The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 55: The Supervisor's Widow

The ferry to Oban left Orasay at ten past eight with eleven passengers, four cars, and a wind that came off the Minch like something with a grudge. Fenn sat on the upper deck with her hood up, notebook against her knee, and watched the island go down behind them: the lighthouse first, then the kirk, then Ewan's workshop, until Orasay was only a smudge the colour of wet slate.

Callum came up the stairs at Connel with two paper cups and handed her one without asking what she wanted in it. Coffee, no milk, one sugar. He'd been paying attention for six weeks and she still noticed every time he did.

"Heard from the office," he said, sitting. "Two calls from Oban this morning. Neither of them me."

"MacVane?"

"Didn't say. Receptionist said a man with a Borders accent, which is half the council." He drank. "They're moving."

"Then we're moving faster."

"Aye." He said it flat. Below them a gannet went down like a dropped knife and came up with nothing. "I want to say something before we get there. Morag Rennie was at my mother's funeral. Nineteen ninety-seven. She stood at the back, she didn't speak to anyone, and she left before the tea."

"Why?"

"Because the night my mother went into the water, my father phoned the Rennies' house. Audrey Rennie told him she couldn't help, and she put the phone down." Callum turned the cup in his hands. "He told me that when I was fifteen. I've thought about it for twenty-five years and I've never once picked up a phone."

Fenn didn't fill it. The ferry pitched, and spray came over the rail, and she waited.

"That's why I never wrote," he said. "Not noble. Just — a boy's grudge, kept warm."

"Then you're allowed to walk in there with a grudge and walk out with whatever she gives us," Fenn said. "We're not asking her to absolve anyone."

"Suppose not."

They didn't talk for the rest of the crossing. Fenn wrote the phrase *Borders accent, two calls* on a clean page and circled it, and under that wrote *who knows we're coming.*

Morag Rennie lived in a first-floor flat off the Corran Esplanade, above a shop that sold nothing but wool and postcards, with a window that looked out at the CalMac pier. She was seventy-eight and small and she opened the door already dressed, as if she had been standing behind it a while.

"You'll be Ellen Macbeth's boy," she said to Callum. Then, to Fenn: "And you'll be the one on the news with the boats."

"I'm a documentary director," Fenn said.

"You're the one with the boats." Morag stood aside. "Come in before the rain follows you up the stairs."

The flat smelled of peat and old paper. There was a photograph on the sideboard of a man in rimless glasses, squinting into sun, and beside it a china lighthouse with Orasay painted on the base in wavering blue. Fenn clocked it and said nothing.

"Sit," Morag said. "I've had four calls this week about Audrey. Three from a nice girl at the council who wanted to know if I'd kept any of her things, and one from a man who said he was doing — what was it — an oral history. Of the fisheries office." She poured tea without asking. "I'm old. I'm not daft. What are you after?"

Fenn put her cup down. "Your husband's records. Anything from 2011, from his time as lodging officer. Specifically a survey report the fisheries office signed off on in July of that year."

"Signed off." Morag's mouth did something complicated. "Vince didn't sign that off. He was told it was signed off by the time he saw it."

The room got very quiet.

"He was a fisheries officer for thirty-one years," Morag said. "He was not a brave man. I want that understood before I say anything else, because if you put him on your television I'll know what you said about him." She looked at Fenn, steady. "He was a good man who was afraid. There's a difference, and people who've never been afraid don't know it."

"Mrs Rennie—"

"There's a box," Morag said. "It's been in the back bedroom for fourteen years. I've never opened it. I know what's in it and I've never once opened it, and if you take it out of this flat I want you to take all of it, because I don't want to be the one who decides."

Callum's voice came out rough. "Why now?"

"Because your mother was dismissed as a hysteric in this town, and I let it happen, and Audrey let it happen, and we were both of us afraid of the same thing." Morag stood and went into the hall. "Wait there."

She was gone four minutes. They heard a wardrobe door, then a shuffle of cardboard on carpet, then nothing for a long time.

"Ellen wrote to me," Callum said quietly. "Twice. After the report. I found the letters when I cleared the house. I never answered them either, because I was twelve and I didn't know how."

"You were twelve."

"Aye. And then I was twenty-five and thirty and forty and I still didn't know how."

Morag came back with a shoebox and set it on the table, and beside it, deliberate, a sealed Jiffy bag.

"Shoebox is his work papers, 2008 to 2013. The envelope I put together myself at the time." She sat down heavily. "He came home the night of the twenty-eighth of July and he sat where you're sitting and he said to me, *Morag, they want me to put my name under a man who never set foot on that shore.* He said MacVane's brother had been in the office twice. He said the brother sat in the corner and said nothing and that was worse than if he'd shouted."

"MacVane's brother," Fenn repeated.

"Edward. The one in Glasgow. He is not a nice man and he has never once been on Orasay and he knows exactly what happened in that bay." Morag folded her hands. "Vince wrote it down. All of it, dates, and then he signed it and got it witnessed by a neighbour, because he said if he was going to be a coward he was going to be a coward on paper. That's in the envelope. That's why the envelope is sealed, and that's why I want you to open it in the street and not in my kitchen."

Fenn's hands weren't quite steady. "Mrs Rennie, do you know what this does? To the council, to the office—"

"I know what it does. My husband's been dead fourteen years and I've thought about it every one of them." Morag stood again, which meant the visit was over. "The girl from the council asked me very nicely if there was anything in the flat that ought to go to the archive. I told her there was nothing. I told her that on Tuesday and I've had a sour stomach ever since."

"You told her there was nothing," Fenn said.

"I told her there was nothing, and then I sat by the window and watched the ferries, and I decided I'd wait and see who came in person." Morag went to the door and held it. "You came in person."

They opened it on the pavement in the rain, under the shop awning, with the wool and postcards behind them.

The shoebox was what she'd said: rosters, daybooks, a bundle of invoices, carbon copies of correspondence that would have gone to the council in 2011 and never did. Fenn photographed each page in order and did not comment.

The envelope held three sheets.

The first was a photocopy of the 2011 three-site survey — the same document Fenn had in her case upstairs, the same signatures, and now a fourth name in the corner that matched the lodging officer's box on the certified carbon copy. Vincent Rennie. It was not his handwriting.

The second was a note in his handwriting, dated 28 July 2011, six lines long, naming Edward MacVane and the two visits and the phrase *unsustainable at any site before the outfall.*

The third was witnessed and signed. It described pressure from Edward MacVane on behalf of Calder Marine Ltd to "close the 2011 report with the survey as stands," and stated that Vincent Rennie had been instructed by his supervisor, Audrey Rennie, to countersign the report of a surveyor who had not attended the site, and had done so.

At the bottom, in careful blue biro, the line that stopped Fenn's pen on the page: *I have kept a copy of this because I do not trust the office to keep it. If it is read, I ask that I be described as a good man who was afraid. I was not the only one.*

Down at the pier, the Oban–Orasay ferry sounded its horn for boarding.

Callum read the third sheet twice. When he looked up, the rain had got into his face and he didn't wipe it.

"It's dated six days before my mother's application," he said. "Six days." He folded the page and didn't give it back. "So she didn't fail the process. There was no process. There was a signature on a form."

"Callum."

"I want to go home." He was already walking, the shoebox under his arm, the sealed pages inside his jacket against the weather. "And Fenn — when we get back, there's something I have to tell you about a loan, and a log, and I've been putting it off since June."

The ferry horn sounded again, long and flat across the rain.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 55: The Supervisor's Widow · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads