The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 24: The Audit Memo

The cottage smelled of damp wool and the paraffin she’d bought in Stornoway. Fenn locked the door, drew the curtains against the long grey light, and laid the audit memo on the kitchen table beside the stove.

The photocopy was a bad one. Someone had fed the original through a machine with a dying drum, so the whole page came out furred, as if she were reading it underwater. Two-thirds of the body text had been blanked with black marker — great flat rectangles where the findings should have been. What survived was cages: headers, a page number, a footer with the audit reference, and the marginal annotations.

She set her phone to maximum brightness and photographed the page again, then enlarged the image and worked through it line by line, the way she’d grade a bad underwater shot until the wreck resolved out of the murk.

Case reference. Subsidy year. Applicant: MacLeòid Coastal Stewardship Ltd. The black boxes began here and ran down the page. Midway, a subheading that had escaped the marker: *Intervening Member*.

Beneath it, one line, half-scavenged by the marker’s edge but legible if you knew what letters were.

*Cllr. A. MacVane.*

Fenn sat back. The stove ticked as it cooled. Out in the bay the wind was rising, slapping water against the slip, and she heard it the way you hear something through a wall — there, unconsidered.

She read it again. *Cllr. A. MacVane.*

Not MacLeod. Not the family that had held the coastal stewardship subsidy, the family whose name was on the croft, on the boat, on half the headstones. An *intervening member* on the review of the claim — a councillor, sitting inside the audit, reviewing the very subsidy that a MacVane-adjacent company drew down. The memo didn’t say which way the intervention had gone. It didn’t have to. The complaint had been withdrawn, and the audit result had been quietly retained, and no one on Orasay had ever heard a whisper, and now she knew what surname sat on the other side of the black rectangles.

She thought of the discharge log in her camera bag, Katrine MacLeòid’s cramped hand writing *Reported. Nobody came.*

Somebody had come. Somebody had come and gone again, and the file had closed over them.

She reached for her cold tea, drank it anyway, and started copying the surviving text into her notebook, because if the cottage was searched the notebook could go in the stove and the photographs lived on a card in her camera and a copy in the cloud. It took her twelve minutes. Her hand shook on the second line and then stopped.

Then she sat with it and made herself say the thing out loud, because saying it made it real.

“They’re inside the subsidy *and* they’re the beneficiary.” Her voice sounded small in the low room. “You can’t petition against the water if the water’s the family’s living and the family’s the council.”

She looked at the clock. Callum was coming at half seven, because she’d asked him to, because she couldn’t walk the site with him on Thursday holding this and smiling. The decision she’d made in Stornoway — don’t ask him about the logbook before Thursday — still held. But this was a different logbook. This was a photocopy MacKay had handed her himself, and Callum was the shore witness on MacVane’s discharge forms, and if anyone on this island could tell her what an intervening member *did*, it was the man who signed the forms.

Knocking, when it came, wasn’t at the door. It was on the kitchen window, two knuckles, and she nearly went through the roof.

Callum came in with the wind behind him and rain on his shoulders. He shook himself off in the porch like a dog and hung his coat on the hook she’d never used. He looked at the closed curtains, then at the table, then at her.

“You’ve been in Stornoway,” he said.

“Sit down.”

He sat. He looked at the photocopy, and his face did not change.

Fenn waited. That was the thing she’d learned on the water — you don’t chase a thing into the murk, you hold still and let it come to you. She watched him read. He read it slowly, the way a man reads a document he has seen before.

“You know,” she said.

“I know.” He turned the page over, checked the blank back, put it down. “I’ve known since the audit. Ishbel — no. Sorry.” He rubbed his eyes. “Not Ishbel. The old man. My grandfather was told by a man in the council office, back when it happened. He was told to leave it, and he left it, and he never told my mother, and my mother—” He stopped himself. Started again, flat. “The councillor’s my uncle. My mother’s brother. Andrew. He sits on the transport and environment committee.”

Fenn hadn’t known. She sat very still.

“He was the one who got the stewardship claim through in the first place,” Callum said. “My grandfather’s name on the application. My uncle’s hands on the review. That’s the whole file. There’s nothing else in it.”

“And you didn’t think to tell me this.”

“On Tuesday you were asking me why I signed a form I knew was wrong.” He looked up at last, and there was something raw in it, not anger — worse than anger. “I told you why. My job. My mother’s house. My uncle’s the man who sits between me and the harbourmaster’s office and the licence to keep taking the boat out. So don’t—” He breathed out. “Don’t do the face. The one you do when you find out the island’s done something small and dirty and you can’t decide whether to be furious or sad.”

“I wasn’t doing a face.”

“You were doing the face.”

She heard herself laugh — one short, ugly sound — and hated it. “I’m doing the face because I spent this morning in an office in Stornoway being handed a redacted page by a man who copies things for people he thinks are in trouble, and I came home and told myself the worst version was that a councillor somewhere in the islands had leaned on an audit. I got the worst version. It’s your family. It’s everybody’s family. It’s Ewan’s bell and Sorcha’s Sunday and the *Katrine* on the logbook.”

Callum’s head came up. He went very still. “What logbook.”

She could feel the sentence in her throat and couldn’t pull it back. “Katrine’s. I found it under the floor in the spare room. Discharge entries. Pump seals. *Reported. Nobody came.*”

The wind took the cottage for a moment. Callum didn’t move. Then, slowly, he did the thing that surprised her most of all — he nodded, once, as if she’d told him the tide was coming in.

“That’s what was under there,” he said.

“You knew it existed.”

“My mother used to say the house ate things.” He looked past her at the low door to the spare room. “She was…” He stopped. Fenn waited. He didn’t finish it. When he spoke again his voice had changed, gone businesslike, and she recognised it as a door closing. “You can’t use that page alone. The memo’s redacted and the logbook’s coming out of a floorboard — a lawyer takes it apart in an afternoon. You need Iona’s report on the water and you need the report to name the discharge source, and you need somebody on the record with a name on it, and you don’t have any of that yet, do you.”

“I have until Thursday.”

“Thursday’s the yard. Thursday’s not court.”

“It’s not court. It’s the film.” Fenn stood up, took the memo from him, and slid it back between the pages of her script, where it lived now. “Ishbel sees the cut in a few days. If the plume is on camera and the audit is on camera and a logbook from a dead woman’s floor is on camera, nobody has to name anybody in court, because the naming is the film.”

Callum stood too. He took his coat off the hook. At the door he stopped, with his hand on the latch and his back to her, and said, “My uncle’s not a villain. That’s the part you won’t get on camera.” Then he was out into the rain, and the door shut, and the cottage was just the stove and the smell of paraffin and the memo sitting in her script like a stone.

Fenn took out her phone and opened the draft to Iona. She added one line beneath her name, beneath the date, beneath the request for the report: *Name of complainant of record: withheld pending confirmation — do not file.*

Then she deleted the whole email and typed a new one, colder, to the MacVane press address on the sponsor letter.

*Requesting written confirmation of the reporting restrictions clause referenced in your note of the 14th.*

She hit send before she could think. If they answered, she’d know how much they were watching. If they didn’t, she’d know something worse.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 24: The Audit Memo · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads