The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 50: The Age Question

The young artist was named Manon, and she had brought a folding stool, a thermos, and a portfolio in a plastic sleeve spotted with rain. She set the stool down in the middle of the empty floor and looked around the Villeray space with the frank appraisal of someone measuring a room against a picture in her head.

“It’s bigger than the photos,” she said.

“It photographs small,” Gabriel said. He was on his knees by the north wall, taping down a strip of kraft paper marked with pencil lines. “You’re here about the call?”

“I’m here about the wall, mostly.” She crouched and unzipped the sleeve. “I do installation. Small objects, a lot of them. I need a wall about six meters and I need to be able to nail into it.”

Sophie was at the table with the release letters spread in three piles—signed, refused, pending—and she did not look up right away. That was the discipline of the thing. She was here as a volunteer. She had a role, and the role had edges, and she stayed inside them.

“Six meters is the west wall,” Gabriel said. “It’s plaster over brick. You can nail, but you have to patch after.”

“I patch,” Manon said. “That’s the whole practice. You build something and you make it disappear.” She stood and turned in a slow circle, taking in Gabriel, then Sophie, then the two of them again. “Are you the father?”

Gabriel’s hand stopped on the tape.

“Sorry,” Manon said, not sounding sorry, only curious. “You’re doing the show together, so I assumed family. Is she your mother?”

The room went very quiet. Somewhere down the block a truck worked through its gears.

Sophie kept her eyes on the letter in front of her, the one from a woman in Laval who had written *I will sign if you do not use my name* in a cramped hand, and she waited. It was a small thing. It was a comma. A man could correct a comma.

Gabriel said, “The west wall is yours. Bring sketches Thursday.”

Manon nodded, pleased, and went to collect her stool. Sophie signed nothing and moved nothing. She turned the letter facedown and stood and folded her coat over her arm.

“Sophie,” Gabriel said.

“I’m going to get the train,” she said.

She made it to the corner before he caught up, which meant he had left the door unlocked and Manon inside with the portfolio, and she did not turn around to tell him that, because he would figure it out and because she was busy being angry in a way she wanted to keep clean.

“Sophie.”

“It’s a fair question,” she said, walking. “She looked at two people in one room and made a guess. People guess.”

“I should have said something.”

“Yes.”

“I froze.”

She stopped at the crosswalk and turned. The light was red. A woman with a stroller waited beside them, and Sophie lowered her voice, which somehow made it worse.

“I know you froze,” she said. “I heard the freeze. It was very loud.”

“It’s not—” He pushed his hands into his jacket pockets. “It’s not that I don’t want people to know.”

“Then what was it?”

“You don’t want people to know,” he said. “You told me that yourself. The associate at your firm. The partners.”

“That was before.”

“Before what?”

The light changed. Neither of them moved. The woman with the stroller went around them and crossed.

Sophie looked at him and felt the whole thing settle into place, the way an argument does when you finally find the sentence underneath it.

“I’m forty-two,” she said. “You’re twenty-nine. I’ve done the math. You’ve done the math. Anyone who ever sees us together is going to do the math, and it is never going to stop being the first thing they notice. I have made my peace with that. I made my peace with it on Saint-Laurent, walking home, when I didn’t sleep.”

“Sophie.”

“The gap is not the problem,” she said. “I can live with the gap. I have lived with worse. The problem is that when a stranger stood in your studio and asked if I was your mother, you went silent, and what you were protecting in that silence was not me. It was you. You didn’t know what you wanted the answer to be, and you didn’t want to say it out loud in front of a witness, and so you said nothing, and what I heard was you deciding I’m not something you claim.”

His face had gone still in the way she recognized from the exhibit, from the long table of prints, from a man who could look at a hard thing for a long time without flinching. He said, “That’s not what I was deciding.”

“Then say the thing,” she said. “Say what you actually want.”

He didn’t.

He opened his mouth and closed it, and the light changed again, and still he didn’t, and Sophie felt the anger drain out of her into something colder and steadier.

“Right,” she said.

She reached into her bag and took out the keys—the space keys, the front door and the storage drawer, on a ring with a chipped metal tag from a hardware store on Beaubien. Anh had had two sets cut. Sophie had been carrying one since Tuesday.

She held them out.

“I’m not taking those,” Gabriel said.

“They’re not mine to keep,” she said. “I’m a volunteer. Volunteers don’t hold the keys.”

“That’s not why you’re giving them to me.”

“No,” she said. “It isn’t.”

He took them. She watched his hand close around the ring, and she felt the small hard snap of a door she had not planned to close, and she knew she could still take it back—one sentence, one hand out, and they would go upstairs and resume the long negotiation. She did not take it back.

“The letters are in three piles,” she said. “Signed, refused, pending. The Lafleur one needs a call, she wrote a note instead of a signature and I couldn’t tell which she meant.”

“Sophie.”

“Thursday I have my mother,” she said. “I told her I’d come.”

She turned and walked to the corner, and this time he did not follow, and she did not look back to check whether he stood at the curb or had already gone inside, because she had asked him the only question that mattered and he had answered it by not answering, and she got on the train with her phone dark in her hand and let the city run gray past the window.

The keys stayed with him. Let him decide whose door they opened.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 50: The Age Question · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads