The man was sitting on an upturned crate at the far end of the pier, and he had a notebook open on his knee.
Fenn saw him before he saw her. He was in his forties, maybe, wiry, wearing a coat zipped to the throat despite the mild afternoon, and he held his pen the way a draughtsman holds a ruling pen, loose, precise. He was drawing. Not writing — drawing, his hand moving in short strokes, pausing, moving again. The wind worried at the pages and he let it, turning the notebook slightly into it as if they'd negotiated terms.
The pier smelled of diesel and rot. The dead mackerel were gone, someone had been down with a bucket and a shovel, but the gulls still circled the harbour mouth like they knew something.
"Hello," Fenn said.
He looked up. Grey eyes, Callum's eyes, though everything else about him was different — narrower through the shoulders, the face more open, unguarded in a way Callum's would never be. He did not seem surprised to see her. That was the first thing.
"You're the fiancée," he said.
"I'm not. That's a mistake. Fenn Adair." She offered a hand.
He looked at the hand, then at his notebook, then at his pen, working out the order of operations. He set the pen in the gutter of the book, closed it, and shook. His grip was dry and brief and exact.
"Ewan," he said. "MacLeòid. Callum's brother."
"I gathered." She sat down on the next crate without being asked, because if she stood over him he'd have to keep tilting his head back, and she wanted a conversation, not a submission. "What are you drawing?"
His hand went flat over the cover. A blue oilskin notebook, the kind that survives weather, corners furred from use. "The harbour."
"Can I see?"
A pause. Then he angled the book toward her and opened it flat on his knees.
Fenn had spent eleven years on boats with scientists, and she knew a working document when she saw one. Two-page spread, hand-ruled, the bay drawn from above in careful contour, and then again in cross-section — depth marked along the vertical, tidal range banded in pencil across the width, and down the margin, columns of numbers in a small square hand. Times. Heights. Wind direction in a shorthand she didn't recognise. Dates going back, she flipped the corner and looked, two years, three, the ink greying as it went but never sloppy.
"You do this every day?"
"Twice. Once at the morning low, once at the evening high. It's sixteen minutes later every day, the tide, so it's not the same times." He said it the way people say things that matter and don't matter at once. "If you only go once a day you miss the spring-neap thing. You have to see the whole cycle or it's just weather."
"Is this what you do? For work?"
"I do the creels. Lobster, a few crab. When the boat's running." He turned a page. "This is what I do."
The page was different. February through May, the bay drawn in outline with the water shaded in pencil — and then, from mid-March on, the shading changed. Hatch marks, a note in the margin Fenn couldn't read sideways, and in April, at the mouth of the burn, small circles dotted through the water in three neat rows.
"What are the circles?"
"Samples." He said it without pride. "I take a jar. The colour's not right. It went brown in March."
Fenn's shoulders went very still. "Brown."
"First it went green. That's normal, the spring. Then brown, and there's a — " he searched for it, spinning the word over — "a film on it, when the wind drops. Like someone's poured oil but it isn't oil. I put it on paper and the paper went yellow at the edge."
"Where's the paper now?"
"In the shed. I've got thirty-one jars." He said the number the way you'd say your own name. "Nobody's asked about the jars."
Fenn looked out at the water. It lay flat and decent in the afternoon, the colour of a good slate roof, nothing you'd stop for. "Who have you told?"
"I told Morag. I told the man from the council, in the office, in March." He frowned slightly. "He said the bay's always done that. I said it hasn't. He said I should keep taking the readings anyway, that's good, that's useful, and he left. So I kept taking the readings."
"And Callum?"
Ewan's pen rotated between his fingers. "Callum's got the lighthouse. He's got the whole thing, the trust, the roof, the money. He doesn't need the jars as well."
Which was not an answer to the question she'd asked, and Fenn noted it, and let it go.
"Ewan. Can I look at the earlier pages? February, the start of March."
He handed her the notebook. Just like that — no conditions, no watching her hands. She turned back through the soften-creased pages, and there it was in pencil and a fine ruled hand: *mackerel in the shallows, 11th*, and a week later, *smell at the mouth*, and the shading beginning to change like a bruise coming up under skin. Dates. Depths. Wind. Three weeks before Morag had gone quiet at her questions. Three weeks before the council man had come and gone.
"You're the only person on this island with a record," Fenn said.
The wind came off the north head and shuffled the pages; Ewan put a hand flat on them, protecting them. "It's the only thing I'm for," he said, quite simply, and Fenn felt something in her chest twist hard, because she had heard people say that about themselves in exactly that tone and it never came from nowhere.
She reached for her bag. Habit, that was all. Nine years of documentaries, and the reflex was as deep as blinking: a person in front of you with something true, you start recording before the moment closes.
The camera came out of the bag. She had the viewfinder to her eye and Ewan's face framed in it, his grey eyes given back to her in miniature, before she heard herself.
"Tell me about March again," she said, and her thumb was already on the button.
He didn't flinch. That was the worst of it. He looked directly into the lens, mildly, as if it were another person who had joined them on the pier, and said, "The first brown was the eighth," and Fenn saw his hand slide down and cover the notebook again, the blue oilskin, the whole record of it, and she took the camera away from her face and set it on the crate, screen-down.
"Sorry," she said. "That was rude. I didn't ask."
"You can film it if you want," Ewan said. "I don't mind."
"That's not the same as asking. My fault." She put the camera back in the bag, and zipped it, which she never did. "I'm sorry. Ask me for something."
He considered this seriously, the way he'd considered the handshake. "Will you come tomorrow at the low? Twenty past six. I do the mouth at the low now as well, because the film sits on the shallows." A beat. "You can bring the camera."
"I won't bring the camera."
"You'll want it."
"I'll bring the jars," Fenn said. "Where do you want them taken?"
Ewan looked at her for a long moment, and she had the strangest sense of being measured against a mark on a wall. Then he opened the notebook, tore a page — he tore it, cleanly, along the ruled line — and gave it to her. The bay drawn small, the burn mouth circled, three sample points numbered, and in the corner, small and square: *E. MacLeòid, low water +0, not these tables.*
She read that last part twice. "Not these tables?"
"The printed ones." He tapped the paper. "They're wrong this year. Tides are sixteen minutes out and getting worse and nobody's fixed them, so the boats are going out on the wrong water." He said this flatly, as data, no fear in it. "Iain knows. Morag knows. Callum knows. I told them all."
Fenn folded the page and put it in her inside pocket, where it sat against the subsidy form she had photographed that morning. Two documents. Same island. Same silence.
"And nobody's asked about the jars," she said.
"No," said Ewan. Then he looked past her shoulder, up the pier, and something in his face reorganised itself — not closing exactly, but reassembling in a different order, the way a person's does when family arrives.
Fenn turned.
Callum was coming down off the road, coat open, hands out of his pockets, walking fast the way he did everything, and he was looking at the two of them on their crates and the notebook open on his brother's knee, and he had stopped dead halfway along the stone.