The Exhibit of Us

Chapter 64: Opening Night

The community space smelled like fresh plaster and rented folding chairs. Sophie stood near the door with a stack of programs she'd reprinted twice overnight, the second run only four hours old, the ink still faintly chemical. Someone had taped a hand-lettered sign to the brick: TERMS OF CONSENT. Below it, in smaller marker, a question—Who gets to decide what a family looks like?

Anh Trinh arrived first, at 5:40, before the doors. He wore the same gray coat he'd worn at the deposition table, and he walked the length of the room without stopping, reading each wall label, the small typed paragraphs that named the subject, the year, the city. He stopped longest in front of a photograph of a woman holding two phone books like a scale. Then he moved on. He didn't look at Sophie. When he reached the end, he turned, found her across the room, and nodded once—barely a movement of the chin—then walked back out into the corridor to wait.

"What was that?" Gabriel asked, from behind the folding table where they'd stacked the release binders, all originals, all signed in ink.

"Nothing yet."

"Or everything."

"Or everything." She set the programs down. "Don't touch them. They're in order."

"I know they're in order. I alphabetized them."

"Doors."

He opened the doors at six.

They came slower than she'd feared and faster than she'd hoped. Maybe eighty people by seven, which for a first night in a borrowed space on a side street off Saint-Laurent was a crowd. Some were neighbors who'd walked past the tape for a week. Some were lawyers, three or four she recognized from the courthouse, one of whom looked at her the way you look at a colleague who's stepped out onto ice and is still deciding whether to say anything. One was a photographer from a small arts weekly, taking three pictures and leaving.

And the families came. Bertrand, who'd driven in from Longueuil with his brother, stood beside his own photo so consistently that Sophie stopped trying to move him along. The woman with the phone books—Nadia—had brought her daughter, eleven years old, who read her mother's wall label out loud twice. There was the father whose release Sophie had personally walked to his door at eleven o'clock the night before last. He stood with his arms crossed, not angry, just planted, like a man guarding something he'd agreed to loan and wanted back intact.

Maëlle arrived last, with her mother, and stood near the back, her hands in her coat pockets.

Gabriel gave his speech at seven-twenty. He didn't use a microphone; the space wasn't big enough. He stood by the table with the binders and said, "I want to thank the forty-one families whose images are in this room. They signed. They read every label. Some of them changed the text, and we changed the text. The exhibit is called Terms of Consent because the terms are the exhibit. That's the whole idea." He stopped. Looked down at the table. "I'm not going to thank anyone who funded this, because the families paid for it first, with their patience." A short silence, and then someone laughed—the good kind of laugh, the kind that releases a room. People drifted back to the photographs.

Sophie hadn't funded a thing; the grant had come through a foundation; Henri had backed the space in exchange for nothing he'd ever collected on. She watched Gabriel move from Bertrand to Nadia, not charming anyone, just present, the way he was in the studio at three in the morning when the prints weren't drying fast enough.

At eight, Maëlle spoke. She stood by her own photograph—the one that had nearly been forged—and said she had agreed two days ago, for the first time, and that agreeing had not been the point; the point was that someone had asked her twice. "I said yes because they stopped," she said. "Most people don't stop." Her mother cried quietly. Bertrand, God bless him, was the first to applaud, and the room followed.

Afterward, Anh Trinh came back in. He found Sophie near the programs and stood beside her, both of them facing the wall, not each other.

"You stopped the show," he said.

"I stopped it for a day."

"You stopped it." He watched Bertrand explaining something to Nadia's daughter, bending down, his hands doing the shape of a frame. "Vachon's supplemental motion is still live. The deposition is Thursday."

"I know."

"Your client will hear about tonight. Some version of it."

"I know that too." She turned. "Anh. Did you come to see the exhibit or to see me?"

"I came to see whether the thing you filed the waiver for was real." He let that sit. "The waiver is real. That's all I'm saying." Then he did something she had never seen him do: he almost smiled, badly, like a man using a muscle he'd forgotten. He walked out without saying goodbye.

Henri never came. Sophie caught herself checking the door until quarter to nine, then stopped checking, and noticed she'd stopped, and the not-checking felt like a small inheritance she'd paid for.

Gabriel found her at nine-fifteen, when the last neighbors were lingering over the wine. "You okay?"

"I'm waiting for something bad to happen."

"Give it time."

"That's not comforting."

"It's not supposed to be." He took her empty cup and set it on the table. "Nadia's daughter asked me what a curator does and I said I keep promises and she said that's not a job, that's just being a person."

"She's eleven. She's right."

"I know she's right."

The doors closed at ten. They stacked chairs. Sophie kept the release binders on the table until the last light was off, then carried them out to her car herself, refusing help, which Gabriel allowed because he understood that the carrying was the point.

She turned on her phone in the driver's seat. It had been off since six. Forty-one notifications, mostly the group chat with the studio assistants, mostly exclamation marks, one from her mother—Was it well attended?—and three from Anh Vu, the earliest sent at seven-fourteen.

The first: Vachon's counsel wants to depose you personally, not just G. About the waiver timing.

The second: I told them the waiver is valid. They don't care. They want the optics.

The third: Call me tomorrow morning. Before you read the review.

Sophie stared at the screen. She scrolled up. There it was, between the second and third messages, a link posted by Inés at 9:52—an hour ago, the arts weekly's site, the review filed early, pushed live the same night as the opening. She hadn't looked at Inés's photo. She hadn't read the review.

Gabriel knocked on the passenger window. She rolled it down. He leaned in, cold air coming off him, his tie loose.

"What," he said, reading her face.

She turned the phone so he could see the headline in the blue light. The byline. The first line of the lede, cut off by the screen edge.

"Do you want to read it alone?" he asked.

"No," she said. "But Tuesday you might want to."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 64: Opening Night · The Exhibit of Us · Lumen Reads