The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 3: The Keeper

The lighthouse stood on the northern tip of Orasay like a tooth that had refused to fall out, white paint gone grey as gull feathers, gallery rail rusted the colour of dried blood. Fenn climbed the access track with the keys cold in her fist and the wind trying to take her jacket off her shoulders. Below, the bay lay flat and pewter-coloured. From up here the dead fish were invisible. From up here the whole island looked innocent.

The small white boat had beaten her to the landing. It sat tied off at the slip below the light, engine cowling still ticking.

She found him on the stairs. Not inside the tower — on the external flight that zigzagged up the seaward face, sitting three steps from the top with his back against the railing and a wrench resting across his knees. Tall even sitting down. Salt-bleached hair to his collar, grey at the temples. Forearms like dock rope. He didn't stand when he saw her.

"You cut your engine," Fenn said.

"Aye."

"Why?"

"Wanted to see who you were."

"You knew who I was." She held up the keys. "Effie gave me these. She thinks I'm your fiancée."

Callum MacLeòid looked at the keys. Then at the sea. It was the look of a man checking whether the tide had turned while he'd been distracted, and finding it had.

"You're not," he said.

"No. I'm not."

"I know."

"Then why is my name on a housing-subsidy form with your signature under it?"

The wind came round the tower and pushed at her. She set her boots wide on the tread and waited. He turned the wrench over in his hands once, twice, like it was something to do with his fingers while the rest of him decided.

"Two winters back," he said. "The council ran a scheme. Crofting subsidy — you had to have a second name on the house. Married, engaged, partner, any of it. They weren't fussy what you called it."

"And you weren't either."

"I needed the roof done." He said it flat, no apology in it. "Storm took half the slates off in November. I'd have done it myself but the grant only came married or near enough."

"So you invented a fiancée."

"I didn't invent her." He looked at her then, properly, and his eyes were the pale grey of the water below. "I'd seen your name. End credits. That film about the Faroes. I wrote it down because I liked the sound of it and I thought, that's a person who'll never know, that's a name nobody on this island can check."

Fenn stood very still. Somewhere below, a gull dropped and screamed and rose again.

"You put a stranger's name on a legal document because you liked how it sounded."

"I put a name on a form because my roof was going. Aye."

"That's fraud."

"It's a slate roof."

"It's fraud."

He nodded slowly, as though she'd made a fair point in an argument he wasn't going to win. "It is."

"And Morag Bàn has the file. She showed me."

Something moved behind his face at that. Not much. A tide going out an inch.

"Morag showed you."

"She did. Entered my name in the system two years ago and never once thought to mention it to anyone, least of all to me, when I walked in this morning asking about dead fish."

"Morag's careful," he said, and something in the way he said it made Fenn file the word away for later.

"Careful," she repeated. "Interesting choice."

He stood up. It took a while. He was taller than her by a head and a half and he used the height without meaning to, the way big men do when they're trying to leave a conversation without looking like they're running from it. He started down the stairs past her. She turned and blocked the tread.

"Three weeks," he said.

"What?"

"Give me three weeks before you report it. Don't tell the council. Don't tell Morag you're going to. Three weeks and I'll have the roof money paid back and I'll file the correction myself, honest, in my own hand."

"Why three weeks?"

"Because there's a vote at the end of the month on the marine survey and I need to be at it, and if there's a fraud enquiry on me I won't be."

"You're on the community council."

"I'm the chair of it."

Fenn laughed. It came out sharper than she meant and the wind took it out over the cliff. "You're the chair of the community council and you've been sitting on a false declaration for two years, and you want me to wait until after the vote so you can vote on the survey. What's the survey?"

His jaw worked. "It's about the bay."

"Which bay? The one with the dead mackerel floating in it?"

"The survey would establish a baseline. Water quality. Sediment. Whether the fish kill's a one-off or—"

"Whether it's a one-off or whether someone's been dumping in your harbour and paying your fishermen not to notice?"

He didn't answer. He didn't have to. The answer was in the way he'd stopped moving altogether, a big man gone completely still on a rusted stair with the sea behind him.

"Three weeks," he said again.

"No."

"Ms Adair—"

"No. I'm not waiting three weeks. I'm not waiting three days." She pulled her phone out. "I've photographed the form. I'm sending it to the council tonight, the mainland office, not the one that closes for a fortnight. And I'm going to ask them, in the same email, why the water in the bay is brown and the tide tables are wrong and every single person on this island has something to say about it except the truth."

Callum looked at the phone in her hand. Then past it, at the slip where his boat sat. Then at the tower above them, derelict, the lamp housing dark.

"You'll do what you'll do," he said. "But hear this before you do. You send that email, they'll come over. Two of them, a man and a woman with a clipboard, and they'll have a look, and they'll write it up, and the write-up will say inconclusive. Because the samples take six weeks and by the time they take them the tide'll have moved whatever it is out past the head, and because the one person on this island who could tell them exactly what's been happening and when, from the very first day, is my brother, and nobody in this whole business has thought once to ask him."

"Your brother."

"Ewan."

Fenn lowered the phone an inch. "Why does that matter?"

"Because Ewan keeps the water in his head. Every reading, every colour, every current for eleven years, hand-drawn, in a blue oilskin notebook. If the bay changed in March, Ewan has the date. He'll have the date and the direction and the wind and what the burn was doing that morning. And if the council comes in with clipboards and lawyers and asks him the wrong questions the wrong way, he'll tell them nothing, because—" Callum stopped. Started again. "Because that's how Ewan is. And then the whole thing goes inconclusive and nothing happens and the fish keep dying."

The gull came back. The wind pushed at them both.

"You're asking me," Fenn said slowly, "to hold off on reporting your fraud so that you can keep your seat at a vote about water quality, on the grounds that your brother has the evidence but will only give it to someone who asks nicely."

"Aye."

"That's a very convenient story."

"It is," he said. "It's also true. You can go and meet him yourself and decide."

"Where?"

"The old schoolhouse. He keeps the charts there. He'll be at the tide mark about now, he goes down for the low water. Don't bring the phone out. He doesn't like being filmed."

Fenn put the phone in her pocket. Not because he'd asked. Because her hand was cold and the wind was getting under her cuff and she needed both.

"I'm not waiting three weeks," she said again.

"I heard you the first time."

"I'm reporting you. What I'm deciding is when, and whether it's before or after I find out what's in that water. That's not a favour to you. That's me doing my job."

Callum looked at her for a long moment. Something shifted in the grey eyes — not respect, exactly, something more tired than that, like a man recognising a weather pattern he'd been hoping would blow past.

"You're a director," he said. "You came here to film a lighthouse."

"I did."

"Then film it. And while you're filming it, go down to the slip at low water and ask my brother about March." He stepped past her on the stairs, boots ringing on the grating, and paused one tread below. "And Ms Adair. The tide tables. You'll want to ignore them. This time of year the printed ones run wrong — the office never updates them after the equinox and every skipper on this coast knows it by feel. If you're planning to take a boat out, ask Ewan first."

"I wasn't planning to take a boat out."

"You will be," he said. "Everyone does, eventually."

He went down. She listened to his boots on the metal, past the door, across the concrete apron, and then the engine coughed twice and caught and he was gone round the point in a widening white line, and the sound of him faded before the sound of the sea.

Fenn stood alone on the stairs of the lighthouse with the keys still in her other hand. The tower door below her stuck, she remembered. Effie had said so. She had a key for it that wouldn't turn without a shoulder behind it, and the whole dead lantern sitting above her waiting to be filmed, and a fraud report burning a hole in her pocket, and to the south, at the old schoolhouse, apparently, a man with eleven years of the bay written down in a notebook who had never once been asked what he'd seen.

The light was going. Low water was in forty minutes if the printed tables could be believed, and the whole point was that they couldn't.

Fenn started down the stairs.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 3: The Keeper · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads