The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 12: Town Meeting

The village hall smelled of wet wool and floor polish. Fenn arrived early enough to watch the folding chairs go out in rows, and by half seven there were forty people in a room built for sixty, which on Orasay counted as a crowd.

Moira Bàn sat at the front table with the minutes book open and a pen she hadn't uncapped. Alastair from the heritage trust had come in his good jacket. Tam Ruadh stood by the radiator with his arms folded and his cap on, as though he'd only dropped in on his way somewhere and could leave whenever he liked. Mrs. MacRae of the Lochview had taken the seat nearest the door, handbag on her lap, smiling at everyone in a way that made Fenn's shoulders tighten.

Callum came in last and stood at the back wall. He didn't look at her.

Fenn had rehearsed it in the cottage with the kettle going, and it still came out clumsy for the first minute — the documentary, the grant, the reason she'd come, the reason she'd stayed. Then she stopped performing and said the thing plain.

"You'll have heard the burn runs brown at the mouth. You'll have smelled it. I've got a jar of it in my kitchen and a lab in Glasgow that will run it for free if I ask. What I want is to film your testimony. Not interviews on a sofa. You, standing at the water's edge, saying what you've seen. That's how the film ends. It's the strongest thing it can be."

For a moment there was only the hiss of the radiator.

Then Tam Ruadh laughed, one short bark, and uncrossed his arms.

"About bloody time," he said. "I'll say it on camera, I'll say it twice. My grandfather took saithe out of that bay, my father took saithe, I take what's left. Fifteen years ago I'd fill the hold by noon. Now I'm steaming to the far side of the Mull to find a shoal. You want to know what's killed it? Ask the man who signs the cheques for the boats that anchor out there. Ask him to stand at the water's edge too."

"That's not—" Mrs. MacRae began, and then smiled, and started again more gently. "That's not quite fair, Tam, and you know it. MacVane put in the pontoons. Without the pontoons there's no pier, and without the pier there's no ferry berth in weather, and without that there's no Lochview. You're not biting the hand, you're biting the whole arm off."

"I'm not biting anything. I'm stating facts."

"You're naming a sponsor."

"I'm naming a ship."

"All right." Fenn stepped in before the room could split down that line and lose her. "I'm not asking anyone to name anyone tonight. I'm asking for permission to film. Six people, eight, however many want to stand up. If that's two, I'll take two."

Alastair cleared his throat. "The trust's position is neutral. We'd want it minuted that we're neutral."

"Noted," Moira said, and wrote it, and still didn't take the cap off her pen.

"Ian Beag's got the creel boat," Tam said. "He'll stand. And Catrìona at the school, she's been taking the bairns down to look at the winkles and there's nothing living on that shore, she'd say it. And I'll say it myself. That's three before I've finished my tea."

Fenn's pulse kicked. Three names, just like that. She kept her face still.

"And who else?" she said, to the room.

Nobody moved. A chair creaked somewhere at the back. A woman near the window examined her own cuff.

Then someone said, "My Dougie won't," and a man at the side said, "I've the boat survey due in September," and another said, quietly, to the person beside him, "My brother-in-law works the terminal, so."

Mrs. MacRae let the silence sit for exactly as long as suited her, and then said, "I'm not against the film. I want that minuted, Fenn, I'm not against it — I think it's a lovely idea and the island should be proud. I'd simply like us to be certain of our facts before we stand on a shore with a camera and say a company's name into it. Because once it's said, it's said, and it's not just us that pays. It's the pontoons. It's the winter fuel. It's Ewan's place at the — well. You'll know better than I do."

She hadn't raised her voice. She hadn't looked at Callum either. She didn't need to. Half the room turned to the back wall anyway, casual, quick, the way you glance at a person who's been named without being named, and Fenn watched it happen and felt the floor of the hall go thin under her, like ice over a channel.

Callum said nothing. He stood with his hands at his sides and his jaw set and he looked at a point on the wall above Moira's head, and that was worse than a no, worse than shouting. Fenn had heard him argue a spring tide through a broken radio. He could clear a room with six words. He gave it nothing.

"I think," Moira said, uncapping the pen at last, "we should take this to the next meeting. Two weeks. People can think on it."

"Seconded," said Alastair.

"I'd like a vote on the principle," Fenn said. "Tonight. Anyone who wants to stand on that shore with me, hands up."

Three hands went up. Tam's, immediately. A woman near the door, hand half-raised, then firm. Then, after a long moment, the woman from the school, Catrìona, with her mouth set.

Four. Fenn counted them and made herself not count the rest.

"Not a vote, then," Moira said. "A show of interest. Minuted."

"And the postponement?"

"Carried," Alastair said, and Fenn heard the room exhale, relieved, all at once, forty people let off a hook, and knew she had lost something she hadn't even been able to name coming in.

They spilled out into the car park together, and it broke up the way island gatherings do, in twos, in clusters, in engines turning over and headlights sweeping the gorse. Fenn stood by her car with her notebook out.

Tam came past first, hands in pockets. "Ian Beag, and Catrìona, you've got. I'll bring the boat round to the burn mouth whenever you say, and you can film her dragging through that scum so folk can see what's on the hull."

"Tam. Thank you."

"Don't thank me. Thank the man that stopped the saithe." He stopped, and looked back at the hall, and spat onto the gravel with real precision. "You'll have noticed our keeper didn't say a word."

"I noticed."

"Aye." He walked off into the dark.

Catrìona caught her arm briefly as she passed and said, fast and low, "Tuesday after school. The shore below the schoolhouse. Bring the jar." Then she was gone, into a car with two bairns asleep in the back.

Fenn wrote: *Tam — boat. Catrìona — Tuesday, school shore. Ian Beag — through Tam.* Three names, the way she'd wanted. She looked at the page and it felt like a very thin sheet of paper to hold up against a whole island.

The hall lights went out one by one. Mrs. MacRae's car pulled away and paused beside her, window down.

"Fenn. Truly. I hope it goes well for you." A smile, warm, practised. "And I hope you know what you're doing with that jar. We've had a long time to learn what we live on."

She drove off.

Moira came out last, sorting keys. Fenn took a step toward the lighthouse track and Moira said, "He walked home."

"I know."

"Fenn." Moira's voice was flat. "Tonight took him a long way down. He'll not thank you for the silence either."

"He didn't have to be silent."

"No," Moira said. "He didn't." And got into her car.

Fenn drove the coast road with the window down and the smell of the bay coming in over the fields, that diesel sweetness she now knew by name, faint and everywhere, like something spilled in the next room. Three names. A postponement. A man at the back of a hall who had let her stand alone with a jar of water in her kitchen, and who had done it in front of forty people, and who had done it, she understood with a slow cold click somewhere behind her sternum, on purpose, and for her benefit and his own, both at once.

The gale warning was up for the morning. She got back to the cottage, put the jar on the sill where the light would catch it, and sat down at her laptop to write to the lab.

Her phone buzzed before she'd opened the mail.

Ewan. *it had a pocket. blue inside. same as the other one.*

Then, before she could answer: *can we talk tomorow not here*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 12: Town Meeting · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads