Tam was already at the door when Fenn came up the hill from the jetty, waving her over with the flat of his hand the way you'd wave off a dog.
"Not the boat," he said. "House. Now."
He didn't say why and she didn't ask. She'd learned the rhythm of the island by now — the way things arrived in their own time and you didn't pull at them. So she followed him up the track to the low white cottage with the netting drying against the gable, and ducked through the door into a kitchen that smelled of paraffin and salt.
There was a young man sitting at the table. Late twenties, maybe. Broad through the shoulders, the same square jaw as Tam but better fed, and the pale line where a hard hat had sat. He had the look of someone who'd come off a shift and hadn't slept, and the nearer look of someone who'd been arguing in a car all the way home.
"Duncan," Tam said. "My boy."
Fenn sat where Tam pointed. The chair scraped. Duncan turned his mug a quarter-turn on the oilcloth and didn't look at her.
"You're the one with the drone," he said.
"That's me."
"You were out past the harbour line last week. Filming the survey boats."
"Tam took me."
"Aye." He nodded slowly, as if confirming something to himself. "I seen the video. Everybody's seen it. It's on the Facebook, the WhatsApp, it's on the ferry. My engineer had it up on his phone in the mess."
Tam put a cup down in front of Fenn without being asked. He didn't sit. He stood by the range with his arms crossed, watching his son the way you watch weather.
"The engineer," Fenn said carefully.
"Torquil Bain. MacVane, out of Oban, fifteen years. Bunks below the waterline, same as me." Duncan's jaw worked. "He drinks. Not much, but when he drinks he talks, and what he talks about is the runs."
"The runs being?"
"Oban to Orasay. The crossing." He looked up at her for the first time, and there was something flat and hard in it. "Two weeks back, three weeks, we done a run in the dark. No manifest on the board, no nothing. I'm on deck, I'm not supposed to see, and I see it anyway — pallets, shrink-wrapped, and the crane taking them off in the small hours while the harbour lights are off. Then the spray, the wash-down, the whole deck bleached by morning like nothing ever sat there."
"Ballast," Tam said quietly. "They'd take on ballast."
"That's what Torquil says. Ballast at night, log in the morning." Duncan's mouth twisted. "Says it like it's a joke. Says the sea don't ask questions."
Fenn kept her hands flat on the table. Her recorder was in her jacket pocket. She did not touch it.
"You want to tell me what was on the pallets."
"I don't know what was on the pallets." He said it fast, like a man stepping over a ditch. "I know what Torquil says. He says it's the same cargo as the survey lads had, and I know what the survey lads had because I seen the crates going out on the Rib. Same stencils. Same colour strapping." He breathed out. "So either the council's shipping in their own gear after dark to save on the ferry fare, which is mad, or they're shipping in something they don't want counted."
The kettle ticked as it cooled. Out beyond the window the light was going long and gold across the water, and Fenn could see, at the far end of the bay, the low grey line of the outfall marker she'd filmed a hundred times.
"Duncan." She said it as gently as she knew how. "I need to ask you for something."
"I know what you need."
"I want to film you."
"No."
"Not your face. Your hands. Your voice, if—"
"No." He sat back. "You can have my hands. You can have the mug. You can have the story. But you don't film my face and you don't film me talking, because I'm on that boat again Thursday and if it gets back to Torquil, or to MacVane, or to anybody in that office that I've been down here talking to the woman with the drone—" He stopped. He looked at Tam, and something passed between them that Fenn couldn't read. "Da. You know what it's like."
Tam nodded once. "I know."
"You've been on this island your whole life," Fenn said. "So has he. They can't just—"
"They can." Duncan's voice was very quiet. "I've got a boy in Oban. Four. I see him every second weekend. MacVane decides I'm a talker, I don't see him every second weekend. That's it, that's the whole of it."
Fenn sat with that. The kitchen pressed in around them, warm and small and full of the smell of tam's pipe smoke sunk into the walls over fifty years.
"One time," she said at last. "You tell me once. I write it down. I film your hands and the mug and nothing above the wrist. No audio unless you say so, and if I do it and you want it gone, it's gone."
"And it stays off the Facebook."
"It stays in my notes until a hearing that matters. And at some point it may need to be said aloud, in a room, under oath, with your name on it."
He flinched.
"Not yet," she said. "Not without you knowing. I'll come to you first. That's what I can promise and it's all I can promise."
Duncan looked at his father. Tam gave him nothing — no nod, no shake, just the steady old face by the range, letting the boy decide.
"All right," Duncan said. "Once."
Fenn reached into her jacket, slowly, and laid the small camera on the table. Then she took out her notebook and set it beside it, and opened the cover. Duncan watched her hands the whole time, as if they might do something sudden.
"Whenever you're ready."
He wasn't, not for a while. He drank his tea down to the dregs and Tam got up and poured him another. Fenn let the silence sit. She'd learned that much from Ewan — that the empty space is where it comes.
"Start with the dates," she said eventually, and clicked the camera on.
Duncan's hands closed around the mug. The shutter was silent. He began to talk.
He gave her the first run: a Tuesday into a Wednesday, two weeks back, eight pallets, MacVane's own crane, no paperwork on the board the next morning. Then the run before it, a Thursday three weeks earlier, six pallets, rain so hard the watch couldn't see the stern. Then the one in the spring, which he thought was the first of it but couldn't swear — a night in April, the ship sitting low in the water after, low the way she never sat coming out of Oban.
Fenn wrote. The pages filled with a deckhand's shorthand: times, tonnages guessed at by the way a hull rode, the colour of the strapping, the name of the crane operator, the fact that the ship's log had gone suspiciously clean in the morning.
And Torquil Bain's phrase, which Duncan said twice, once as a joke and once, at the end, not as a joke at all.
Ballast at night, log in the morning.
When he stopped, the light had gone. Tam had lit the lamp over the table and the room had turned amber. Duncan looked down at his own hands on the mug as if they belonged to someone else, and Fenn stopped the camera.
"Done," she said.
"Are you keeping the audio?"
"There's no audio. It's a silent camera. But I'll show you the file if you want."
He thought about it. "The words I gave you — the dates, the tonnages."
"Notes. My handwriting."
"Not on a machine."
"Not on a machine."
He sat a moment longer, then pushed back from the table and stood, and Tam walked him to the door. Fenn heard their voices low on the step, two Orasay men talking in the dark — not about pipes or pallets or hearings, just the ordinary thing, the weather coming, the boy in Oban, the morning tide.
Tam came back in alone and sat down heavily in the chair his son had left warm.
"He'll not say it again," Tam said. "That's the once."
"I know."
"And he'll not thank you if it costs him his berth."
"It won't, if I can help it."
Tam looked at her for a while. "You can't," he said. "But you'll try."
She gathered up the camera and the notebook. The pages felt heavier than they should — eight pallets, six pallets, a night in April. Enough to put a name to what the council was doing by dark. Enough to stand up in Stornoway.
At the door she stopped and looked back at Tam, sitting with his hands on the table where his son's mug still sat, half-drunk and going cold.
"Tam. If the ship comes in again before the fourteenth—"
"It's in tomorrow," he said. "The crossing's on the board. Oban, six of the morning, come in at dusk."
Fenn stood in the dark doorway with the notebook against her chest, and did the arithmetic in her head — the hearing's fourteen days, the survey's missing sites, MacKay's warning about every unedited frame, and now a ship on the board for tomorrow, arriving after the light goes.
Tomorrow it would be dark by the time the MacVane came in.
Which meant whatever went into the bay tomorrow night would go in without being seen — unless somebody was already on the water with a camera, on a boat nobody had cause to stop, with a deckhand's testimony in her pocket and a promise to keep.
Behind her Tam said, very quietly, "You'll not be going out in her, then."
Fenn looked out at the black water and the far light going round and round on the headland, and said, "I think I have to."