The house was still dark when they pulled up to the curb, the streetlamp on the corner buzzing its familiar dim orange. Viola had the journals in her bag and Camille's small brass key on a cord around her neck, and she sat in the passenger seat for a count of ten before she opened the door.
Sebastian killed the engine. He didn't ask if she was ready. She liked that about him now, the way he'd learned when the question would cost more than silence.
They let themselves in the front door. The hall smelled of dust and the sweet rot of the roses she'd forgotten to change. She didn't stop for the roses. She went straight up the stairs, past the landing, to the second-floor door with the flaking paint, and turned the brass knob.
The nursery looked the way she'd left it — the iron crib, the faded mural of peacocks, the dresser with the missing drawer pull. And the wall. Forty-odd photographs in frames of every shape, organized in no order she could see, some silver, some gilded, some bare wood.
She set her bag on the floor and took out the journals. Laid them open on the wicker chair. Turned to the third journal, the one where Camille's handwriting tightened, grew smaller, as if the words themselves were trying to hide.
*She kept a picture for every one of them. Not their faces — they couldn't give their faces. A picture of something else. A postcard. A bridge. A cat. Something that was theirs. When she had their story, she would take the picture down and put it back up, and no one ever knew.*
Viola looked at the wall again.
"Not decoration," she said.
Sebastian came to stand beside her. He read the open journal over her shoulder, and she heard his breath change.
"The photographs are an index," he said. "One picture, one woman."
Viola stepped to the first frame — a sepia postcard of a bridge over a bayou, curling at the corners. She lifted it off its nail. The backing paper was loose, and she slid a fingernail under it.
The microcassette dropped into her palm.
It was the size of her thumb. A small white label ran along its spine in her mother's hand: *C.B. — 3/14/86.*
She looked at Sebastian. His face had gone very still, the way it did when he was doing arithmetic he didn't want to finish.
"Count them," he said.
She didn't need to count them. She'd counted them the first week she moved in, lying in bed at night, hating a wall she couldn't explain. She'd never known why her mother had hung exactly that many, exactly that way, in a room no child had used since 1987.
Every frame held one. The postcard of the bayou. The photograph of a grey cat on a porch rail. A bus schedule, neatly folded. A child's crayon drawing of a house. A matchbook from a diner in Baton Rouge. Forty-one frames on the wall. Forty-one cassettes.
They worked in silence. Sebastian took the high rows; Viola took the low, where she'd once knelt as a child, and her hands remembered the cool floor and the smell of dust. Each backing slid off with the same soft rasp. Each cassette clicked into her palm, light as a tooth. She laid them in a shoebox she found in the closet, the same kind of shoebox Deborah had kept under her bed in Houston, and the echo of that went through her like a wire.
By the fortieth frame her hands were shaking. Sebastian noticed. He took the box from her, set it on the crib rail, and put one palm flat against the small of her back.
"Last one," he said.
The last frame on the bottom row was empty. Just glass, no photograph behind it, the nail tilted. She touched it, and the whole frame swung on its wire, and behind it, wedged between backing board and wall, was a cassette with no label at all.
She knew before she pulled it free.
"One more," she said. "Unlabeled."
She set it on top of the others and they stood looking at the box. Forty-one tapes. The nursery had never been a nursery to her mother, not really — the crib was the first thing Camille had bought when she found out she was pregnant, and then Viola had been born and taken, and the room had been empty ever since. Empty except for this. Empty except for four decades of women, each one a photograph, each one a story nobody had been allowed to tell.
"She kept their pictures so she could keep them at all," Viola said. "Faces would have ruined them. This was how she remembered who she was protecting."
Sebastian pulled the cassette player out of his shoulder bag — the one he'd bought at a gas station on the drive back from Houston, the same model as the one in the attic, because they hadn't wanted to rely on a machine that had been sitting in heat for thirty years. He set it on the dresser.
They didn't have time for forty-one tapes. They had a probate hearing in thirty days and a demolition clause that had been counting down for sixty. But Viola's hands had already reached for the first one, the one labeled *3/14/86*, because something in the date pulled at her.
She pressed play.
The voice that came out of the little speaker was a woman's, young, flat, not much older than Viola was now. She didn't introduce herself. She said: *He said if I told anyone he would find my brother. My brother is twelve. I'm telling this to Camille because Camille said she would keep it where no one could get it.*
A pause. Then: *His name is Jules Fontaine.*
Viola stopped the tape. Started the next. A different woman, different cadence, softer. *He kept me in a room on Magazine Street for nine days. He said I was his. My name is —* and then a name, spoken once, and then she moved on as if saying it had cost more than the rest of the tape combined.
They played them in order, one after another, fast-forwarding through silence. Each woman had a name that got spoken once. Some of them cried and then came back and kept talking. One of them laughed the whole way through, a high tight laugh, and it was worse than the crying. Every single tape ended the same way: *I am telling this to Camille.*
Sebastian sat down on the floor with his back against the dresser. "Every one of them names Fontaine," he said. "Every one. This is the evidence from 1994. This is what the hearing was supposed to be about."
"She didn't just record them," Viola said. "She collected witnesses. Before there was a hearing. Before anyone would listen. She built the case in this room for eight years and then she — "
She stopped. Because the last tape was still sitting there, unlabeled.
Sebastian looked up at her. "You don't have to hear it."
"Yes I do."
She put it in. Pressed play.
Camille's voice. There was no mistaking it — Viola had spent fifty-six chapters of her life listening for that voice on answering machines, in dreams, in the sound of her own throat remembering it. It was the same voice from the music box, only slower now, and she could hear the pen in the background, tapping against something. A desk.
*My name is Camille Marchand,* her mother said. *I'm recording this in case I don't get to tell it myself. Viola, if you're hearing this, I need you to know I did not leave you because I loved you less.*
A pause. The pen tapped twice.
*I left because a man named Jules Fontaine put his hand around my throat in a parking lot on Magazine Street in 1987 and told me he would find you wherever I hid you and he would take you the way he took those other women. And I believed him. So I gave you to your grandmother and I left, and I have spent every day since making sure the day I could come back would also be the day somebody would listen.*
*The tapes are here. All of them. In the pictures. If you're hearing this, take them to the district attorney, not to any lawyer in this city. I am going to see her tomorrow no matter what it costs.*
The tape ended. The little reels stopped turning.
Viola stood in the empty nursery with her mother's voice still in the air, forty-one names, forty-one women, every one of them protected by a voice that had been disciplined out of two pieces of thin plastic.
She thought of Sebastian's office. Of the hearing on day eighty-nine. Of the demolition. Of the man who had sat in her drawing room on day one and told her he was only protecting the family's interests.
"It was never an attic," she said. "It was never the stairs, either. It was the pictures. It was always the pictures."
Sebastian stood up and picked up the shoebox with both hands, carefully, the way she would lift a piece of porcelain.
"We can't take these to Prejean," he said. "We can't take them to my office."
"We don't take them anywhere," Viola said. "We count them. And we find every one of those women still alive to say her name."
She looked at the wall of empty frames, forty-one photographs waiting to go back up.
And outside, on the street, a car door shut.