The House on Saint Claude

Chapter 59: The Tapes

They worked through the night.

Viola took the photographs down one at a time, setting each frame face-up on the nursery floor in the order she removed it, and Sebastian caught the microcassettes as they slid free. Forty-one women. Forty-one small rectangles of gray plastic, each labeled in her mother's hand with a name and a date. The earliest was 1987. The last was 1993.

By three in the morning they had stopped talking. There was too much to say and no way to say any of it with words, so they said it with their hands instead — Viola peeling tape from the backings, Sebastian stacking the cassettes in columns of ten on the windowsill where the streetlight could reach them. Somewhere below, the house ticked and settled like a body in a long fever.

"Say the last one again," Sebastian said.

Viola picked it up. The label read: *Fontaine, J. — corroborating — 3/94.*

"Corroborating," she said. "It's not just testimony. It's corroboration. She wasn't going to the grand jury to tell them what happened to her. She was going to tell them what happened to all of them."

Sebastian rubbed his eyes with the heels of both hands. He had taken off his tie hours ago and it lay curled on the floor like something shed. "Forty-one women go on the record against Jules Fontaine. Circumstantial on any one count, but together—" He stopped. Started again. "Together you don't beat it. You don't beat forty-one sworn statements. You settle. You plead. You go away for a very long time."

"She never got there."

"No." He looked at the cassettes. "Because somebody knew they were in the house."

Viola had been circling it all night without saying it, the way you circle a hole in the floor you don't want to fall into. Now she said it. "Prejean's father was the defendant. And sixty days after my mother disappeared, the hearing never happened, and the house sat there with the evidence inside it, and nobody ever came for it."

Sebastian's face did something complicated. "Nobody ever came for it," he repeated, "because they couldn't find it. Not until Camille's daughter moved in and started tearing the walls apart."

"She was smart," Viola said. "She hid them where nobody would look. But she couldn't hide them forever. Sixty days, Sebastian. That's the clock. Sixty days from the hearing and the estate goes into probate and the house can be sold, and whoever buys it can do anything they want."

"Demolish it."

"Demolish it." She sat back against the wall. "You don't have to find evidence to destroy it. You just have to buy the building and tear it down."

They sat with that for a while. Below them the house was very quiet, as if it were listening to them the way it listened to everything, and somewhere in the plaster a pipe knocked twice and went still.

It was almost dawn when the front door opened.

Neither of them heard a knock. There was no bell. Just the sound of the latch turning and footsteps in the foyer, unhurried, familiar — a man who had been in this house many times and knew which floorboards were honest.

Viola was on her feet with the letter opener in her hand before she knew she'd picked it up. Sebastian moved past her, down the hall, and she followed him to the top of the stairs.

Nathaniel Crane stood in the foyer with his hat in his hands.

He looked up at them. His face was gray in the early light, and he looked older than he had at any point in the two months Viola had known him — not tired exactly, but eroded, the way a stone looks after a long time in water.

"I know what time it is," he said. He didn't raise his voice. "I know I'm not supposed to be here."

Sebastian had gone still in that particular way lawyers go still. "You have a key."

"I've had a key for thirty years. I'm the volunteer who's kept this house standing since your mother—" he looked at Viola, "—since your mother didn't come home. Somebody had to."

"That's not an answer."

"It's the beginning of one." Crane came up the stairs slowly, one hand on the rail. At the top he stopped, taking in the open nursery door, the strip of photographs on the floor, the columns of tapes on the sill. He didn't look surprised. He looked like a man seeing the end of a long arithmetic.

"Forty-one," he said quietly.

"Forty-one," Viola said. "You know about them."

"I guessed. About a week after I met you. I found one behind a photograph in the front parlor and put two and two together, and I've been trying to get to the rest before Prejean's people did." He drew a breath. "Your mother told me, once, before you were born — she said if she ever disappeared, there was something in this house that mattered more than she did. She didn't tell me where. She said that part was for you."

"Then why didn't you tell me?" Viola's voice came out harder than she meant it to. "Six weeks. You sat across from me six times and told me to read the clause and sign the deed and go home."

"Because Prejean's firm hired me six years ago to document the house for the estate. When the ninety days started, they sent me here specifically. My instructions were to inventory the nursery and remove its contents before the hearing." He met her eyes. "There's a manila envelope in my car with a pre-signed letter from Prejean authorizing the removal. I've had it in the glove box since March. I've been stalling. That's what the six visits were. That's what 'it's boilerplate' was."

Sebastian's jaw worked. "So Prejean sent you to destroy the evidence."

"Prejean sent me to remove some boxes from a dead woman's nursery. He never said the word evidence. He never said the word tape. He's a careful man." Crane set his hat on the banister. "But I've known what was in this house since 1994. I was on the volunteer list, Mr. Beck. Not a lawyer, not a witness. Transport. I drove three women to that courthouse from this very doorway, and they went in and they told their stories and nothing ever happened to Jules Fontaine because the case died when your mother didn't reach the stand." He looked at Viola again, and his voice was not steady now. "I've been carrying that for thirty years. I would like, before I die, to carry something else."

The silence stretched. Down in the street a garbage truck groaned and moved on.

"You want to testify," Sebastian said.

"I want to testify. I can put Fontaine's men in the lobby of the courthouse on the morning of the fourteenth. I can tell them who gave the instruction. I can put Prejean in the room in 1994 — he was his father's errand boy, he was eighteen, and he was there."

Viola's hands had gone cold. "You saw him."

"I saw him."

Sebastian looked at her. This was the moment — she knew it, the way you know the moment a surface is about to give — and she could see him weighing it, the careful lawyer's calculus, and she could also see something underneath that wasn't calculus at all. "If he testifies," Sebastian said, slowly, "we have the tapes and we have a corroborating witness, and the hearing becomes something else entirely."

"If he's telling the truth."

"If he's lying, we lose everything, and we lose it on the record."

Crane said nothing. He stood there and let them look at him, which was, Viola had to admit, the only thing a man could do.

She thought about her mother's last journal entry. *I am going to see her tomorrow no matter what it costs.* And she thought about the fact that her mother had walked into this house, that night, and no one had ever seen her again — and that the tapes had never been found, because the one man who knew roughly where they were had spent thirty years keeping the house standing instead of burning it.

"You drove them," she said.

"I drove them."

"You waited outside."

"Until the last one went in. Then I went home. It was the day before your mother—" He stopped. "I went home, and the next morning I heard she was gone, and I closed the shop at noon and drove around this city for eleven hours looking for her, and I never stopped, in a way. I never stopped."

Viola set the letter opener down on the sill next to the tapes.

"I don't trust you," she said.

"I wouldn't trust me either."

"But my mother put a key in your hand, and you didn't use it to hurt her. That's the only character witness I've got." She looked at Sebastian. "Put him on the list."

Sebastian nodded once. "I'll need a written statement tonight. Everything you just said. Everything you can prove."

Crane picked up his hat. "I'll have it by noon."

"And you should know," Viola said, before she lost the nerve, "that when this is over, and if we win, and if I still own this house — you don't get a key anymore."

For the first time, Crane almost smiled. "Fair."

He was halfway down the stairs when Viola said, "Mr. Crane."

He turned.

"The glove box," she said. "The letter. Bring that too."

His face changed — she couldn't read it exactly, but it wasn't reluctance. It was something closer to relief, the look of a man setting down something he'd been holding far too long.

"Tomorrow," he said, and let himself out.

The door closed. The house settled. Sebastian turned to her, already speaking, already drafting the list in his head, and Viola was looking past him at the nursery, at the photographs on the floor, at forty-one gray cassettes standing in the early light like a small, patient congregation.

Something in the house changed just then. The air pressure, very slightly, the way it does when a window is opened in another room. Not a sound. Not yet.

Sebastian stopped mid-sentence.

"Did you hear that?"

"No," Viola said, and waited, and heard nothing, and told herself it was only the morning coming up over Saint Claude — the pipes, the plaster, the old house breathing.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 59: The Tapes · The House on Saint Claude · Lumen Reads