The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 65: The Review

Gabriel's phone was face-down on the table between the coffee cups. Sophie watched it the way she watched witnesses—waiting for it to move.

"I told the volunteers no calls during install," he said. "They're calling anyway."

"Answer it."

He did. Listened. Said, "Send me the link," and hung up. Then he turned the phone over and read.

Sophie drank her coffee, which had gone cold, and waited.

"'The most honest show in Montreal this year,'" Gabriel read. He'd stopped eating. "'Twenty-three photographs, each one a family negotiating its own fracture. Nothing here is staged and nothing here is sentimental.'"

"That's good."

"'But the wall text frames the project as a collaborative inquiry, and one keeps returning to the fact'—keeps, ok, they're English"—'that the legal architecture surrounding this exhibit was designed by Sophie Marchand, a family law attorney with no curatorial training, whose involvement raises a question the show never answers: is this art, or is it therapy with paperwork?'"

He lowered the phone. "There's more."

"Read it."

"'Marchand's professional interest in family dissolution cannot be separated from the subjects' consent to be seen. This is not a criticism of the show. It is, perhaps, the show.'"

Sophie set the cup down. The café window was fogging where the space heaters blew. "Who's the critic?"

"Claire Bertrand. La Presse. She came Thursday, stayed an hour."

"And she liked it."

"She says the second paragraph of the wall text—the one about consent being an ongoing negotiation—is the strongest thing in the room and it's not a photograph."

Sophie turned her cup a quarter-turn on its saucer. "She's not wrong."

"She's not entirely right either."

"Which part?"

Gabriel ate a bite of the croissant, chewed, set it down. "The part where she calls you the legal architecture. You're not architecture. You're on install. You made the phone calls Thursday night. You sat in Maëlle's stairwell—"

"She's a critic." Sophie reached across and pulled the phone toward her, scrolled. "She gets one frame. She picked the frame where I'm a lawyer."

"And if she picked the frame where you're a person?"

"Then she's writing a profile, not a review." Sophie pushed the phone back. "You should be flattered. She wrote that the show has no thesis, which means it has a thesis."

He looked at her.

"What?"

"Say the next thing."

"There isn't a next thing."

"There's always a next thing with you."

Sophie leaned back in the chair. The café was mostly empty; a man in a puffer jacket was reading a newspaper at the window bar, silent as a prop. "Fine. She's right that there's a gap between how the show talks about consent and how consent was actually obtained. One release was forged. We caught it, we fixed it, we opened a day late. None of that is in the room."

"We agreed not to make that public. It would have put Maëlle on display again."

"I'm not saying we should have made it public." Sophie heard her own voice go flat and billable. "I'm saying the language overstates."

Gabriel's mouth tightened. She recognized the tightening; it happened whenever she used the architecture voice on him.

"You want me to change the wall text."

"I want to know what you think it's for."

"The exhibit?"

"The paragraph. The one Bertrand liked."

He picked up the phone and read it again to himself, lips moving faintly, the way he read everything. "'Consent is not a form. It is an ongoing negotiation, and the work of that negotiation is part of what you are looking at.'" He put the phone down. "That's true."

"It's true about photographs. It's not true about families. Families don't negotiate. They sign and they move on and then somebody files a motion six years later."

Gabriel was quiet.

"That's not a criticism."

"It's a criticism."

"It's an observation." Sophie heard herself and stopped. Started again, slower. "When I left my marriage I signed a separation agreement with eleven pages of provisions about who would attend whose parents' funerals. I read every line. I understood every line. And it changed nothing about the part that mattered. So when your wall text says consent is an ongoing negotiation, I want to know—negotiated by whom, with what consequences, and whether the people in the photographs have the same version of the story we sold to Bertrand."

Gabriel nodded slowly. He didn't look defensive. He looked like he was hanging a photograph—checking the level, deciding where the nail went.

"You want the workshop," he said.

"I didn't say that."

"You're describing one."

"I'm describing the problem."

"Sophie." He waited. "You're describing a workshop."

She exhaled. He'd been doing this for two months, taking the thing she'd said and holding it up until she either claimed it or disowned it. It was infuriating. It was the reason she was still at the table.

"Fine," she said. "I'm describing a workshop."

He reached for his bag, pulled the sketchbook out, and flipped past what looked like twelve pages of lighting diagrams to a blank one. He wrote at the top: PUBLIC CONSENT WORKSHOP.

"Wednesday."

"The deposition's Thursday."

"I know."

"You can't schedule a workshop the day before."

"Then Saturday." He wrote Saturday. Circled it. "I'll ask Anh."

"Ask Anh what?"

"Whether she'll co-lead. She's the one who first told me the releases were a problem. She said the signatures felt like receipts."

"She's a photographer."

"She's a subject." He underlined the word. "The workshop isn't about the law. It's about what you sign and what you don't, and what we should have asked before we asked for the form. You can do the legal part in ten minutes. She can do the rest."

Sophie looked at the page. His handwriting was small and precise and slightly left-leaning, the handwriting of a man who had been told his whole childhood to be careful.

"How many people?"

"Twenty. Thirty. Whoever comes. We put it on the community calendar."

"In French and English."

"Both." He wrote that down too. "And we invite Bertrand."

Sophie laughed once, short. "Absolutely not."

"Why? She's already writing about the gap."

"She'll write about us."

"She'll write about the show." Gabriel set the pen down. "You don't want her at the workshop because you don't want her at the workshop. That's fine. But don't pretend it's about the ethics."

There it was—the thing that had been sitting under the whole review. Sophie looked out the window. Sleet had started again, thin and horizontal, the kind that got under collars. She thought about the wall text and the forged signature and Maëlle's stairwell and every question she had learned to answer in the shape of a paragraph with a heading and a signature block. And she thought about Anh Trinh, who had stood in the corner of the opening and said nothing and then nodded.

"Invite her," Sophie said.

"You're sure."

"I'm not sure. Invite her anyway." She picked up the cold coffee and drank the last of it. "And I want a line added to the wall text."

Gabriel's pen was already moving.

"'A release was revoked and reconfirmed during installation; the exhibitors chose to open late rather than show work without a current signature.'"

He wrote it, read it back, didn't change a word. "It says we made a mistake."

"It says we noticed."

He tore the page out of the sketchbook and folded it twice and put it in his jacket. For a moment neither of them said anything, and the silence was comfortable, and Sophie became aware of the man in the puffer jacket turning a page of his newspaper, and of the fact that she had not once looked at her phone since Gabriel had answered his.

She looked now.

Six messages. Three from Anh Vu about the supplemental motion—she'd read those on the walk over. Two from the office. And one from Inés, sent an hour ago, with a photograph attached.

Sophie opened it.

It was the hands piece. Two pairs of hands on a table, one older, one younger, gripping and not gripping. It was hung on a white wall, lit from the left, and there was a label beside it, small and silver-edged.

Below the image, Inés had typed: *Hung this morning. Gabriel's assistant did the install. He knows.*

Sophie turned the phone face-down on the table, the way Gabriel's had been when she'd walked in.

"That was Inés," she said.

"What does she want?"

The café door opened and closed and let in a wedge of sleet. Sophie kept her hand flat on the phone.

"She wants to know if you and I are going to keep lying about the hands piece," she said. "Because as of this morning, it's in the show."

Gabriel went very still. Outside, the sleet came down.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 65: The Review · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads