The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 51: After the Assumption

Claire was already at the kitchen table when Sophie let herself in, a crossword half done and a cup of tea gone cold beside it. She didn't look up.

"You're late. The kettle's still warm."

"I know." Sophie hung her coat on the hook by the door — the same hook her father's jacket used to hang on, and she noticed, the way she always noticed, that nobody had ever moved it. She poured herself tea without asking. The apartment smelled like the same lemon soap it had smelled like for thirty years. "I went by the space first."

Claire filled in a word. Five letters. "The Villeray one."

"The Villeray one." Sophie sat down across from her. The chair creaked the way it had always creaked, in the same place, as if the house had memorized her.

For a while neither of them said anything. Claire finished the puzzle's across clues, set down the pen, and finally looked at her daughter the way she only looked when she'd decided something.

"You've been talking about this exhibit for two months and you've said his name four times," Claire said. "So either he's difficult, or he's the other thing."

Sophie wrapped both hands around the cup. The tea was too hot and she didn't move it away.

"He's twenty-nine," she said.

"I know how old he is. You told me at Easter."

"Then you know what I'm going to say."

"I don't know anything," Claire said. "I'm asking."

There was a long pause. Somewhere down the hall a neighbor's television murmured, that low steady backdrop of the building, the sound of everyone else's ordinary evening. Sophie had come here to be the one who asked the questions. She was good at questions. She could depose a man about his offshore accounts for six hours without raising her voice.

"I'm afraid," she said, "of being a phase."

Claire didn't react the way Sophie had braced for. No sharp intake, no *oh, Sophie*. She just turned her cup a quarter turn on its saucer, thinking.

"A phase," she repeated.

"He's twenty-nine. He's going to want things I've already had. A first apartment that isn't a compromise. Kids, maybe. A version of his life that doesn't come with a forty-two-year-old woman's whole previous marriage dragging behind it." Sophie heard how flat her voice had gone, the lawyer's voice, the one she used to keep her hands steady. "And in two years, or five, or when I'm fifty and he's thirty-seven and some girl his own age walks into his studio — he'll realize he was in something and I was in love. Those aren't the same thing, maman. I've represented enough people who found that out to know how it ends."

Claire nodded slowly. She didn't argue. That was the surprising part.

"Your father," she said, "looked at me like that."

Sophie set the cup down.

"Like what."

"Like he'd already decided and was waiting for me to catch up." Claire's eyes were on the table, on the crossword, on something that wasn't in the room. "We met at the hospital. I was thirty-three and divorced and I thought that was the end of it — I thought the interesting part of my life was finished and everything after was just upkeep. He was younger than me."

"By three years."

"By three years." Claire smiled, small. "Do you know what I told my sister? I told her, I'm not doing this, I'm not going to be some young man's education. And your father listened to me say that for a whole evening at a Christmas party, and then he walked me to the metro and he said — he said, *Claire, you keep telling me what I'm going to do. Ask me what I want to do.*"

Sophie looked at her mother. Sixty-nine years old, hands spotted, wearing the same cardigan she'd worn every winter since Sophie could remember. It occurred to her that she had spent her entire life knowing her mother and had never once thought of her as having been a young woman with a whole catastrophic interior life.

"And you asked him."

"I asked him." Claire picked up her pen again, not to write. "Thirty-six years. He never once made me feel like the phase."

The tears came faster than Sophie expected and she hated it — not the crying, the timing, the way it arrived in the middle of a Tuesday at her mother's kitchen table over cold tea. She pressed the heel of her hand against her eye and laughed once, wetly. "I'm not — this is ridiculous."

"It's not ridiculous." Claire reached over and covered her daughter's wrist. Her hand was warm and dry and very light. "You know what I think? I think you're not afraid of being a phase. You're afraid of being loved by someone who hasn't read the file yet. And Sophie — nobody has read the file. Not even the ones who were there for it."

Sophie laughed again, or cried, and it came out as the same sound.

They sat like that a minute. Then Claire took her hand back and said, in the practical tone she used for everything important, "Does he know you're afraid?"

"No."

"Then he's making decisions in the dark. Same as you." She turned back to the crossword, done with the subject, done with it forever. "Eat something before you go. There's soup."

She ate the soup. She told her mother the news about the space and the release letters and M. Tremblay's daughter, and Claire listened and asked one question about parking, which was her way of saying *I'm proud of you*. And then Sophie drove home through the cold, empty streets of a city that was already pretending it wasn't winter yet, and the car was too quiet, and she kept hearing *ask me what I want to do* in her father's voice, which she barely remembered, which she had maybe invented.

At home, before she took off her coat, she called Julie.

Julie picked up on the fourth ring, which meant she'd been ignoring it. "Do you know what time it is."

"Ten past nine."

"It's late for you. You're the one who goes to bed with the retirees." A rustle of paper. Julie was probably still at her desk. "What's wrong."

"Nothing's wrong. I want to know about the ethics review."

A pause. Sophie could hear the radiator ticking in the background, the particular hum of the firm's building at night, which she knew better than her own kitchen.

"That's an interesting thing to want to know about at nine at night."

"Julie."

"Fine." More paper. "It's in front of the committee. Fournier's office filed their materials Friday. There's a hearing scheduled — well. There *was*."

Sophie's coat was still on. She sat down on the arm of the sofa. "'Was.'"

"They postponed it. The committee postponed. But the interesting part is the chamber — Fournier's own people opened a file on him. That's the rumor, anyway. Cynthia in litigation has a cousin at the bar who says the sanctions committee is looking at whether he filed a meritless complaint with knowledge of the underlying facts, and Sophie, I have to be careful here because I am repeating a rumor—"

"Repeating."

"—but the rumor is that when they reviewed the Vachon matter, someone noticed he'd been on the other side of a very similar claim five years ago and settled it quietly. Which means he knew exactly how thin it was when he went after you."

Sophie let that sit. Somewhere under the exhaustion, in some old part of her, there was a small, mean satisfaction, and she set it aside, because she didn't trust it and didn't want it.

"And my file?"

"Still suspended." Julie's voice flattened. "I'm sorry. Suspension stands pending the review, but the review now has a different character than it did a week ago. If the committee is looking at him, they're looking at both of you, and they're going to have to decide which one of you behaved like a lawyer."

"Which one of us behaved like a lawyer," Sophie repeated. "I kept a client's confidential document."

"You did."

"I'd do it again."

"I *know* you would." Julie sighed, and it came out almost affectionate. "That's the problem, Sophie, that's always been the problem. You're going to be fine. I have to say that as your friend. As your colleague I have to say I can't tell you anything official and you should not repeat any of this."

"I won't."

"Good." A beat. "Are you okay? Really."

Sophie thought about the kitchen table. The lemon soap. Her mother's hand over her wrist, light as a leaf.

"I think I might be," she said. "I don't know yet. Ask me in a week."

"I'll ask you Friday," Julie said, and hung up.

Sophie sat on the arm of the sofa with her coat on for a while after that, listening to the building. She didn't call Gabriel. She wanted to — the wanting was right there, a phone-shaped weight in her pocket — but the wanting wasn't a reason, and she had told him she wasn't his lover and he had stood in that doorway and let a stranger believe she was his mother, and both of those things were still true tonight and would still be true in the morning.

What had changed was smaller and stranger. She wasn't afraid of being a phase anymore. She had said it out loud to the one person whose judgment she actually feared, and her mother had looked at her and said *thirty-six years* and *ask him what he wants*, and the fear had shrunk to the size of a real, manageable thing — a document she hadn't read yet.

She took off her coat. She hung it on her own hook. She made herself a cup of tea, too hot, and sat at her own empty kitchen table.

Tomorrow she would go to the space and walk the wall again, and Thursday she would keep her word, and at some point — not tonight, but soon — she would stop deciding for him what he was going to want, because that was the same silence he'd been guilty of, and she was tired of both of them making honest decisions in the dark.

The tea cooled. She drank it anyway.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 51: After the Assumption · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads