The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 42: Anh's Return

The café on Saint-Viateur was crowded for a Tuesday, steam fogging the window, the good kind of noise—spoons, a grinder, somebody's kid banging a plastic cup against the table leg. Sophie had gotten there first and taken the corner booth, back to the wall, sightlines to both doors. She was aware of the habit and disliked it.

Anh Trinh came in at four past two, thin as a wire, a duffel bag over one shoulder and the airport still on her. She spotted Sophie, crossed, and did not sit down right away.

"You didn't have to," Anh said. "Meet me."

"Yes, I did."

They looked at each other. Then Anh set the bag down and slid into the booth across from her.

"Where's Gabriel?"

"On his way."

Anh nodded, fiddling with the sugar caddy, turning the little glass jar a quarter turn, then back. "You know he hasn't called me once. Since the article. He sent one text. *Your name stays out of it.* That's all."

"That sounds like him."

"It sounds like a man who thinks he's protecting you by not telling you he needs anything." Anh's accent had softened the last few years, but it thickened when she was tired. "I've watched him do it to my brother for ten years."

Sophie didn't answer that. The bell over the door rang and Gabriel came in, saw them, and stopped for half a second—just long enough to take Anh in, make sure she was real—before weaving through the tables. He didn't hug her. He pulled up a chair and sat at the end of the booth, angled so he could see both of them, and Sophie felt something click into place and hated that she noticed it.

"You look terrible," Anh told him.

"Thank you."

"You're welcome." She finally let go of the sugar caddy. "Okay. So. You want to know why I left."

"I didn't ask you to explain anything," Gabriel said. "I asked if you were all right. I'm still asking that."

"I'm all right. I'm angry, which is different." Anh reached into the duffel and came out with a padded envelope, manila, worn at the corners. She set it on the table between the three of them and didn't open it.

"He has the negatives," she said. "You know that already. What you don't know is he has had them since the fourteenth."

Gabriel went still. Sophie knew that stillness; she'd seen it in depositions, the moment a witness realizes the thing they've been protected from is already over.

"You left on the ninth," he said.

"On the fourteenth, a man came to my apartment." Anh's voice stayed flat, deliberately so. "Two men. One talked. He had photographs of my mother's building in Blainville—not the outside, the inside. Her kitchen window. He said Henri understood I was the only person who knew where the negatives were, and that Henri was disappointed to have learned this second-hand."

"Jesus," Sophie said.

"He didn't threaten her." Anh said it like a correction. "He never said a single thing you could take to anyone. That's what made it work. He just—described her kitchen. And then he said the gallery had a lawyer who was making things complicated, and that things would go easier for everyone if I simply helped return the gallery's property to the gallery." She looked at Sophie, briefly. "I didn't know your name. He didn't give it. I figured it out two days later when the article ran."

"He means me," said Sophie.

"He means all of us."

Gabriel had his hands flat on the table. "You gave him the negatives."

"I gave him *access*." Anh pushed the envelope with two fingers toward Sophie. "I gave him access, and I photographed every negative first, with my phone, into my own cloud, before he touched them. I'm not asking you to forgive me. I'm telling you what I did and what I still have."

Sophie opened the envelope. Prints, maybe forty of them, black and white, small format. Families in kitchens and doorways and parked cars. A father carrying a girl asleep on his shoulder. Two women on a front stoop, squinting into the sun. A boy in a T-shirt that read *Champions de la rue* holding a hockey stick taller than he was. She went through them the way she read contracts, fast and then again slow, and stopped on the last one.

It was the boy with the hockey stick, but smaller, different angle. She turned it toward Gabriel.

"That's the one he took down," she said.

Gabriel looked at it for a long moment. "That's not the one he took down."

"What do you mean?"

"He took the one from the wall, the one I made at seventeen. This is a different frame from the same roll." He turned the print over before he remembered there'd be nothing on the back. "I didn't know there was a second frame."

"There are six," Anh said. "Of that family. He had me pull all of them."

Sophie set the print down. "You want them shown."

"I want them *returned*." Anh said it sharply, then sat back. "But yes. I think they should be shown. That's what I've been carrying since Thursday. That's why I came back."

Gabriel started to speak and Anh cut him off.

"Not like before. With consent." She leaned forward. "I've been in that room, Gabriel. I know exactly what your show does to a mother who recognizes her own kitchen and never agreed to have it hung. I've watched a woman cry in front of a photograph of her own husband drinking coffee and be told by a stranger *this is your family's story*, and I have done nothing. Twice. So I'm not going to help you put six more up on a wall in twenty days just because this time Henri isn't the villain."

"Do you have contact with them?" Sophie asked.

"Some. I did the intake, Sophie. I have every release interview, every address we collected, every phone number anyone wrote down." Anh looked at her, and there was something careful in it, something that had been held back a moment. "And I know which ones never signed."

Sophie felt her pulse in her throat.

"Nineteen names," Anh said.

"Thirty-four." Sophie said it before she decided to.

Both of them stared at her.

"I have the releases," Sophie said. "The unsigned ones. They were in my drawer when the firm took me off the file, and I—" she stopped. "I took them home. I've been going through them. Nineteen have no signature at all. There are another fifteen with signatures that were never witnessed, or signed by one spouse when the photograph has two people in it, or signed by someone who is not clearly the subject of the image. Legally, those are worse than nothing."

"Shit," Anh breathed.

"So if you're saying what I think you're saying—"

"I'm saying we ask them," Anh said. "Every one. Show them the image. Let them decide: this one, like this, with this caption, or not at all. And if they say no, it comes off the wall."

Gabriel hadn't moved. He was looking at the envelope.

"It's not a show anymore," he said finally. "If everyone decides, then it's not an exhibition. It's a—"

"It's a document of what people agreed to reveal." Sophie heard herself, the lawyer in her grabbing hold of the thing. "That's the show. Not the families. The *consent*. What's left on the wall is what people chose, and the empty rectangles are the refusals, and the refusals are the point."

There was a silence, and in it, the espresso machine screamed.

"Henri would hate that," Gabriel said.

"The gallery board won't," Sophie said. "The board can survive a controversy. It cannot survive a second seizure and a class action from nineteen families." She was already writing in her head, form and clause, revocation, minor subjects, a photography embargo pending signature. "Twenty days is enough if we start tonight."

"You're suspended," Gabriel said. Not an accusation. Something closer to *are you sure*.

"I'm suspended from representing the gallery." Sophie picked up the print of the boy in the hockey shirt and looked at it. Small, old, unposed; the kid had been laughing at somebody off-frame. "I'm not suspended from representing them."

Anh exhaled and put both hands on the table like she'd just finished something. "Good. Then there's one more thing, and I want it out now, because I don't want it coming back to bite us in a week."

"Go," said Sophie.

Anh looked at Gabriel. "When I pulled the six frames of that family—the boy, the hockey stick—the envelope wasn't in his file. It was in a different box." She swallowed. "The label on the box was a name. And it wasn't the boy's."

She reached across and pulled the last print from Sophie's hand and laid it flat, face up, and turned it so Gabriel could read what she'd written in pencil on the back corner in her own hand, a note she'd made for herself before she'd left it behind.

Gabriel read it. Then he looked up at Sophie, and for one second his face was twenty years younger and completely without a door.

"It's my mother's name," he said.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 42: Anh's Return · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads