The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 39: After the Article

The article was four hundred and twelve words long. Sophie read it standing at her kitchen counter, coat still on, keys still in her hand. Then she read it again sitting down. Then a third time with a pen, marking the lines that would matter to a lawyer.

Manon Trudel had done exactly what she'd promised. She had the seizure notice quoted in full, the loan terms, the twenty-one-day demand. She had Gabriel's statement — *I won't sell the work to keep the building* — and she had Henri's, released within the hour: *My son has confused a gallery with a grudge. I wish him luck with both.*

The line that stopped Sophie each time was this one: *Sources close to the gallery's counsel say the acceleration was timed to a legal proceeding unrelated to the loan.*

She had said that off the record. Trudel had used it anyway, laundered through "sources," which was fair enough in the trade and would be very hard to trace back to her, which was the point. *Sources close to the gallery's counsel.* Henri's lawyers would read it. They would pull the thread. They would get to Julie, to the file, to her.

Sophie set the pen down. The apartment was very quiet. Somewhere below, a snowplow scraped the length of the street, and she listened to it go, all the way to the corner, and turn.

She had been suspended from the file. She was home at nine forty on a Thursday with her coat on, reading about a man she had told to come over, who had said no.

She picked up her phone and called Linh.

It rang five times. Then: "Sophie? It's late."

"I know. I read the article."

"What article?"

"Le Devoir. It ran today. I need you to know Anh is safe. The story names Henri, not your mother, not the shop. Nobody goes near the shop."

There was a long pause. Sophie could hear the television muttering in the background of Linh's house, a kettle somewhere.

"You're calling me at nine forty to tell me my mother is safe," Linh said.

"Yes."

"You could have texted."

"I wanted to hear it land."

Another pause. The kettle clicked off.

"You're not at the office," Linh said. "I can hear it. No elevator, no lobby. You're home."

"I'm on leave."

"From the firm?"

"From the file."

Linh made a small sound, neither surprise nor sympathy — the sound of a woman adding a column of numbers and not liking the total. "Because of this. Because of him."

"Because of a complaint I filed that I would file again."

"He's got you suspended and you're calling me to do damage control for his gallery."

"I'm calling you because your mother didn't do anything wrong and I didn't want you finding out from the newspaper."

"Fine. Thank you." Linh's voice softened half a degree, which with Linh was a great deal. Then, evenly, the way she asked questions she already knew the answers to: "Sophie. Do you love him?"

"That is not the question."

"It's exactly the question. I've watched you not answer it for two months."

"It isn't. The question is whether I take a man who refuses to be helped into the middle of a legal fight I'm already losing, and whether that helps him or just makes me feel less useless."

"That's not a question either," Linh said. "That's a paragraph."

"Linh."

"Do you love him?"

Sophie looked at the article on the counter, the pen marks, the four hundred and twelve words. *I wish him luck with both.*

"He hung up on me," she said. "He called me happy and frightened and then he hung up because he thinks Henri's people are listening to the line. He's right. They might be. That's where we are. So the question is not whether I love him. The question is what I can do from here that doesn't hand Henri another lever."

"That's still a paragraph."

"Good night, Linh."

"Sophie."

"I heard you."

"I didn't ask if you'd tell him. I asked if you loved him."

Sophie closed her eyes. The radiator ticked. Below, another plow, or the same one coming back.

"Yes," she said. "Good night."

She hung up before Linh could say anything kind about it.

Then she sat for a while doing nothing, which was not a thing she did, and then she got up and fetched her bag from the front hall and took out the envelope she had carried home from the office in her coat pocket like contraband: the unsigned releases, still in her drawer for two years, still in her hands for reasons she had not named even to herself.

She cleared the table — the article, the pen, the cold cup of tea from that morning — and laid the releases flat, one sheet at a time, in a grid. Sixteen pages. Three clients. Two of them had finished mediation and simply never come back to sign; one had disappeared after the fourth postponement, and her file had a note in Julie's handwriting that said *client relocated, no forwarding.*

Sophie opened her laptop and made a spreadsheet.

Column one: file number. Column two: parties. Column three: date the release was drafted. Column four: last contact. Column five: status. Column six — she sat looking at the blank header for a while before she typed it — *what she wanted.*

Not what the release said she wanted. What she had said, in the room, when she'd stopped arguing and started listening.

Client nine-fourteen, the husband: *I don't want the house. I want to be in the same room as my kids without a court order. I'd sign anything for that.*

Client nine-sixteen, the wife: *I want him to stop telling people I ruined him.*

Client nine-twenty, the one who relocated: *I want to not be a story in this city anymore.*

Sophie typed all three in. Then she sat back and looked at the grid, sixteen pages of releases nobody had signed, and the sixth column full of things people had said once, in a small room, to her.

She had taken them home because the firm was reviewing her. She understood that now, sitting in her own kitchen with the plow going by a third time. Not as evidence. As a reminder. Somewhere in the last four months she had stopped being able to tell the difference between a client and a person, and it had cost her the file, and she was not sorry, and she needed to know what she *was* going to be, if not the lawyer who won.

She worked for forty minutes. She added a seventh column: *release needed?* For nine-fourteen, yes — he'd never get the access schedule without it. For nine-sixteen, yes, but with a term: no public statements, either party, twelve months. For nine-twenty, she wrote *no*, looked at it, and left it.

Her phone lit up on the counter. Unknown Montreal number. Fifth time now.

She let it ring. Eleven rings — nobody lets it ring eleven times unless they mean it — and then it stopped, and the screen went dark, and she did not call it back.

She sat with her hands flat on the table on either side of the laptop, and let the quiet come back in.

It occurred to her, in the way that obvious things arrive late, that she had been asked a question twice tonight and had answered it only once. Linh had asked if she loved him. Somewhere under that was the other question, the one she had been circling for weeks: *what do you do with it.*

She had told Gabriel the truth — that she wouldn't be his lawyer, that she couldn't protect him from behind a wall, that the only ground they could stand on was level. He had agreed with her and then hung up anyway, because level ground felt like a target to him now. She understood that. She had spent fifteen years watching people reach for each other across a courtroom and miss.

She could call him. The article was out; the wound was fresh; he was alone in a half-empty gallery with no counsel. He would answer. She knew he would answer.

She did not call.

Instead she saved the spreadsheet, closed the laptop, and went to make tea she actually intended to drink. While the water heated, she read the article one more time — not for Trudel's phrasing or Henri's statement, but for the last paragraph, the one she'd skipped the first three times because it wasn't about the loan.

*Asked what he'd say to his father, Benoît-Vachon paused for a long moment. "That the exhibition isn't about him," he said. "It never was. I'd like him to come see it before it closes. I don't expect him to."*

Sophie stood in her kitchen with the kettle ticking and read that twice, and something in her chest went carefully, deliberately still.

He hadn't told her that part. Of course he hadn't. He'd told the reporter, and not her, because a reporter was safe — a reporter was a stranger he'd chosen to hand the truth to, and she was someone he'd chosen to protect from it.

The kettle clicked off. She poured the water and stood there, and did not decide anything, and drank her tea by the window, watching the street the plow had left clean.

On the table behind her, the sixteen pages of unsigned releases lay in their grid, and the laptop slept, and the unknown number stayed unanswered, and it was late, and Sophie Marchand was, for the first time in a long time, exactly where she had chosen to be.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 39: After the Article · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads