie's office with the disclosure memo open on her passenger seat when her phone lit up with Gabriel's name. She let it ring twice, headlights smearing across the wet Sainte-Catherine asphalt, and then answered anyway.
"Where are you?" he said.
"Downtown. I have a nine o'clock that's going to end my involvement in your exhibition."
"I'm at your office."
She almost said *my office is in my building and so is the gallery*, and then understood he meant Marchand et associés, the eleventh floor. "I'm twenty minutes out."
"Then I'll wait twenty minutes."
It took her twenty-five because of the tunnel traffic. She parked badly, half in a loading zone, and took the stairs rather than the elevator so she wouldn't have to hear the chime of her own floor. When she pushed open the glass door, Gabriel was sitting in the reception chair with his coat still buttoned and a manila envelope on his knees, and Nadia at the desk was pretending very hard not to look at him.
"You can go home, Nadia," Sophie said. "Log it as overtime."
Nadia left with the particular speed of someone who wanted to be gone before the interesting part.
Gabriel stood. He looked like he hadn't slept either, but on him it produced a kind of clean ascetic look that was unfair. He held out the envelope.
"Everything I know," he said. "About my father, about the 1958, about Anh. Written down, dated, signed at the end. If you want to use it, use it. If you want to shred it, shred it, but read it first."
Sophie took it. It was heavier than paper usually felt. "Come inside."
She put the envelope on her desk unopened, because opening it in front of him would have turned the room into a deposition, and she was trying—she didn't know what she was trying. She took her own chair and let him take the client chair, and the word *client* sat between them like a stain.
"My father died when I was eleven," Gabriel said. "What you've probably read is that it was a heart attack. It was a heart attack. He was also forty-one and a runner and had no history, and he was on the phone with Henri Vachon when it happened."
"He was on the phone with Henri."
"Henri was his gallerist. Henri was his friend. Henri was in our apartment two nights before, and there was an argument my mother made me go to my room for, and I sat on the floor and heard about nine thousand dollars and a contract and the words *you'll never show in this city again.*" He said it flatly, the way you say a thing you've repeated to yourself for thirty years until the words are furniture. "The line went dead while they were still talking. I don't know what was said. My mother doesn't know. Nobody knows but Henri, and Henri has spent my entire adult life being very generous to me whenever I've done what he wanted and mentioning my father's name whenever I haven't."
"And the 1958 print."
"It hung in my father's studio. After he died, my mother couldn't look at it, so it went into storage, and then it went into Henri's storage because he offered, and by the time I asked for it back it had been *damaged in transit*, and I let that go because I was twenty-four and he was paying for my master's." He stopped. "The twin is in his stairwell. You saw it."
"You knew it existed."
"I knew there was a second print from the edition because my father told me, once, when he was framing it. I did not know it was Henri's. I suspected, in the way you suspect things you don't want to be right about. And then you found it, and instead of telling you, I—" He lifted his hands and let them fall. "I made you into the person who might find it *for* me, so I could keep my hands clean with the family."
"Anh."
"Anh came to me two years after the divorce. She had nowhere to go. She was not my partner, she was not my lover—she was my father's studio assistant's daughter, which is a complicated thing to be, and she needed a couch and then a room and then a job, and I gave her all three because it cost me nothing. Then Henri started asking about her, and she got frightened and moved to the coast and changed her name, and she put me down as her emergency contact because she had nobody else, and I told her I would keep her address out of my mouth, and I did." He looked at Sophie directly. "That's the lie. Not the gallery business. That. You asked me twice and both times I told you I had no idea where she was."
Sophie sat with it. Somewhere down the hall a printer hummed and stopped. "She has a sister who has been sick with this for months," she said. "Linh thinks Anh is dead."
"Linh is the reason Anh left. Not Linh's fault. Henri used her. He asked Linh questions for a year, friendly questions, and Linh answered them because she had no idea she was being mined." He paused. "If I'd told Linh the truth, she'd have gone to Anh, and Henri would have followed her, and Anh would be a piece of paper. So I didn't. Which is a reason and not an excuse."
"No," Sophie said. "It isn't an excuse."
"No."
She pulled the envelope toward her and turned it over once. Stapled, three, maybe eight pages inside. "What do you want from me?"
"Not representation." His voice had gone quiet in a way that was worse than anger. "I heard you on the terrace, at the gallery. You said you were an officer of the court and I was a witness. You were right. But Sophie—" and he leaned forward—"I don't need another lawyer. I have one. He's very good and I don't like him. I need one person in this city who will tell me the truth about what's happening without billing me for it."
"You want a friend."
"I want you."
The sentence landed in the office like something falling off a shelf. Neither of them moved to pick it up.
"You're asking me to choose between the file and you," Sophie said.
"I'm asking you to stop doing both at once. It's one or the other. You can't sit across from me as counsel and then sit across from me at my kitchen table and tell me the table version is real. I'll take either. I won't take both." He stood and buttoned his coat, which meant he was leaving before she could answer, which was its own kind of cruelty, delivered politely. "Read it. Two days. If I don't hear from you, I'll assume it's the file, and I'll live with that."
At the door he stopped.
"Henri is having a funders' dinner on Tuesday. I'm invited because I'm the curator and because he likes to show me off to people who write cheques." His mouth did something that wasn't a smile. "He'll say something. He always says something. I'll be listening this time."
And then he was gone, and the elevator chimed, and Sophie was alone with her own desk and the envelope and the clock on the corner of the screen: 8:41.
She opened the envelope. The first page was a chronology in his small, careful hand, dated back to a year before she was born. The second page was about the print. The third was about Anh, with an address in Vancouver written in the margin and then crossed out so hard the pen had gone through the paper, and beside it, in the same pen: *I never went. She asked me not to.*
At 8:49 she took out her phone and looked at the disclosure memo in her drafts, then at the shop's number in her contacts, then at the document again.
At 8:56 she opened a blank reply to Julie and typed: *I need until end of day.*
She read it twice.
At 8:58 the phone buzzed in her hand and the screen said JULIE, and Sophie looked at the envelope on her desk, at the name in the margin, at the papers of a man who had just told her to pick one, and pressed answer.