The gallery after dark was a different animal. The streetlights on Notre-Dame caught the high windows and threw pale rectangles across the floor, and the floor was the problem — you could see all of it now. Where the seven seized works had hung, the wall was a shade lighter, unfaded, like skin that had worn a ring for years.
Gabriel sat with his back against the baseboard beneath the torn photograph's empty rectangle, knees up, a takeout coffee going cold beside him. Sophie had come in through the loading door because the front was still staked out by two reporters who'd decided the story was a siege.
"I brought the seizure paperwork," she said, holding up the folder. "But you don't want it tonight."
"No."
She sat down across from him. Not beside him. Six feet of bare floor between them, the way you'd sit across from a client, except she'd stopped pretending that's what this was somewhere around the second hour of cataloguing other people's unsigned releases.
"I counted the walls today," he said. "Twenty-nine pieces when we hung it. Twenty-two now. I keep thinking if I don't count them, more will go."
"That's not how bailiffs work."
"I know how bailiffs work." He picked at the coffee lid. "My mother left when I was twelve. Did I tell you that?"
"No."
"He was a bastard and she had a good reason. I want to be clear about that up front, because I spent about ten years thinking I was the reason, and I'm not doing that version anymore." He looked up at the empty wall, not at her. "She came into my room the night before. Sat on the edge of the bed. I remember she was wearing her coat already, which is the detail I can't get rid of, the coat. She said, *tu vas comprendre quand tu seras grand.* You'll understand when you're older."
Sophie said nothing.
"So I waited to be older." His mouth moved like it wanted to smile and didn't quite. "Turns out I got older and I understand fine and it doesn't help. She was right and she was gone. Both things."
The building ticked. Somewhere on Saint-Laurent a truck downshifted.
"My father wouldn't say her name after that," Gabriel said. "Henri either. Like she'd been a business decision that didn't work out. And every time I did anything they didn't like — quit law school, take the curatorial job, hang other people's broken families on a wall — it was *ça, c'est ta mère.* That was her name in our house. *Ta mère.* The thing that made me unreliable."
"Is that why you won't fold?" Sophie asked. "Because folding looks like her?"
"I don't know." He finally looked at her. "Maybe I'm just stubborn and you're looking for a story."
"I'm a lawyer. I'm always looking for a story. It's a professional deformation."
"Deformation." He repeated it like he was tasting it. "Yeah."
She should have said something lawyerly. *You should have gotten the releases signed in 2019. You should have consulted counsel before you let a reporter in. You should have let me handle the seizure.* All of it true, none of it useful, and none of it what he'd asked her here for. She was suspended. She had no standing to give him advice and no standing to withhold it either. So she just sat there with the folder in her lap and let the silence do its work.
"You're not going to tell me what I should have done," he said after a while.
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because you know what you should have done. You don't need me to say it out loud. You need somebody to sit on the floor with you at nine at night in a room full of empty rectangles."
His face did something complicated. He looked away first.
"Okay," he said. "Your turn."
"My turn."
"You know about my mother. I don't know anything about yours."
"Different kind of story."
"So make it a different kind of story."
Sophie set the folder down. She hadn't talked about it in four years, not properly — not since the last mediation, when she'd had to sit across a conference table from Marc and agree that irreconcilable differences were, in fact, irreconcilable, and the mediator had used the word *unfortunate* eleven times.
"I was married for eleven years," she said. "I don't say that often. It feels like a statistic about somebody else."
"Marc."
"Marc. He was kind. That's the thing nobody believes about a divorce lawyer's own divorce — that it can be boring. He wasn't cruel. He didn't cheat. He just — " She stopped. Started again. "I worked. I built a practice. I won cases and I got good at it, and at some point the marriage became a thing I scheduled, and he noticed before I did. That's the worst part. He noticed first. He sat me down on a Tuesday and said, *Sophie, when did we stop?* And I couldn't answer, because I didn't know. I hadn't been paying attention."
Gabriel didn't fill the pause. That was the thing she was learning about him. He could hold a silence without panicking in it.
"I booked a client call the next morning," she said. "Nine a.m. I remember standing in the kitchen with the phone to my ear, and he was in the doorway with his suitcase, and I waved at him. Waved. Like — *one minute, I'm on a call.*" She felt the laugh come out of her anyway, short and ugly. "He waited. He actually waited until I hung up. I don't know why. I wouldn't have."
"He loved you."
"He did. I think he still does, in the way you love a thing you had to leave."
"And that's why you keep everybody at the length of a billable hour."
It wasn't a question, and it wasn't kind, and she was grateful for it. "That's why I keep everybody at the length of a billable hour," she agreed. "People leave when you stop paying attention. So I keep paying attention, but I charge for it. That way nobody's surprised."
"Your client nine-twenty."
"What about her?"
"The release you didn't want to sign. The one you said might not need a release." He tipped his head. "You've been at this four days. You took the file home after they suspended you, which you didn't have to do."
"I don't know why I took it."
"Because it's her." He said it simply. "Because when she sat in the mediation she said what she wanted and you wrote down what she was allowed to want, and you've been thinking about it ever since. That's the lawyer version of what I do with the walls."
Sophie looked at him for a second too long. That was the whole problem with the room being empty. With the work gone from the walls, there was nothing to look at except each other, and there was no exhibit between them to explain why they were both here at nine at night with a folder of court papers and a cold coffee.
"You're doing the thing," she said.
"What thing?"
"You're seeing me. It's very inconvenient."
He stood up. Crossed the six feet of floor. Sat down next to her, not touching, with his back to the same wall, close enough that she could feel the warmth coming off him and smell coffee and the rain from wherever he'd been before.
"I keep thinking about the countdown," he said. "Twenty-one days when we hung it. I don't know how many now. Fifteen? Fourteen?"
"I don't know either. I stopped counting when they suspended me."
"I want him to see it." He said it flatly, looking straight ahead. "Henri. I want him to walk in here and stand in the middle of these empty walls and see what he took, and I want him to know he took it and it still counts. I never told you that."
"You told the reporter."
"I told you now."
He put his hand on the floor between them, palm up. Not reaching. Just — there. Available.
Sophie looked at it for a long time. Long enough that she was aware of the choice happening, long enough that she could have stood up and walked out and nothing would have happened, and every part of her that had learned to leave first or bill for it or wave from doorways said *don't.*
She put her hand in his.
They sat like that by the empty wall for a while. His fingers closed over hers, warm and dry. Neither of them said anything. It was, she realized, the first time in years she'd touched somebody without a file open between them, without an hourly rate accruing, without an exit already planned. Her thumb moved once, involuntarily, across his knuckle, and she felt him stop breathing for a beat and start again.
He turned his head toward her.
"Don't," she said, softly, not moving her hand.
"I wasn't going to."
"You were thinking about it."
"I think about it constantly. That's not the same as doing it." He exhaled. "You have the ethics review. I have Henri's lawyers. I'm not going to be the reason — "
"I know." She stood up, taking her hand back, and the cold on her palm was immediate. "I know what you're not going to be the reason for."
She picked up the folder. She didn't open it. At the loading door she stopped with her hand on the bar and didn't turn around, because if she turned around she wasn't going to leave.
"Leave the seizure documents at my place tomorrow," she said. "I'll read them."
"Sophie."
"What?"
"If I wanted to stop this," he said, from the floor, "I would have stopped it by now."
She left anyway.
Outside, the two reporters were gone, replaced by a black sedan idling across the street with its lights off. Sophie walked past it without looking, turned the corner onto Saint-Laurent, and had her phone out before she'd gone half a block — not to call him, and not to text him, and she told herself that too. She pulled up the spreadsheet instead, scrolled to row nine-twenty, and read the column she'd filled in at two in the morning: *What she actually wanted.*
The sedan rolled forward behind her and stayed a careful half-block back.