The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 14: The First Correct Attempt

The council offices in Stornoway occupied a converted school, and Fenn sat in the waiting area under a framed photograph of the building's original pupils, all of them squinting against a wind that had been blowing since 1911. She had the correction form on her knee. Four pages, three of them guidance notes, one of them asking her to state, in her own hand, the nature of the error.

She had written: *I am not, and have never been, engaged to Callum MacLeòid. I am not a resident of Orasay. My name appears on the subsidy claim in error.*

The clerk called her through at ten past eleven. His name was Donald MacAulay and he had the particular patience of a man who had spent thirty years explaining forms to people who had crossed an ocean to argue with them.

"You'll want to be careful with the wording," he said, turning the form around to face himself. "You've put 'in error.'"

"Because it is one."

"Aye. But the claim itself states that the household consists of two named adults. If your name is in error, the claim was wrong in April. It was wrong the April before that." He tapped the page. "The subsidy's paid quarterly. If we correct your name, we open the whole file. Every quarter. Four years of them."

Fenn looked at the guidance notes. "It's a form."

"It's a form that starts an audit." Donald leaned back. "I'm not telling you not to file it. I'm telling you what filing does. The review goes to the mainland. They'll want to see the occupancy, the residency tests, the care arrangements. They'll want to speak to Mr. MacLeòid. They'll want to speak to the boy."

"Ewan."

"His placement's tied to the household being a household. If the household's not compliant, the support stops while they investigate. That's not me being cruel, that's the process. It stops on the day the review opens, not the day it concludes."

Fenn set her pen down. Outside, a ferry was sounding somewhere out past the harbour wall, the noise arriving late and flat.

"How long's an investigation?"

"Three months if it's clean. Longer if it isn't." He slid a second form across the desk. "This is the one you actually want if you're just trying to get your name off. It's a change-of-circumstances notification. It doesn't trigger the review."

"Why didn't you say that first?"

"Because I've been doing this long enough to know when someone's trying to fix a name and when someone's trying to fix the truth." He said it without unkindness. "Which is it?"

Fenn didn't answer. She took the second form and read it. It was one page. *I wish to notify the department that the circumstances described in the above-referenced claim have changed.* Tick. Sign. Date.

She could do that in ninety seconds. Her name would come off. The claim would continue, Callum would keep the cottage, Ewan would keep the £840, and the burned tidal log would stay burned, and the subsidy paperwork with both their signatures on it would become a thing no one had ever seen.

"The lamp's being decommissioned," she said.

"So I've heard."

"There's a book. The previous keeper's tidal log. It had the original signed paperwork in it. Callum burned it before I arrived."

Donald's face didn't move. He had the clerk's gift of letting a statement land without picking it up.

"If it was burned," he said, "then it's Mr. MacLeòid's word against—what?"

"Mine. And a boy's, who'd repeat Callum's story if anyone asked him officially. And a gap on a shelf."

"Then it's no one's word against no one's." He turned the correction form back toward her. "You understand the position you're in. If you file this, you've got no document and a four-year claim that suddenly doesn't add up. They'll ask why. He'll say he made a clerical error. It'll be his word against a piece of paper he didn't write."

"And the paper wins."

"The paper always wins. That's the whole trouble with paper." Donald stood, went to the window, and looked out at the same grey water she'd filmed at dawn. "I'll tell you what I know, off the record, as a man whose sister lives on Orasay. There's the bank every second household on that island uses. There's the haulage. There's the pontoon at the harbour that got rebuilt for nothing. Nobody local asks where it comes from because the answer's always the same and the answer's always fine."

"MacVane."

"I didn't say that." He sat back down. "I said whatever you file, you should know what it costs before you cost it. Not after."

She walked out with both forms in her bag, and stood in the car park for a long time with the wind taking her hair sideways, and did not drive to the post office.

She drove north instead, past the turn for the ferry, and stopped at a lay-by where the moor ran down to a shoreline of black rock and the water in the bay was doing the thing she'd filmed that morning — the slow orange crawl of a vessel that had come eleven hundred metres closer than it had any business being.

She had the sample in the cool box on the back seat. She had Ewan's nine-year chart in a tube in the footwell, wrapped in a towel. She had the library book in her bag. She had, altogether, more evidence than she had ever assembled for a film, and none of it was admissible to a department that only recognised forms.

Ishbel rang while she sat there.

"Where are you?"

"North of town."

"Did you file it?"

"Not yet."

"Fenn." A pause. "I've had a call from the production company. The commissioning editor's seen the dailies. She's pleased. She asked specifically about the harbour footage."

"There isn't any harbour footage."

"There's the pontoon footage. From the drone. The one with the MacVane logo on the crane barge."

"That's a wide shot of a harbour."

"It's a wide shot of a harbour with the funder's logo in it, which is what she likes. She wants a sequence on the regeneration. The pontoons, the new moorings, the bit where the town came back to life." Ishbel's voice was careful, which was how Fenn knew she was delivering someone else's words. "They'd like you to shoot it this week."

"They'd like me to shoot an advert."

"They'd like you to shoot the thing they paid for, which is a film about a light going out, and which also happens to keep you in a camera and a sound recordist and a boat."

Fenn watched the vessel on the water. It had a white superstructure and an orange hull and it was doing nothing wrong. That was the problem with it. Nothing it did was ever anything wrong.

"I'll call you," she said, and hung up.

She got to the lighthouse at four. Callum's van wasn't there. Ewan was on the wall by the gate with a paperback and a jumper over his knees, and he looked up at her the way he always did, checking her hands first, to see what she'd brought.

"The form," she said.

"You filed it."

"No."

He frowned. "Because of the review."

"Donald told you?"

"Donald's my mum's cousin. He rang the cottage." Ewan shut the book on his finger. "He said if you file it, they'll take the money off us while they look into it."

"That's what he said to me too."

"And then he said, if you don't file it, you're a liar."

Fenn sat down on the wall beside him. The tide was out and the smell off the rocks was low and green and clean, which it wasn't, further round.

"For three years I made films about things that were already decided," she said. "Somebody had already looked at the water and written the report. I turned up with a camera and made the report look like a story. This is the first time I've been standing where the report starts."

"So you'll file it."

"I don't know."

"That's a stupid answer." He said it without heat. "You either do it or you don't."

"Then I don't know if I'm doing it."

Ewan opened the book again, then closed it. "I showed you the chart," he said. "That was the first time I showed it to anybody. Nine years. I said you could film it if you were right about all of it." He looked at her levelly. "If you don't file it, you're not right about any of it, and I want the chart back."

Fenn was still holding the correction form in her bag. One page of a four-page set, guidance notes attached, a space at the bottom for a signature and a date.

"Ewan. The book. Did it have a card pocket?"

"No," he said. "I keep telling you. It had a card pocket."

"Say it again."

"It had a card pocket. Blue, with a white edge. It was the same blue as the boat." He said it patiently, as if the patience were the point. "You asked me that in the text. I answered you in the text."

Fenn took out the library book and opened it to the back board. Empty. Glued flat to the spine, no pocket, no ghost of one. She laid it on the wall between them.

Ewan looked at it for a long moment. Then he said, "That's not the same book."

"It's the same title. Same author."

"Same title, same writer, different book." He put his finger on the back board. "The one I put back had a pocket because it was the one with the stamp sheet in it. It had dates in it all the way back to before I was born, and every time somebody borrowed it they stamped the card and left it in the pocket. That's a whole other copy. That means there were two."

Fenn sat very still. Two copies. One on the public shelf, whose lending slip was now in her name and dated in April. One somewhere else, issued to A. MacLeòid, with a pocket and a card and a chain of dates.

"Well," she said. "That's the first thing today that's actually helped."

"It doesn't help."

"It tells me where to look next."

Ewan looked past her, down the track, and his face changed. Fenn turned. Callum's van was coming up the road, slow, and it wasn't alone behind it; a second vehicle was following, one of the orange-hulled hire trucks off the mainland, and both of them were being let through the gate by a man Fenn had last seen sitting at the back of the village hall with his arms folded, saying nothing, when the room split over whether to let her film.

Callum got out. He looked at the form in her hand, and he didn't ask about it. He said, "Fenn. They've had a call from the council."

"About what?"

"About a correction request." His voice was flat. "Somebody filed one this morning. Stamped and entered."

"I didn't file anything."

"I know," Callum said. "That's the trouble. Somebody did it in your name."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 14: The First Correct Attempt · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads