The lab was a converted net loft above a chandlery in Oban, and it smelled of diesel and cold coffee and something faintly sweet underneath, like burnt sugar. Dr. Iona Sinclair had cleared a bench for Fenn by shoving a tangle of sampling tubes into a bucket.
"You want the good news or the chemistry?" Iona said, pulling the chromatograph printout from a tray.
"I want the chemistry."
"Right." Iona flattened the sheet with both palms. "You've got a pyrogenic PAH profile. Not the weathered background stuff you'd see from general harbour traffic. High-ring aromatics, and here—" her finger dropped to a cluster of peaks near the right margin, "—a marker compound. That's not crude. That's not fuel oil. That's a scrubber-water tracer."
Fenn kept her hands still on the bench. She'd learned, filming, that if you stayed very calm people kept talking, and that if you reached for anything too fast they stopped.
"Meaning?"
"Meaning someone's running a closed-loop scrubber system and dumping the wash water, or an open-loop system and lying about where the discharge goes. The marker's specific. It comes off the sorbent media in a particular make of unit." Iona tapped the printout. "I can tell you the bay isn't clean, and I can tell you it isn't clean in a way that has a signature. That's as far as I go without chain of custody."
The word sat between them. Fenn looked at the peaks. On the boat, her sample had been a bottle in a cool bag, and Ewan's chart a folded sheet in her jacket, and both had felt like small private things. Now they had a name. Scrubber discharge. It was the kind of fact that, once she said it out loud to the wrong person, would stop being hers.
"You took this where?" Iona said.
"Off the rocks at the south end."
"That's not an answer and you know it."
Fenn smiled at nothing. "It's the answer you'll get."
"Fenn." Iona pulled the stool round and sat, arms crossed. The printout lay between them like a hand of cards. "How long have I known you?"
"Twelve years."
"Twelve years, and I've never once asked you what you were doing. Because I know: you're the one with the camera, you're the one who goes out and comes back with the story. Fine. But this—" she gestured at the sheet, "—this is a regulatory sample. This is the sort of thing that goes to SEPA with a date, a time, a GPS fix and a signature on the bag. Instead it's in a lemonade bottle in a cool bag and my instrument's the only witness."
"There was a bottle. There was a bag."
"Was there a fix?"
Fenn didn't lie to Iona. That was the rule, the only rule that had survived twelve years and two continents. So she said nothing, which was its own answer.
Iona sat back. Above them, rain started on the corrugated roof, a slow irregular tap that made the room feel smaller and offshore. "And you've told the council? You've told the coastguard? Anyone who has to act on this?"
Fenn thought of the two forms in her bag, one page and four pages, folded in a coat pocket in Ardnasaig. She thought of Callum's hands on the kitchen table. She thought of the number 840.
"No," she said. "I haven't told anyone."
"Fenn."
"Not officially, no."
"Officially." Iona repeated the word like it was a hair in her mouth. "So unofficially there's a person, and officially there's a hole in the ground where the report should be. You know what you're asking me to hold."
"I'm not asking you to hold anything. I'm asking what it is."
"I've told you what it is." Iona stood and crossed to the little sink, turned the tap on and off again without using it. "It's the sort of finding that ends a company's licence or ends a scientist's career, depending on who's holding it when it lands. You don't put this in a documentary. You don't put it in a shot where a fisherman says 'aye, the water's turned.' You put it in a properly witnessed sample and you hand it to the people whose job it is."
"What if the people whose job it is are the ones paying?"
Iona went still. The rain kept up on the roof. From down in the chandlery someone laughed, a burst of it, then muffled.
"That's a different conversation," Iona said eventually.
"It's the same conversation. I just walked in the back end of it."
"Then say the front end."
Fenn looked at the printout again. The peaks were neat as a signature. She thought of Ewan standing on the south rocks in March, the wind coming off the burn mouth, a boy with a notebook, nine years of a chart nobody had asked for. She thought of what Ewan had said: if you don't file, you're not right about any of it. She thought of what Callum had said: fighting the correction means the audit might come anyway. There was a version of the next hour in which she said all of it out loud to Iona, and Iona, being Iona, would tell her to sign a statement and be done. That version was correct. It was also the version in which a man lost his brother's care and a dead woman's name got dragged through a Benefits Agency review.
"Sheep dip," Fenn said.
Iona turned around.
"On Islay, back in '17, a sampler I worked with found a spike near a farm outflow. Turned out to be sheep dip, not effluent. Whole story collapsed. I'm not putting this anywhere until I know what I'm actually holding."
"That is, genuinely, the least convincing thing you've ever said to me."
"I know."
"And it's still the most honest thing you've said in this room today." Iona came back to the bench, sat, and tore the printout along a fold. She handed Fenn the half with the marker peaks on it. "Take that. It's your sample, it's your peaks, it's not my letterhead. If you want my name on anything, you come back with a chain of custody and a proper container and we do it properly, and I'll stand behind it with my registration number on it."
"And if I don't."
"Then you and I have had a nice visit and no conversation ever happened."
Fenn folded the page into quarters and slipped it into the inside jacket pocket, against the chart. Two papers, both of them hers, both of them silent.
"Fenn." Iona had the chromatograph tray in her hand and wasn't looking at it. "Whatever this is, be careful who you hand it to. Scrubber tracers are traceable. People who run that kit are used to swimming in the waste. They keep lawyers for it."
"Noted."
"I'm serious. If you're going at a company, don't do it from a village where the company is the biggest employer, on a boat the company's chandlery fuelled, with a camera the company is paying for."
Fenn stopped at the door with her hand on the latch. Downstairs, the chandlery laugh happened again, just one man, going on with his day. She could feel the folded page through the coat, the two soft corners of it, and the marker compound was on it in a neat little cluster of peaks, and she had just told the only person who could put a registration number behind it that nothing had happened.
"It's not going at a company," she said. "It's just water."
"Water doesn't get a marker compound," Iona said. "Companies do."
Fenn walked out into the rain. Halfway down the hill toward the ferry slip the phone went in her pocket, and she stopped under a doorway and looked at it, and it was Ishbel, and the message was twelve words: regeneration sequence confirmed for Thursday, Callum wants to walk you round the site first. Fenn stood there in the Oban rain with the printout against her ribs and the chart folded under it and thought: Thursday. Two days. Two days to decide what she was holding, and who she was going to give it to, and whether the man who was going to walk her round the site was with her or on the other side of the lens.
She put the phone away without replying and started down to the boat, and it didn't occur to her until she was on the water that she had told Iona the truth about the sample and lied about everything else, and that somewhere between the two she had crossed a line she was only going to notice later.