The bailiff had a soft, apologetic voice, which somehow made it worse.
Sophie heard him before she saw him—Gabriel's phone held away from his ear at arm's length, the speaker crackling with official French, the sound of a man reading from a document he clearly wished he didn't have to read. She was in her own kitchen, coffee going cold, the spreadsheet of unsigned releases open on her laptop. She'd been on the phone with Gabriel for eleven minutes when the knock came.
"Sophie." His voice went thin, distant. "There's someone here."
"I heard."
"Huissier de justice. He has—" A pause, paper rustling. "He has a notice. Seizure of artworks pursuant to the loan agreement. They're taking the collection."
She was already standing, already reaching for her keys before she remembered she had no standing to be there. Suspended. Handed off. Julie's file now. Her fingers closed on nothing.
"Are you there?"
"Yes." She made herself sit back down. Made herself breathe. "How many pieces?"
"Let me—" More rustling. "Seven. Including *La Photo Déchirée*. Henri's pieces. He signed them over as collateral two years ago and I never—" His breath caught. "I never thought he'd actually do it."
"Gabriel. Listen to me." She kept her voice level, the voice she used in mediation when both parties wanted to walk. "Do not resist. Do not argue with the huissier. He's just executing a court order. You fighting him gives Henri's lawyers a photograph for the morning edition."
"But the exhibition opens in—"
"I know. Let him take them."
Silence. She could hear the bailiff's voice in the background, patient, saying something about an inventory and a receipt.
"Document everything," Sophie said. "Photograph each piece where it hangs before he touches it. Get the condition in writing. Date, time, the huissier's name and commission number. Ask for his card. Do you have paper?"
"It's a gallery. I have paper."
"Then stop talking to me and start writing."
The line went quiet except for ambient sound—footsteps on the concrete floor, the low murmur of the bailiff, the scrape of a ladder being positioned. Sophie stayed on the line, phone pressed to her ear, listening to a room she wasn't allowed to be in being dismantled.
It took ninety-four minutes.
She counted. She'd always counted—billable hours, minutes between objections, the time it took a client to decide whether to leave a marriage. Counting was how she kept her hands from shaking.
Gabriel came back to the phone in increments. "First piece is down. *Sans Titre III*. The big one from the east wall." Later: "*Le Couloir*. They're wrapping it in bubble film, Sophie, they're using *bubble film*—" Later still, quiet: "Okay. Okay. I photographed it. I got the condition report. He signed it."
"Good. What's left?"
"*La Photo Déchirée*." A long pause. "He's standing in front of it. He says he's not supposed to take a piece off the wall without the artist's representative present, or the gallery director, and I'm the director, and I'm—" His voice cracked. "I'm supposed to hand it to him."
"Hand it to him."
"Sophie—"
"Hand it to him." She closed her eyes. "It's paper and ink. It's not yours. It was never yours. You told the reporter you wanted Henri to see the exhibition before it closed. This is him seeing it. This is the only way he knows how to see anything."
"You think he's watching."
"I think the huissier arrived the morning after the article ran and you already know that."
He laughed, once, without humor. "Yeah."
"Document it. Then hand it over. Then call me back."
She heard the small click of a photo being taken. Then another. Then the soft paper sound of a frame being lifted from its hook, the specific hush of a room losing something.
"I'm handing it to him now," Gabriel said, and the line went dead.
He called back from his office, door closed, and she could tell from the echo he was sitting on the floor.
"Half the main room is empty," he said. "It's—you know how a room looks when a tooth's been pulled? The gap is louder than the wall."
"Tell me the inventory."
"You don't have to—"
"Tell me the inventory, Gabriel."
He did. Seven pieces, condition noted, signed for, removed between 9:47 and 11:21 a.m. The huissier's commission number, his card details, the receipt with the court's seal. He'd photographed every empty hook with a measuring tape against the wall, which she hadn't told him to do and which was, she thought, exactly the kind of detail that would make a lawyer love him.
"You did well," she said.
"I did what you said."
"You did it well."
Rain started against her window, sudden and heavy, the Montreal kind that arrived like an accusation. She looked at the spreadsheet still open on her laptop—client names, what they'd asked for, what they'd received—and thought about all the things people sign without reading.
"Hang on," Gabriel said. "There's—"
The door. She heard it through the phone, the low chime of the gallery's entrance, voices. He was on his feet, moving, and then his voice came back changed, careful, professional.
"Can I help you?"
A man's voice, smooth, English with a French edge. "Monsieur Laurent? I'm with the firm of Deschamps et Associés. We represent Groupe Vachon. I'm here regarding the accelerated balance and a matter of counsel."
Sophie sat very still.
"Counsel," Gabriel said.
"We understand the gallery received legal advice in connection with the recent press coverage. Advising a party adverse to our client's interests implicates certain confidentiality obligations. We'd like to know who advised you, and under what terms."
"I don't have a lawyer."
"That's precisely the interesting part, monsieur."
Sophie's thumb moved before she thought about it—the call still live, his phone in his pocket, the man's voice carrying clear and small. She could hear Gabriel breathing. She could hear him decide.
"I'm not going to discuss that," Gabriel said. "I'd like you to leave."
"Of course. We'll be in touch through your counsel—" A pause, deliberate. "When you have one."
The door chimed. Footsteps. The rain.
Gabriel came back to the phone. "Sophie."
"I heard."
"They know."
"They suspect. There's a difference, and the difference is everything." She was already standing, already pulling the releases into her bag, already thinking in the flat fast way she thought when a case turned. "They're fishing. They read 'sources close to the gallery's counsel' in Le Devoir and they want a name they can use to disqualify or frighten you. Don't give them one. Don't confirm, don't deny, don't be clever. If they call again, say you have no comment and refer them to—" She stopped.
"To who?"
To no one. To the counsel he didn't have. She pressed her palm against the counter and looked at the rain.
"Gabriel," she said. "I'm going to ask you something and I need you to answer straight."
"Okay."
"When you told the reporter to run that story—when you stood in that room and handed over the photo—did you do it because it was right, or did you do it because you wanted him to see you doing it?"
Silence. Long. The rain filled it.
"Both," he said finally. "Is that allowed?"
She thought about Henri's dismissive statement, about the eleven rings on her phone, about a stranger at the door asking who she was to him and meaning it as a threat. She thought about how she'd built forty-two years of life on the principle that you never let anyone name your relationships for you.
"Bring the receipt and the condition reports to my apartment," she said. "Tonight. Not because I'm your lawyer. Because I want to see them, and because the walls of that room are half bare, and I don't think you should sit alone with that."
"The ethics review—"
"Will do what it does. Come over, Gabriel."
A pause. Then, quietly: "Okay."
She hung up and stood in her kitchen with the rain coming down and the spreadsheet glowing, client nine-twenty still waiting in its cell, *may not need a release at all*—and she understood, with the clarity of someone who had spent a career reading the fine print, that she had just made a decision she could not bill for and would not be able to argue her way out of.
Her phone rang again.
The same unknown Montreal number. She looked at it for a long moment, then answered.
"Sophie Marchand," she said.