The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 60: The Ethics of Us

The call from Anh Vu came at 7:40 Saturday morning, before Sophie had finished her first coffee, and it was not about the opening.

"Vachon's counsel filed a supplemental," Anh said. "They're arguing the community co-op's assumption of the debt is a fraudulent conveyance designed to shield Marchand-Bellamy assets. The motion names the co-op, the gallery, and—" a pause, the sound of papers—"the curator. Gabriel Bellamy. They're deposing him Thursday."

Sophie set the mug down. "On what basis?"

"On the basis that he's been coordinating with you personally since the injunction. They have phone records. They have your name on a legal aid intake form he signed in February. They're going to ask him what else you've coordinated."

The coffee went bitter in her mouth. "That's garbage. He's a client-of-record on a separate matter."

"He's a client-of-record on a separate matter who has dinner at your mother's house and walks you through a locked gallery at night," Anh said, evenly. "Vachon's people have a photograph."

So did every tabloid in the province, Sophie thought, but she didn't say it. "How bad is the exposure?"

"For the co-op, manageable. For you—the Bar's conflict rules don't need a bad outcome, they need the appearance. He's a party to the litigation. You've been advising him. It's the same signature on the same page."

Sophie was quiet a moment. "Send me the supplemental. I'll deal with it Monday."

She hung up and sat in the kitchen with her hands flat on the table, watching light climb the far wall. Then she opened her laptop and drafted, for the first time in her life, a conflict waiver naming herself.

The document was four pages. It took her until noon.

It opened conventionally—party identification, the nature of the simultaneous representation, the informed-consent standard. Then it did something no waiver in her template library had ever done: it separated the roles into numbered paragraphs with headings. *Legal Representation.* *Personal Relationship.* *Confidentiality Boundaries.* *Scope of Advice.* Under *Legal Representation* she wrote that she would advise Gabriel Bellamy on matters arising from the Vachon action only, that she would not advise him on contractual or gallery matters, that she would refer those to Anh Vu. Under *Personal Relationship*—she typed the heading twice before leaving it—she wrote that any personal interactions between them would be kept distinct from the scope of legal advice, that she would not use confidential information obtained through the personal relationship in any legal proceeding, and that he similarly would not.

It was not romantic. It was worse than not romantic. It was the most honest thing she had ever put her name to.

She printed two copies, put them in a legal folder, and drove to his place.

Trân's apartment was on the second floor of a triplex on Casgrain, narrow stairwell, bicycle chained to the railing. Gabriel opened the door in a paint-stained T-shirt and bare feet. He'd been working on something on the kitchen table—contact sheets, a lamp clamped to the edge, the smell of fixer drifting from the bathroom.

"My sister will be home at seven," he said, letting her in. "We have about three hours."

"This won't take three hours."

He looked at the folder. "That's a legal folder."

"It is."

She sat at the kitchen table and set the folder between them, unopened. For a moment she just looked at him—the ink on his fingers, the way he was already braced, the light coming sideways through the window and catching the fine, permanent-looking scratch on the lens of his glasses.

"Saturday morning," she said, "Anh called. Vachon filed a supplemental. They want to depose you Thursday about our relationship."

His face didn't change much. He got very still, the way he did when he was listening. "Why?"

"Because they think a curator coordinating with a lawyer on the other side of a seizure is a story they can sell to a judge. Because there's a photograph of us. Because you signed an intake form in February with my name on it, and somebody searched."

He turned the lamp down, which made the contact sheets go dark and the room come forward. "And that's a problem for you professionally."

"It's a problem for the case. It's a problem for the co-op." She touched the folder. "And it's a problem for us, if we don't draw the line ourselves before someone draws it for us."

"So draw it."

She opened the folder.

He read the first page the way he read everything—slowly, hands on the paper, mouthing nothing but with his eyes tracking back over clauses. Halfway down the second page he stopped and looked up.

"You wrote this."

"This morning."

"For me."

"For us. Both copies." She slid the second one across. "Paragraph four is yours. I don't use anything you tell me as a person in any proceeding. Paragraph five is mine. You don't ask me to advise you beyond the scope."

"What's the scope?"

"Matters arising from the Vachon action. Nothing else. Anh takes everything else." She paused. "Gabriel, I'm not offering to be your lawyer. I'm telling you what I can't be if I'm also going to be—" She stopped, because the next word did not exist in a form she could say out loud yet.

He waited. When she didn't finish, he said, "If I'm also going to be at your mother's table."

"Yes."

He looked back down at the page. He read the confidentiality paragraph twice. Then he asked, "What does the last section say?"

"It says either of us can terminate the legal portion at any time, in writing, without terminating the rest."

"The rest."

"The rest."

He was quiet a long time. The bathroom fixer smell had gotten stronger; somewhere downstairs a television was on. Gabriel turned the second page, then the third, and his thumb tracked up the margin like he was checking for a trap he couldn't see.

"Vachon will use this," he said finally.

"Against what?"

"Against us. They'll enter it as evidence that we knew there was a conflict. They'll say a document this careful is an admission."

"It's the opposite. It's a document that says this was never hidden." She leaned forward. "If Thursday goes how I think it will, they ask you why I've been in your studio, and you say because we're together, and you produce this. Or you don't, and it doesn't matter, because the co-op's assumption isn't a fraudulent conveyance and Vachon's counsel knows it—they're fishing."

"Fishing for what?"

"For the version of me that looks like a woman who broke her own rules for a man twenty years younger." She said it plainly, because there was no other way. "I'd rather hand them a document that says I didn't."

He nodded slowly. Then he picked up the pen she'd brought—she'd brought a pen, an actual pen, fountain, black—and flipped to the last page.

"You want me to sign the part about confidentiality."

"I want you to sign the whole thing."

He did. His handwriting was worse than his paintings suggested it would be, cramped and left-leaning, the *B* of Bellamy coming up short. He signed both copies, blew on the ink out of habit, and handed her one back.

"Now I want something," he said.

"What?"

"Write on mine. At the bottom, under the signatures. Something that's not legal."

Sophie looked at him. Then she took the pen and wrote, in the margin below his name, in her own cramped black hand:

*The legal part is the easy part. This is the rest.*

He read it. He didn't say anything for a while. Then he closed the folder and put his hand flat on top of it, the way he put his hand flat on a photograph before he committed to hanging it.

"Thursday," he said.

"Thursday. I'll prep you for the deposition Tuesday night. As your lawyer, per paragraph two." She stood, gathering her things. "And Friday, if it goes badly, I'll show up as the other thing."

"Which thing?"

She was already at the door. She turned. "The one without a clause number."

He laughed—short, surprised, the real one. She left him there with the folder and the dark contact sheets and walked down the narrow stairwell and out onto Casgrain, where the street had gone afternoon-quiet and the light through the maple leaves was doing to the pavement what he did to paper.

Halfway to the car her phone buzzed. Inés, by the preview.

*Sophie. Call me tonight. Something about the hands piece you should know before Thursday. It's not shelved.*

Sophie stopped on the sidewalk. She read it twice. Then she looked back up at the second-floor window, where the lamp was still on, and Gabriel was still there, and thought: he told me it was out of the show.

She put the phone in her pocket and kept walking.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 60: The Ethics of Us · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads