Sorcha was mucking out the byre when Fenn found her, not that there was anything left to muck — the MacRaes had sold their last cow the year before, and the stall now held a rusted quad bike and forty-seven plastic tubs of something Fenn couldn't identify. The girl worked the scrape anyway, chasing old straw into a corner with a yard brush, and she didn't look up when Fenn's boots sounded on the concrete.
"You're the film one," Sorcha said. "Moira's told me. She's not pleased about it."
"I gathered." Fenn stopped in the doorway, letting her eyes adjust from the bright, sour wind off the machair. "You're Sorcha."
"I am." The brush kept moving. "And I've only got the afternoon, so if you've come for the grand tour you've picked the day we're shifting the creels. That's meant literally. I'll be up to my elbows in dead mackerel by four."
"I came to talk, not tour." Fenn sat down on an upturned bucket by the door, which was either an invitation or an imposition, depending on how the next minute went. "About what I said at the hall. About the cameras."
The brush stopped. Sorcha straightened, red-haired and red-fisted, and Fenn saw the girl her mother must have been at nineteen, before the grandmother and the care rota and the endless small weather of the island had pared her down.
"You want me to stand in front of your lens and say the bay's ruined," Sorcha said. "My mam's told half the village you're here to shut the works."
"I'm not here to shut anything. I'm here to find out what's in the water, and I'll film whatever answers I get."
"Whatever answers." Sorcha's mouth twisted. "That's the bit I don't trust. You've a sponsor."
"You know about the sponsor."
"Everyone knows about the sponsor. The regeneration income's the whole reason they let you on the rocks at all, and the whole reason Tam's got his back up, and the whole reason my mother won't have you in the house." She propped the brush against the stall wall. "So what happens when your money doesn't like what I say?"
"Nothing happens. It's my film."
"That's what they all say." Sorcha wiped her hands on her jeans and came to stand in the doorway, close enough that Fenn could smell the straw dust and the sea on her. "You want honesty? My mam's turning sixty this year and she's been on that shore since she could walk, and she thinks the bay is fine because if it isn't then her whole life was spent fishing a toilet. My gran's dying slow in the front room and I'm the only one strong enough to lift her, so I haven't slept more than four hours since March. I was accepted to the marine science course at Oban two Septembers in a row, and I deferred twice, and if I defer once more the offer lapses, and everybody's very sorry and very kind and nobody's going to say the thing out loud, which is that if the water's bad then maybe the works would close and there'd be no jobs and nobody'd be left to look after Gran, and I'd have to *stay*, and I'd be honest-to-God grateful for it." She stopped, breathing hard, evidently having surprised herself. "There. That's your film. That's the bit they'd cut."
Fenn was quiet for a moment. Out in the yard a gull was worrying something on the stones with the patience of a much larger animal.
"They'd cut that bit," Fenn agreed. "That's exactly the bit a sponsor cuts. You know how they'd cut it? They'd take your mother's lines and my footage of the salmon pens and Callum's drone shots of the cliff, and they'd make you all grateful. Grateful we came. Grateful for the funding. Grateful the bay still looks like a bay."
Sorcha watched her.
"So I'm not going to hand it to them."
"You already did. You signed," Sorcha said, and it wasn't cruel, only exact. "The minute you took their truck and their letters and their registration number on my rocks, you signed."
"I took the truck because there's no other truck," Fenn said. "And I came up here with a permit that lets me stand on a pier I don't own and film water I can't test."
"Then why say anything at all?"
Fenn considered lying, because lying would have been faster and easier and the girl would have seen straight through it. "Because I took a sample off the burn mouth two weeks ago," she said, "and a friend of mine tested it, and it came back wrong. And I've been sitting on it since, telling myself it's for the film, telling myself there's a right time."
Sorcha didn't move. "Wrong how?"
"I'm not going to tell you that yet. Not because I don't trust you. Because the moment I say it out loud up here it stops being mine." Fenn stood up, the bucket scraping. "But when I do say it — when I put it in the film — I promise you it goes in whole. Your bit included. The bit where you'd be grateful if it closed. And if the sponsor tries to cut it, I'll take the film off them and finish it myself, even if I finish it on my own money with a camcorder and two batteries."
"That's a big promise from someone who's been here three weeks."
"It's the only one I've got."
Sorcha looked at her for a long, unhurried beat, the way her mother looked at everything — as if there were a weight to be taken and she wanted to know where Fenn carried hers. Then she dragged the brush back off the wall.
"All right," she said. "I'll sit for you. Thursday's no good, I'm up with the creels. Sunday, after chapel. But there's one thing I want in exchange."
"Name it."
"Come see the burn at low tide first. Not the mouth. The top end, behind the works, where the ditch runs down off the storage yard. You've filmed the wrong end of it."
Fenn felt something turn over in her chest, cold and deliberate, like a key. "What's at the top end?"
"Nothing," said Sorcha, with her mother's flatness. "That's the thing."
She went back to the straw. Fenn stood a moment longer in the byre doorway, and then she walked out into the wind and down the track toward the road, and she was halfway to the lighthouse before she understood what the girl had actually given her, and understood also that she was going to have to be very careful about the order in which she told the truth to people.
She had promised a whole film. She had promised it standing in a byre with nothing to back it but a sample she'd refused to file, a chart she'd hidden, and a printout folded in her coat pocket that she'd lied to Iona about. She'd promised a nineteen-year-old girl that nothing would be cut, and the girl had believed her, because the girl was desperate and because Fenn had said it well.
Fenn pulled out her phone at the top of the rise, where there was one bar, and saw Ishbel's text still sitting there from the afternoon.
*Thursday confirmed. Callum walks you round the site 9am. Wear the good jacket, they photograph everything.*
She typed: *Can we push to Friday? Something on Sunday I don't want to move.* Then deleted it. Then typed it again and sent it, because the truth was Sorcha's Sunday, and the truth was also that Fenn had no idea what she'd find at the top end of the burn, and no idea what she'd do if it was nothing, or if it was everything.
The reply came before she reached the lighthouse gate.
*Thursday only. The ferry's on the afternoon tide. Don't be late.*
Fenn put the phone away and climbed the last stretch of road toward the light, and thought about how she had promised to keep a promise she didn't yet know the shape of, to a girl whose whole life hung on whether the water came back clean, and how the one person who could confirm what was actually in it was a scientist in Oban who had told her, plainly, not to go after a company from a village where the company was the main employer.
Thursday, she'd walk the site with Callum and his borrowed truck and his forged signature.
Sunday, she'd sit in a chair with Sorcha and a camera between them.
In between, there was a burn that ran off a storage yard, and Fenn was starting to suspect she'd been filming the wrong end of it from the very first day.