The morning was grey with a low chop on the bay, and Tam's creel boat was older than Fenn was, a wooden thirty-footer with a wheelhouse the size of a cupboard and a deck worn pale as driftwood. He brought her alongside the lighthouse pier at half seven without being asked and stood at the helm with his hands in his pockets while she jumped down, camera bag over one shoulder.
"You'll want the light behind you," he said. "Everything out here photographs better backlit."
"You've done this before."
"I've had a camera pointed at me since 1974. You learn where to stand."
He took her out past the point, past the pale stripe of Callum's dive site, and then further than she had been, north by the shoulder of the island where the chart showed nothing but depth. The swell came in long and ugly from the Atlantic and the boat climbed it slowly, and Tam throttled back while the pots came up off the winch, one after another, dripping.
Empty.
Fenn filmed his hands, because his face wasn't giving anything. Barnacle-crusted line, a starfish, two small crabs that he turned over and dropped back. Creel after creel. Six, seven, eight. She counted without meaning to.
"That's my whole string," he said at the end. "That's the lot."
"Has it been empty before?"
"Individual pots, aye. Never the string. Not since I was a lad." He re-baited one without looking at her, mackerel from a bucket that had started to turn. "Twelve years ago I'd have said you could walk across the bay on the creels. Now the man that buys my langoustine says he's had two boats east of here pack it in since spring."
She kept filming. He knew she was filming. That had been the agreement, reached at the pier without either of them saying the word.
He took her in closer, then, into the shallow water off the west beach where the burn comes down, and cut the engine. The boat rocked and the smell hit her before she saw anything: something turned, something sweet and wrong. There was a seal in the shallows, rolled half onto its back, its belly a pale bladder of bloat. Flies, though it was cold. It nudged gently on the swell with each set, like something still deciding.
Fenn lifted the camera.
"Don't," Tam said.
"Tam—"
"I said don't." He came out of the wheelhouse and stood between her and the rail, blocking the seal with his body, not aggressive about it, just planted. "I'm not having my boat in the frame with that in the water. You can film a dead animal, that's your business, but you'll not film it off my stern."
She lowered the camera but kept it in her hand, which he noticed.
"Why?" she said.
"Because the first thing anyone will say is, whose boat is that." He wiped his palms on his trousers. "Then it's Tam's boat, Tam's been at the creels thirty years, Tam's boats fouled the bay himself and now he's crying about it. I've seen it done. I was in the paper in ninety-one over the herring and I was the villain for a fortnight and I'd done nothing but go to work."
"So you want me to film the evidence but not the evidence."
"I want you to film it off somebody else's boat."
The seal rolled again, and the stink came across the water, and Fenn made herself breathe through her mouth. She thought about the four rules. She thought about how the second rule was that no one's filmed without saying yes twice, and how Tam had effectively said no once and yes twice and no a third time without any of it being about consent at all.
She sat down on the fish box. "All right. No seal. Off the boat, off the record, off the island."
"Off the island," he repeated, and looked at her properly for the first time that morning, and something in his face came loose. "You're the first one from away that's ever said that to me and meant it."
"I'm not from away."
"No," he said. "You're not. That's what worries me."
He sat on the opposite box, and they rocked there in the shallow water with the dead thing fifty feet away and neither of them looking at it.
"Ask me," he said.
"Ask you what?"
"What you've been wanting to ask since the pier. You've a face like an unpaid bill."
So she asked it. "What do you actually want, Tam? Not what you'll say on camera. Not the thing that plays well. If this whole review goes your way, if the bay comes back — what's the thing you want that you'd know you'd got?"
He took a long time. He looked at the beach, the burn coming down through the stones, the flat grey water, the far headland where the light sat doing nothing at this hour.
"My grandson's nine," he said. "Lives in Glasgow, his mother's at the university. They come up in August for a fortnight and he's never once been in the water here. Not once, and he's a boy that would live in it. First summer we were here he had the croup, she wouldn't let him. Every summer since, I've said to myself I'll take him in off the west beach, and every summer I've stood up here and looked at it and thought, no." He rubbed his jaw. "I don't need the creels back. I'm sixty-eight. I don't need the money — I'd have to sell the boat but I've been meaning to anyway. What I want is for that wee lad to swim off that beach with his granda watching and for me not to be thinking about anything while he does it. That's the whole of it. That's what I want."
Fenn didn't lift the camera. There was no point; she'd remember it word for word and so would the edit.
"Can I use that?" she said. "Not your face. Your voice, and the beach, and no boat."
"You can have the voice," Tam said. "You'll not get the boat."
They motored back in without speaking much. He gave her a bag of the mackerel that was too far gone for bait and she took it because refusing would have been a remark. At the pier he held the boat steady against the ladder with one hand on the stones and said, "Thursday you're out with the divers?"
"Thursday, yes."
"Take the long lens and stand on the point. Callum'll be up there with the radio. He'll not say anything to you, mind. He's got a face on him like a shut door this week."
"So I've noticed."
Tam spat over the side. "Aye, well. He's a man with one boat and one brother and a bill he can't pay, and you're the one holding all three, so you'll excuse him being poor company."
Fenn climbed the ladder with the mackerel and the camera bag, and at the top she turned back.
"Tam. The seal."
"I'll report it."
"To who?"
He looked up at her from the well of the boat, and the grey water moved between them, and he said, "To you, I suppose. Seeing as you're the only one on this island that writes anything down."
She walked back along the pier with the wind off the bay in her face and her phone already out, thinking about the west beach and the burn and the shallow water and the seal, and about what had been running into that burn, and for how long, and from where.
Her phone buzzed before she was off the pier. A number she didn't have saved, island prefix. She stopped walking and answered it, and a woman's voice, brisk, mid-Atlantic, hotel-bright, said, "Miss Adair? Mrs. MacRae at the Isle Hotel. I've been told you're the one asking questions. I'd like to answer some of them, and I'd rather do it before the festival and not after."