The kitchen table had become a war room. Fenn cleared it after breakfast — the flour tin, the stack of Ewan's magazines, the bowl of sea glass Callum had collected as a boy and no one had ever thought to throw out — and laid down what she had: the blue pages on a folded towel, the audit memo, two photocopies of the discharge logs with the ink difference circled in pencil, a printout of the tag coordinates.
Callum stood in the doorway with his tea going cold.
"Right," he said. "Where do I sit."
"Anywhere that isn't on the evidence."
He moved the flour tin to the windowsill and sat. He'd shaved, which he did not normally do on a Tuesday, and she understood it as armour without asking. He had brought his own contribution: a school exercise book, coverless, filled in a cramped leftward slant.
"What's that?"
"Timeline. Da kept everything. Vet letters, the ferry stubs, the respite invoices. I pulled the dates."
She reached for it. He didn't let go immediately.
"It's not clean," he said. "My handwriting's a disgrace and there's a gap in ninety-eight I can't account for. But it's honest."
"I don't need clean. I need dated."
He let go.
They worked in two directions, which turned out to be the right way. He went backwards — what happened when, who signed, who was on shift, what the weather had done — and she went forwards, from the documents to what they proved. By noon the table was three layers deep and Ewan had come in twice to look at it, frowning, before being shooed back to the front room with the radio.
"He wants it written down," Callum said, when they heard the radio go on.
"He wants to see it's under control."
"Aye. Good luck to him."
Fenn drew a page toward her and began, at the top, to write. He leaned over to read and she put her hand flat on the paper.
"Rules first," she said. "Then the appeal."
"Rules."
"Three. Agreed between us, before we put a single word on the file. Because if we don't, one of us will do something at two in the morning and the other will find out from Mrs. Munro."
Callum's mouth moved toward something that was nearly a smile and then thought better of it. "Go on, then."
She wrote one, and turned it to face him.
*1. Neither of us talks to the council, the press, or anyone with a title, alone.*
"That's sensible," he said. "That's the one that keeps me out of MacKay's office making a fool of myself."
"It keeps us both out of it." She capped the pen. "Two."
*2. No one is filmed without saying yes twice.*
He read it. He read it again, which she had expected. Then he looked up.
"Why twice?"
"Because the first yes is usually politeness."
He sat back. The radiator ticked through its cycle and neither of them said anything for a moment. Outside, the wind was working the loose sheet on the byre roof, a sound like paper being turned.
"That's a bleak way of looking at folk," he said.
"It's an accurate way of looking at folk." She tapped the page. "You've done it yourself. Someone points a camera at you in the pub, you say yes because saying no would take longer than the yes. Then it's on the internet and it's not what you thought you agreed to."
"I've never been on the internet."
"You've been on my camera."
"Aye," he said. "And I'd said yes once. You'd have kept rolling."
"I did keep rolling."
"I know." He rubbed his jaw. "So the twice is for me."
"The twice is for everyone. It's for Tam when I dive on Thursday. It's for Ishbel when she finally gets her interview, if she gets it. It's so that when I put a piece to air, nobody on this island can say I took their answer off them before they'd thought it through."
He was quiet. She watched him work it, the way he worked everything, all the way around the shape of it before he'd agree it was a shape at all.
"The first yes," he said. "You're saying I said it, out there in the rain, and you didn't count it."
"I'm saying you said it because I'd caught you with the pages and you wanted the conversation to be over." She kept her voice even. "You've got a second chance to answer. That's all the rule is. A second chance for everybody."
Callum picked the pen out of her hand — an intimacy that neither of them acknowledged — and wrote beneath her line, in his bad, left-leaning script: *Agreed.*
"What's three," he said.
She took the pen back. She'd been turning three over since the night the letter came, and she still didn't have it clean.
*3. Nothing goes in the file that either of us can't stand over in front of Ewan.*
Callum read it and put his hand flat on the table, fingers spread, as if the table had moved.
"That's the hard one," he said.
"That's why it's third."
"He'll not understand it. The review. The auditor's report. He'll think it's a fine thing, us getting the money back, and he won't ask what we had to say to do it."
"Then we tell him what we said. Before he hears it from someone in the shop." She set the pen down. "He circled Thursdays three times, Callum. He wants the arrangement on paper because he spent forty years watching things disappear out of people's heads. He's not going to thank us for keeping this one in ours."
Callum looked at the exercise book, at the gap in ninety-eight he couldn't account for, at the dates his mother had left him and the ones she hadn't.
"Aye," he said. "All right. Three rules."
They shook on it, which was ridiculous, and neither laughed.
The appeal took the two days precisely because they did it honestly. Fenn built the document from the bottom up — appendix first, narrative last — and Callum sat opposite her and corrected her at every turn.
"Not *misconduct*," he said, on the second afternoon. "If you write misconduct, MacKay's got to defend against misconduct. Write *misfiling*."
"It was misfiled."
"It was put in a drawer by a man who was forty-one different kinds of busy and it came out of the drawer twenty years later. That's the whole story. Say the story."
She rewrote the paragraph. The paragraph got shorter.
Later, his turn to be corrected. He'd drafted the section on the household income and it had come out in the passive voice, the way grief comes out in the passive voice — *the respite provision was discontinued; the prescription account was frozen* — as though nobody had done it.
"Whose subsidy is it," she said.
"Mine."
"Then write mine."
He did. It made the page worse and the appeal better.
On the second evening Ewan came through and stood at the end of the table with his mug, reading what was pinned there upside down, the way he read everything, from the far side.
"Lass," he said. "The Thursday."
"It's in the appeal. Appendix four. The respite hours, with the invoices."
"Not the appeal." He set the mug down and put his finger on the school exercise book. "The Thursday. When it's back. Put it in the book."
Callum started to say something and Fenn stepped on his foot under the table.
"Afternoon or morning this time?" she said.
Ewan considered. "Afternoon. I sleep better."
She wrote it in. *Thursdays — respite, afternoon.* Ewan watched the pen the whole way, then took the book, turned it around, and read it twice.
"Good," he said, and went back to the radio.
When the door closed, Callum let his breath out slowly. "It's not back. The review's six weeks. It might not come back at all."
"It's written down," Fenn said. "He can hold us to it. That's what it's for."
They finished at eleven. Fenn saved the file twice, to the laptop and to the drive in her pocket, and Callum made tea neither of them drank. The lighthouse light swung round the room and went away and came back.
"There's something I should say before we send it," he said.
She waited.
"The auditor's report goes to the community. You know what that means."
"MacKay told us."
"Aye. It means the whole review gets read out in the hall. Names in it. Mine, my mother's, the man who misfiled the form." He turned his mug a quarter-turn on the table. "And yours. Fenn Adair, documentary director, representative of the appellant."
"I know."
"Do you." He looked at her properly for the first time in two days. "Because the festival's tomorrow, and Ishbel will be there, and if the bay's fouled the way your footage says it is, then the review's not the end of it. Six weeks of quiet, and then you'll want to put the rest of it out."
"Yes."
"Then there's a fourth rule, and we're not shaking on it." He stood. "You bring me what you find, before the island sees it. That's the whole of it. Bring it to me first."
The wind took the byre sheet again, once, hard, like a door.
"I can't promise that," Fenn said. "Not if it's something that shouldn't wait."
"Aye," Callum said, at the door, not turning. "I know. That's why I'm asking."