The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 6: The Ledger

The gallery was cold when she arrived, the radiators ticking like something settling. Gabriel had left the front door unlocked and the lights off, which Sophie noted the way she noted everything—as a fact with potential liability attached.

"Back here," he called.

She found him in the small office behind the exhibition space, a room she hadn't seen on her first visit. It was the size of a closet and twice as cluttered: a desk drowning in paper, a printer with its guts exposed, a filing cabinet with one drawer hanging open like a tongue. He was holding a banker's box against his hip, trying to pry the lid with his thumb.

"You left the door open."

"I was expecting you." He set the box down. "And it's Griffintown at three in the afternoon. Nobody's stealing a photograph of a torn wedding."

"People steal for stranger reasons." She stayed in the doorway. "What is that?"

"Everything I have about the show. Every loan, every agreement, every email where somebody said yes and then changed their mind." He pulled the lid off and set it aside. "You asked for documentation. I'm giving you documentation."

Sophie stepped in. The office smelled like toner and old coffee. On the wall above the desk, someone had taped a print of the torn wedding photo—the same one at the center of the dispute—and drawn a circle around the bride's severed hand in red marker.

"That's not the original."

"That's a working copy. I mark things up." He gestured at the box. "You want to start?"

She wanted to start by asking why his hands were shaking, but that wasn't the question she was being paid to ask. She sat down in the chair he pulled out—vinyl, cracked, cold through her trousers—and began to read.

The first folder was straightforward. Loan agreements, condition reports, insurance riders. She read the way she read everything, fast and suspicious, her pen tapping against her thumb. Gabriel stood by the window, watching the street, doing the thing he did where he pretended not to watch her.

Forty minutes in, she found it.

"Vachon Holding," she said.

He didn't turn around. "What about it?"

"This isn't a loan agreement for a photograph. This is a line of credit." She lifted the page. "Sixty thousand dollars against the gallery's receivable's and tangible assets. Collateralized. Signed eighteen months ago."

"The gallery needed a roof."

"You have a roof."

"The roof needed a roof." He turned now, hands in his pockets. "It's fine. It's a family thing."

She set the page down and looked at him. "Groupe Vachon is your family."

"My father's company. He puts money in, I pay it back when I can. It's not complicated."

"It's a loan that encumbers your inventory." She pulled the document closer, scanning. "Every work on the premises is listed as collateral. Every work. Including the Trinh."

"It's boilerplate."

"It's not boilerplate." She found the clause and read it aloud, flatly, the way she'd read it in court. "'In the event of default, the lender may take possession of all collateral, including without limitation any artworks, and may dispose of same at its sole discretion to satisfy the outstanding balance.'" She looked up. "You signed a document that lets your father seize and sell the entire show."

Gabriel shrugged. It was a small shrug, almost invisible, but she caught it—the way he did when he wanted to end a conversation he hadn't started.

"So?"

"So if you default, he can take Anh Trinh's negatives. He can sell the wedding print. He can do whatever he wants with the one thing in this entire situation that isn't even yours to lose."

"It won't come to that."

"You don't know that."

"I know my father."

Sophie put her pen down. "Everyone knows their father until the paperwork arrives."

He laughed—a short, surprised sound—and she felt something shift in her chest, the way it did when he laughed, which was a problem she was choosing not to have right now.

She turned back to the file and kept reading. The terms grew worse as she went: a personal guarantee, cross-default provisions, a maturity date that was, she noted, eleven months away. She photographed each page with her phone. Gabriel watched her do it.

"You're documenting my finances."

"I'm documenting a document. It's in the box."

"It's in my box."

"You handed me the box."

He made a face she couldn't read and turned back to the window. Outside, a delivery truck idled, and someone wheeled a rack of clothes down the sidewalk. Sophie finished with the Vachon file and set it on the corner of the desk, separate from the rest, the way she kept exhibits apart from background evidence.

"Why did you show me this?" she asked.

"You asked for documents."

"I asked for releases."

He was quiet a moment. Then: "Because I don't want you to think I'm hiding anything. Because the last lawyer I dealt with found out about the loan from a bank statement and used it." He turned. "I'd rather you hear it from me."

"Who was the last lawyer?"

"My father's. After my mother died." He said it evenly, the way people said things they'd practiced saying evenly. "There was an estate. There was a disagreement about the gallery. He won. That's why the loan exists. That's why he owns the roof."

Sophie didn't say anything. She had spent fifteen years learning that the moment after someone tells you the true thing was usually the moment they'd tell you more, and she had also spent fifteen years learning not to trust that instinct in her personal life. She let it sit. In the box, under the Vachon file, she noticed a second folder, unmarked, thicker than the others.

"What's that one?"

"Old loan agreements. The credit line has been amended twice."

"Show me."

He pulled it out and handed it over. The amendments were worse than the original: a higher rate, a shorter maturity, a new clause that extended the lender's right to inspect the collateral on demand. Sophie read it twice because the first time her hands had gone cold.

"These terms are punitive."

"He restructured after the estate."

"This isn't restructuring. This is a leash." She set it down. "If you keep this line of credit open through the show, if you miss a single payment, your father can walk in here and take every work on these walls. Including the ones other people gave you to protect."

Gabriel didn't shrug this time.

"I know," he said.

"Then why—"

"Because I don't have another sixty thousand." He said it plainly, no self-pity in it, which somehow made it worse. "The gallery doesn't make money. It makes—" he gestured at the walls, the taped photograph, the room—"this. The show matters. I don't know how to explain it to a person who bills by the hour, but the show matters, and the only way I get to the show is to sign the papers my father's lawyer puts in front of me."

Sophie looked at the folder, then at him. In the other room, the radiators ticked.

"There's a difference between signing the papers and reading them," she said.

"I read them."

"You skimmed them."

"I know what they say."

"Then you know he can take the Trinh."

"He won't."

"You keep saying that." She stood up, and the chair scraped. "You keep saying that as if wanting it were the same as controlling it. It isn't. I've watched people lose things they were certain they'd keep. I've billed for the aftermath."

He was still for a moment. Then he reached past her, picked up the amended agreement, and dropped it back into the box.

"Okay," he said. "What would you do?"

The question landed wrong—too direct, too personal, exactly the kind of question she didn't answer for clients and certainly didn't answer for men in cold offices with marked-up photographs on the wall.

"I'd get a second lender," she said. "Or a guarantor who isn't the party who stands to gain from your default. Or I'd let the line lapse and use the interim to restructure the show around works I actually own." She paused. "Or I'd ask why my wife left me the gallery and my father the loan."

Gabriel looked at her for a long beat. Then he laughed again, but it wasn't the surprised laugh from before. This one was quieter. Almost grateful.

"You're good at this," he said.

"I'm expensive at this."

"I know." He picked up the box. "Coffee? I'll make it in the back. I won't ask you to stay, I'll just make it and you can decide."

She should have said no. She was already past the point where her notes would be clean. But her coat was still on and the door was still open and she heard herself say, "Black, no sugar," which was neither yes nor no, which was, she realized as she heard it, exactly the shape of everything that had happened between them since the first meeting.

He went to make the coffee. Sophie sat back down and, while he was out of the room, took one photograph of the amended loan agreement that she hadn't taken before—the signature page, his father's name in heavy black ink—and filed it in a phone folder she'd labeled, months ago, *matter 4836 / incidental*. She told herself it was evidence.

She told herself that on Thursday, at two, she would meet him and Linh Trinh in the Plateau and write everything down, and on Friday she would do what the file demanded, and the loan and the leash and the man in the next room would all be one closed matter among many.

Then he came back with two cups and set one in front of her, and on the rim of it, in his handwriting on the cardboard, was a small mark—like a signature but not one—and she found herself looking at it instead of him, which was its own kind of answer.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.