The charter boat was called the *Mistress of Nothing*, which Fenn had taken as a bad joke until the harbourmaster in Oban confirmed it with a straight face. She'd spent the crossing wedged against a rail that had been painted so many times the bolts had disappeared, watching the sea do something she didn't have a word for yet. Not oil. Thicker than oil, and moving wrong — a slow greasy scum that the bow parted like skin, closing behind them without a ripple.
Now it was dead mackerel.
They floated belly-up in the harbour mouth, hundreds of them, silver going grey in the flat morning light. Gulls stood on them. That was the thing Fenn couldn't stop looking at. Not circling, not diving. Standing. The birds had given up treating them as food.
'Dinna trach that,' said the ferryman, without turning from the wheel. His name was Iain and he had not said a word since Kerrera. 'Wi' your hand, I mean. It gets in the creases.'
'What is it?'
'It's the bay.'
'That's not an answer.'
'No,' Iain agreed, and throttled back.
The engine dropped to a mutter, and Fenn heard the island before she saw it properly — the low grind of water over a slipway, wind through something that wasn't trees, the flat clang of a chain on a mast somewhere out of sight. Orasay came up out of the mist in pieces. A grey shoulder of rock. A scatter of houses with their backs to the weather. The lighthouse at the north head, banded white and ochre, standing on its own like a man who'd been told to wait and had kept waiting.
She had four days booked on the island and a shot list that ran to eleven pages. The lighthouse was decommissioned as of the new year. She'd pitched it as *a light going out*, which her commissioner in Glasgow had liked, and she'd liked it too, right up until the boat went into the slick.
The tide table lies this time of year,' Iain said, as though she'd asked.
'I've got the tables.'
'Aye. That's what I mean.' He spun the wheel, and the boat came round the end of the pier. 'Mind your feet.'
She was still working out what that meant when the boat kissed the wall and a woman was there, standing on the wet stone with both hands out, as if she'd been waiting an hour and had decided not to mind.
'There she is,' the woman said. 'There she is.'
Fenn got her bag up onto the pier first, because it had the camera in it, and then took the offered hands and let herself be hauled. The woman was in her sixties, in a red waterproof that had been red for a very long time, and she held on a beat after the hauling was done.
'You'll be frozen,' she said. 'Iain, have you no kettle on that boat? He's no kettle on that boat. Come up out of the wind.'
'I'm—'
'You've the look of the photographs,' the woman said, pleased, and put a set of keys in Fenn's hand before Fenn could get the sentence finished. Three keys on a brass ring. A big one, two small ones, all of them cold. 'The big one's the tower — it sticks, you give it a lift before you turn it, and dinna fight it, it wins. The middlin one's the store, the wee one's the gate. Gate's rotten. I've told him.'
'You've told who?'
The woman stopped.
Fenn said, carefully, 'I think you've got the wrong person.'
'You're no Callum's girl?'
'I'm Fenn Adair. I'm here for the film.'
The woman looked at her. Her face didn't do anything hostile; it did something worse, it did a slow, private recalculation, the way you'd look at a clock that had stopped at an unexpected time. Then it smoothed over entirely, and she smiled, and she said, 'Aye, well. Come up out of the wind anyway.'
'I'm not—'
'You'll want Morag. She's the one for the film.' She was already walking. 'Iain'll bring your gear. Iain. The lassie's gear.'
'Iain,' said Iain, from the boat.
Fenn stood on the pier with the keys in her fist and the dead fish turning below her and a wind coming off the north that went through her coat like it had a key of its own. Nine houses visible. Two cars. A telephone box that had been repainted so many times the word TELEPHONE had filled in and become a shape. Everything small, everything accounted for, everything already looking back at her.
She'd done this twenty times. In Donegal, in Newfoundland, in a fishing town in Chile where the whole crew had been adopted by a woman named Ana who still emailed her on her birthday. It was a thing that happened. You arrived with a camera and a deadline, and a place decided who you were, and usually you got paid to play along.
The keys were warm now from her hand.
She put them in her pocket.
The harbour road ran up between a Co-op the size of a garage and a kirk with a leaning gate. Fenn walked it with her bag on her shoulder and the water behind her, and by the time she'd gone two hundred yards she'd said good morning to four people and been told twice she'd brought the weather with her, once that she hadn't, and once — from a man with a dog who stopped dead in the road and stared — nothing at all.
The dog stared too.
She stopped at the top of the brae and looked back. The bay from up here was one flat sheet, dulled pewter, no break in it. It should have had a hundred birds on it. It had none. Down at the edge, where the burn came out under a little footbridge, there was a brown stain spreading into the sea, and she could see exactly where the burn had been.
She took out her phone and photographed it. The signal bar was empty. She photographed it anyway, and then she photographed the harbour, and then, because she thought she might as well start as she meant to go on, she photographed the mackerel.
'You'll not get the colour right,' said a voice behind her.
Fenn turned. A woman in a fleece and muddy wellingtons was leaning on the wall, maybe late forties, with a face that had decided to be friendly before it had decided whether to mean it.
'Get the colour right on what?'
'The water. Folk send it to the papers every year. Comes out silver, and silver doesnae get anyone out of bed.' She offered a hand. 'Morag Bàn. You'll be the director.'
'Fenn Adair. Yes.'
'Good,' said Morag, and there was something in it, some small easing of a muscle, that Fenn filed away without knowing yet why. 'You've met Effie, then.'
'The woman with the keys?'
'That's her. President of the hall committee, treasurer of the lifeboat, and she's never once been wrong about a person.' Morag looked at her steadily. 'I'd have said that was a compliment.'
'She thinks I'm Callum's fiancée.'
'Aye,' said Morag. 'I'd heard.'
'Heard from where? I've been on the island eleven minutes.'
'Twelve,' said Morag. 'Effie texted the group. Come on, I'll show you the office, you'll want the key for the hall.'
They walked. Fenn said, 'Who's Callum MacLeòid?'
Morag glanced at her, sidelong, and took her time.
'The keeper,' she said, at last. 'Or he was. There's no keepers now, there's a trust and a man from Oban that comes out in the summer, but Callum stopped the light going out the first time and they never made him stop.' She shrugged. 'He's on the north end. He doesnae come in much in the winter.'
'And he has a fiancée.'
'He has a boat,' said Morag.
The office was a Portakabin behind the hall with a ramp that had been swept recently and a noticeboard by the door advertising a ceilidh in November, a yoga class, and a missing spaniel, gone since Tuesday, do not approach. Fenn read the spaniel notice twice while she waited for Morag to work the lock.
Inside it smelled of toner and damp coats. There was a desk, a kettle, a filing cabinet, and a poster on the wall of the bay as it had been — she could tell it was the bay because of the shape of the headland, but the water in the photograph was another colour entirely. Another substance.
'It's a braw photograph,' Morag said, catching her looking. 'Nineteen ninety-six.'
'It's the same view.'
'It is.'
Fenn set her bag down and did what she'd come for. They talked logistics: the hall, the hours of light, the fact that the tower was a listed structure and there was a form for the form, permits for the drone, a man called Donald who would take her out to the north head if the sea allowed and would not if it didn't, and either way wouldn't be hurried. It took forty minutes. Morag was good at it — sharp, unsentimental, kept a pen in her hair and forgot it was there.
Towards the end Fenn said, 'The fish in the harbour.'
'Uh-huh.'
'That's not normal.'
'No.'
'Is anyone testing the water?'
Morag put the pen down.
'You've been here twelve minutes,' she said. 'You get four days. Shoot your lighthouse, director.'
'I'm asking a question.'
'Aye, and there's a fortnight of forms behind that question, and the office is shut from Friday.' She said it flatly, no apology in it, and then she did something odd — she stood, went to the window, and checked the harbour mouth, the way you'd check a sky. Whatever she saw, she stood there a moment longer than she needed to.
Fenn said, 'What's out there?'
'Lunch,' said Morag, turning back, all briskness. 'You'll eat at the hotel. Tell them Effie sent you.' She held the door. 'And director — the tide tables. Dinna trust the printed ones. Ask Iain.'
'Iain told me the same thing.'
'Then it's true,' said Morag, and waited for her to leave.
Outside, the light had shifted. The whole bay had gone the colour of a wet slate, and out towards the north head there was a shape coming round the point — a small white boat, working against the swell, slow, with a man standing in the stern who did not look like a man in a hurry.
Fenn stood in the road with her bag on her shoulder and her hand in her pocket around three cold keys, and watched it come.
By the time she thought to get the camera out, he'd already seen her, and he'd cut the engine.