The croft sat low against the wind, its whitewash scoured grey, a single hawthorn bent sideways over the gate like something that had given up arguing. Fenn parked the hire car on the verge and sat a moment with the engine off, listening to the sea she couldn't see beyond the machair.
The envelope was in her coat pocket. She had read the address four times on the ferry and once more at the turn-off, as though repetition might make her feel entitled to be here.
Kirsty MacLeòid opened the door before Fenn reached it. She was smaller than Callum, wiry, grey hair cut short and flat to her skull, and she looked at Fenn the way you look at a bill you already know the amount of.
'You'll be the film one.'
'Fenn Adair.'
'I know your name. He phoned.' Kirsty stood aside. 'Come in before the weather does.'
The kitchen was one room doing everything: range, table, a window with a sill of dead flies and one living plant. A cat occupied the only good chair and did not move. Kirsty filled the kettle without asking and set it on the range, and Fenn stood with her hands at her sides because there was nowhere to put them that didn't look like taking liberties.
'Sit.'
Fenn sat.
'You've come a long way for a conversation I could have had on the phone.'
'You said you'd talk to me, not to him.'
'I did.' Kirsty measured tea into the pot, three spoons, no ceremony. 'He asked about the logs.'
'He read some of them. He stopped.'
Something crossed Kirsty's face and was put away again. 'Aye. He would.'
'Mrs MacLeòid—'
'Kirsty. I've not been Mrs anything for a long time.' She poured. The tea was black as a rock pool. 'You want to know what I know. So ask.'
Fenn took the slate out of her bag and set it flat on the table, screen dark. 'May I record?'
'No.'
'Then I'll take notes.'
'You'll listen,' Kirsty said. 'That's what you'll do. The notes are for people who want to prove something later. I'm not interested in later.'
Fenn put the slate away. The kettle ticked as it cooled.
'I kept two logs,' Kirsty said. 'That's the short of it. The official one went to the Northern Lighthouse Board, and in it the weather is noted, and the light is noted, and the oil is noted, and nothing else is noted, because nothing else was any of their business.'
'And the second?'
'The second was mine. Tides, mostly. I was a keeper's wife and a fisherman's daughter and I knew that water better than the Board ever did, so I wrote down what it did. When it ran brown. When the weed came up. When the birds stopped coming to the west skerry, which was the year before the fish did.' She blew on her tea. 'And when MacVane's boat went out at low water with a barge behind it and came back without.'
Fenn's pen stopped. 'You saw it.'
'I saw it. I was on the gallery with the glass. I wrote the time and the state of the tide and the registration of the barge, because that's what you do. You write it down.'
'And you told nobody.'
Kirsty looked at her over the rim of the cup. 'I told the Board. I told the man who came out to inspect, and he told me it was a maintenance matter and I should keep my log to the weather. I told my husband. He said the same, gentler.' A pause. 'Then MacVane came to the door and asked me, very pleasantly, whether I'd thought about what happened to keepers who made trouble, and whether I'd thought about the school, and the ferry, and the price of diesel, and I understood him perfectly.'
'So you left.'
'I left with the true log in a canvas bag under the pram, and I did not give it to anybody, because there was nobody to give it to that MacVane couldn't reach, and because I had a boy to raise and no wage and no roof but the one the Board gave me.' She set the cup down hard. 'You can think what you like about that. I've thought all of it myself.'
'I'm not judging you.'
'Everyone says that. It's never true, but it's polite.' Kirsty stood, went to the dresser, and opened the bottom drawer, which was full of paper: envelopes, receipts, a bundle of tide tables tied with string. She took out a folded sheet, brittle at the creases, and laid it on the table between them.
Fenn looked. It was a carbon copy — thin blue typing, the letters faint, the paper so thin it had gone translucent at the folds. At the top: a Board memorandum, reference number, date. Subject line. And below, in the body, one sentence that made the kitchen go very quiet in Fenn's ears.
*The intervenor in the matter is understood to be Mr Duncan MacVane, brother to the lessee, and it is recommended the report be closed accordingly.*
Fenn read it twice. 'Intervenor.'
'The man who signed your coastguard's report,' Kirsty said. 'His brother. They put it in writing and they carboned it and somebody filed it, and when the office in Oban cleared out their cupboards in the nineties the girl who did the clearing was my cousin, and she posted it to me in a brown envelope with no note.' She sat back down. 'I've kept it eleven years. I've never shown it to a living soul, including my son.'
'Why not?'
'Because it proves the report was buried, and it doesn't prove a thing about the pipe.' Kirsty's finger tapped the paper once. 'It's a motive with no body. You take that to your appeal and MacVane says, aye, my brother recused himself, here's the letter, all above board, and where's your evidence the pipe was moved? And you've got nothing but a diver's word and a scraped tag.'
Fenn sat very still. 'How do you know about the tag?'
'Moira Bàn,' Kirsty said. 'She telephoned. She said a film woman was asking after me and that MacVane's man had been in the shop asking who'd been talking.' She gave Fenn a long look. 'She said you were honest but you were still a stranger, and strangers get people hurt. I told her I'd decide for myself.'
The cat got down and walked across the table, unhurried, and Kirsty let it.
'There's a wrongness in this,' Kirsty said. 'You've come here because my son asked you to, and my son has not spoken to me in eleven years because he thinks I left him. I didn't leave him. I left that island, and he was eight, and the Board moved him to his grandmother's and told him I'd gone for work.' She smoothed the carbon copy flat with the heel of her hand. 'He found out at fourteen and he's been carrying it since. That's the man you're working with. Now you know more about him than he'd want you to.'
Fenn said nothing, because anything she said would have been a shape drawn wrongly.
'There's a condition,' Kirsty said. 'If this is going to be evidence, it's evidence on camera, and I'll say all of it — the barge, the tide, the inspector, MacVane at my door. But I'll not sit in front of your lens alone.'
'What do you want?'
'Him. In the frame. Beside me.' Kirsty's chin came up, and for the first time Fenn saw Callum in her, the same shut door. 'He wants to know what happened to his mother, so let him stand next to the answer. Both of us, or neither.'
Fenn turned the carbon copy over and back. The paper felt like it might tear if she breathed on it.
'I can't promise that.'
'Then there's no evidence.'
'I can ask him.'
'Asking isn't promising.' Kirsty stood and took the sheet back, folded it, and slid it into the drawer, and the drawer shut with a sound like a full stop. 'Go home, Ms Adair. Ask him. And when you've asked him, ask yourself whether you want to be the one who put a mother and a son in a room for your film.'
She walked Fenn to the door. The wind had got up and the light was going. At the gate, Kirsty said, 'You'll need the ferry. The afternoon one's likely off. There's a boat at six.'
Fenn turned. 'Kirsty — the second log. The true one. Where is it?'
'That,' Kirsty said, 'is a different conversation, and you haven't earned it yet.' She shut the door.
In the car, Fenn sat with her hands on the wheel and did not start the engine. The carbon copy was back in the drawer. All she had was the reference number, the date, a name, and a promise she had not made and could not keep.
Her phone had signal here, one bar, and a message from Ishbel: *trailer has 40k views. Ewan's answering questions about you to a journalist. Call me.*
She looked at it for a long time. Then she put the car in gear and drove for the six o'clock boat.