Tam throttled back a hundred metres past the harbour line and let the boat wallow in the swell, engine idling, stern to the wind.
Through the viewfinder Fenn had the survey vessel in the frame — the *Muirne*, sixty feet, grey, hired out of Oban and repainted with a council crest on the wheelhouse door. Two inflatables had gone out from her at slack water, and the inspectors were working a grid they'd laid themselves.
"How many sites they have on that chart?" Tam said.
"Nine."
"And how many you counting so far?"
She moved the wide camera on its gimbal, tracking the nearer inflatable. Two men in orange. A Van Veen grab on a winch line. The bow pushed round into the tide and the grab went down and came up grey with mud.
"One," she said.
"Aye."
The second inflatable was working the far side, closer to the rocks than any survey had a right to be, and the grab came up fast and shallow and dumped into a tray and one of the men wrote on a form and they moved on. Half an hour later they were back at the *Muirne*.
"Two," Fenn said.
"That's their three, then."
"Tam, there's nine sites on the schedule."
"There was nine sites on the schedule." He spat over the side. "Weather's closing Thursday. They'll file three and call it representative. Council saves four days' hire."
Fenn swung the close camera onto the outfall, low and east of the harbour mouth, the concrete head just breaking the surface in the chop. She kept ten seconds on it. Ten more. The tide was running hard and the discoloration fanned out from the pipe in a brown plume you could see from fifty metres, and she held on it and let it run, because it was the one honest image in the bay.
The nearer inflatable turned and came toward them.
"Here we go," Tam said.
The man at the bow had a clipboard and a lanyard and the flat expression of somebody who had spent the morning wet. He cupped his hands. "You're inside the survey area."
"We're outside the harbour line," Tam called back. "International waters, son. You want to argue with the Admiralty chart?"
"This is a council inspection. You're interfering with a statutory process."
"I'm fishing."
The inspector looked at the two cameras on their tripods and the boom taped to the gunwale and made a note. "Ma'am. I'm asking you to stop filming."
Fenn kept her eye to the viewfinder. "I'm on the water, not on the site. You've no authority over a public waterway."
"I'm asking you as a courtesy."
"And I'm declining as a courtesy." She panned the wide camera deliberately across the *Muirne* and the two inflatables and the grey chop in between. "This is a public bay. There's no exclusion order. You can call the coastguard if you like and they'll tell you the same."
The inspector's jaw worked. "You'll want to be careful. Health and Safety have already requested your footage."
"Then they can request this one too." She looked up for the first time. "It'll have a timecode on it. That's the difference."
He held her gaze a second too long, then turned his head and said something to the man at the tiller, and the inflatable swung away and went back to the third site.
Tam put the kettle on the little stove and didn't say anything for a while.
"Your hands are shaking," he said eventually.
"I know."
"You did fine."
"I've just made three people write down that I was here."
"Aye. And they've just made a film." He poured. "You want to be careful with that tea, it's hotter than—"
She took the mug. She kept the wide camera rolling on the *Muirne* and the close camera on the pipe and they sat in the swell for another hour and forty minutes, and at no point did a fourth inflatable go out. At two o'clock the *Muirne* turned for the sound and the inflatables were winched up and the men went below and the sea closed over the grid that had never been sampled.
"Three," Fenn said.
"Three," Tam said.
She checked the cards and logged the timecode and they went back inside the harbour line.
Ishbel had the parish hall keys and a whiteboard and a temper.
"Nine sites," she said. "Nine, on the panel's own schedule. Three sampled."
"Three that we saw." Fenn pulled the card and slotted it into the laptop and put the wide shot on the projector, the harbour mouth, the *Muirne*, the two inflatables, the timestamp running along the bottom. "We were on the water from ten past nine. They were at site one by nine-forty. Site two at eleven. Site three at half past twelve, and then they finished."
"You didn't have eyes on the far side the whole time."
"No. But the far side's site four and five and it's a thirty-minute run in that tide. They were never there. Look at the wake." She froze the frame and pointed. "That's the *Muirne* at twelve-forty with the inflatables still stowed. If anyone had gone round the point they'd have had to come back past us."
Ishbel sat down slowly.
"So what can they prove," Fenn said, "with three samples out of nine, when every one of the three is inside the harbour, upstream of the outfall head? That's the trick of it. None of the three is in the plume."
"You're sure."
"I held on the plume for four minutes. It's on the close card. It's the colour of strong tea from fifty metres out and they sampled none of it."
Ishbel was quiet for a moment. Then: "Kirsty's counsel will have the schedule. The panel set the sites. If the survey doesn't match the schedule, it's not a survey, it's a piece of theatre."
"Then we need someone to say so on the record." Fenn looked at her. "Three weeks. Kirsty still hasn't said she'll do it without Callum in the frame."
"She won't."
"Then we've got a survey that isn't a survey, a witness who won't sit, and a hearing on the fourteenth."
Ishbel stood and went to the window, where the light was going the long way it went in October, down toward the Uists.
"Do you know what your trouble is," she said.
"I imagine you'll tell me."
"You keep hoping to get to the fourteenth with all of it intact." Ishbel turned. "You won't. The council's already ahead of you. They contracted early, they sampled early, and they chose their sites. That's three moves while you were waiting for a woman to change her mind."
Fenn didn't answer for a second. Then she said, "What's the fourth move?"
"That's what I'd like you to ask yourself." Ishbel picked up her coat. "Because it's coming, and it's not coming at the hearing. It's coming at you."
She found Callum at the pier, coiling a line that didn't need coiling.
"The inspectors have filed their survey dates," she said. "Three sites. Tam and I filmed it."
"Good."
"You don't sound like it's good."
"I think it's good you got it." He finished the coil and hung it and started on another. "I also think when the council reads that correspondence they'll notice a documentary crew on the water at every stage of this and they'll start asking who's directing whom."
"They asked me to stop. I didn't."
"I heard." He looked up. "Tam's been on the VHF to half the island about it. You're a hero this afternoon."
"I don't want to be a hero. I want the plume on a card with a timecode."
"Aye." He let the line go. "Fenn, my mother's counsel will have seen the schedule too. If she's called as a respondent witness and the survey's short by six sites, they'll have her say it was adequate. She'll say it because it's what they ask her, and she'll do it looking straight at the camera, and then your film has my mother on both sides of the same lie."
Fenn stood very still.
"You think she'd do that."
"I think she'll do whatever keeps her in the room." He wiped his hands on his trousers. "That's what she does. It's what she's always done. And it's why I'm not sitting in frame with her, whatever you've promised yourself about the fourteenth."
"I haven't promised myself anything."
"You've promised yourself something." He started down the pier. Then he stopped. "There's a boat in from Oban tonight. MacVane crew, three of them off the ship. They'll be in the Anchor till late."
"Why does that matter?"
"Because they run the Oban crossing four times a week and they don't run it empty." He looked back at her. "If the council's moving something into the bay, they won't bring it in on a lorry over the causeway where Ishbel can count it. They'll bring it in on the water, at night, and they'll use a boat that's already going that way."
The wind came off the sound and pulled at the tarpaulin on the fish boxes and Fenn thought about the grey *Muirne* turning for home at two o'clock with six sites unwritten.
"Then tomorrow," she said, "we find out what a MacVane deckhand knows."