The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 62: Sorcha's Answer

Sorcha was already at the end of the pier when Fenn came down, sitting on the edge with her boots hanging over the black water, a folded sheet of paper in her fist.

"You're up early," Fenn said.

"I've been up since four." Sorcha didn't turn around. The tide was low and knocking at the pilings. "I can't sleep in that house. Every time the wind moves the gate I think it's somebody coming up the path with a letter."

Fenn sat down beside her. The paper was creased white against Sorcha's brown knuckles.

"Go on, then," Fenn said.

Sorcha handed it over without looking.

It was two pages, on MacVane letterhead, and Fenn read it twice to be sure she had the shape of it. A full scholarship — fees, accommodation, travel — to a mainland marine science course beginning in January. Conditional on nothing they'd put in writing. What they'd put in writing was the congratulations, the pleasure of informing her, and, in the second paragraph, an expression of MacVane's commitment to the island's young people and to building a future on Orasay. Fenn looked for the hook and found it in the last line, where a name and a phone number were set apart as though they were a courtesy: any questions about the process, please contact Alan Trask.

"When did it come?"

"Yesterday. Mairi at the post brought it up herself. She stood in the kitchen while I opened it, so that was nice." Sorcha's voice was flat. "She told my mother it was a wonderful chance and my mother cried, and then she told me it was a wonderful chance and I said thank you and went out to the shed and stayed there till dark."

"And what do you want to do?"

Sorcha turned and looked at her properly for the first time. "You're the only one who's asked me that."

"That's not an answer."

"No." Sorcha looked back at the water. "I want to be a marine scientist. I've wanted it since I was nine and Callum took me out to the skerries and I saw what's under the surface there, all of it, the whole city of it, and I thought, nobody knows this is here. Nobody's even looked." Her jaw worked. "And I can't take a thing from that man's hand. Not one thing. Because the day I take it, everything we're doing is his, and he'll know it, and I'll know it, and every time I sit an exam I'll be sitting it for him."

Fenn folded the letter along its own creases, carefully, and gave it back. "There's other money. There's other courses. It's not the only door."

"I know."

"Do you?"

"I've done the sums." Sorcha pushed the letter into her coat pocket. "There's a hardship bursary at the mainland college and there's a fund for island students and it's less, and I'd live in the cheapest flat in the town, and I'd work weekends. I've written it all out. I did it last night at the kitchen table while they were all asleep and I was still doing it at three." She sniffed, once, hard. "I know what it costs. That's the whole point. I know exactly what it costs and I want to say no anyway."

"Then say no."

Sorcha laughed — a short, cracked sound. "You don't understand. When I'm in a room with the letter, I can't hold the no. I sat with it for an hour yesterday. I got as far as Dear Mr Trask and then I started thinking about my father's boat and what happens in February if the quota's gone, and by the end of the hour I'd convinced myself the course was a good thing and I could be a scientist and still—" She stopped. "I need it to be real. Outside my head. Where I can't get at it."

Fenn understood a half-second before Sorcha said it.

"You want me to film you."

"Not for the film." Sorcha said it fast. "Not for the documentary. For me. I want it on a card, in your camera, so that when I'm sixty and MacVane's put a plaque on the pier I can look at it and see that I was twenty-two and I knew exactly what I was doing." She looked at Fenn sideways, almost defiant. "You film people saying true things. That's what you do. That's the job."

Fenn was quiet. The tide sucked at the pilings and the light was coming up grey and pink over the mainland hills, and somewhere below them a seal coughed and went under.

"All right," she said. "But not here. Not on the pier with the wind taking it. Where's the letter going to live when it's done?"

"In the kitchen drawer with the deeds," Sorcha said. "There's a box."

"Then we do it at the kitchen table. That's where you did the sums."

Sorcha's mother was at the sink when they came in, and she looked at Fenn's camera bag and then at her daughter's face and said nothing at all, which Fenn understood to be a kind of permission. She took her mug of tea and went out to the shed.

The kitchen was small and warm, low-ceilinged, with a salt-bleached barometer by the door that had been reading the same pressure all week. Fenn set the camera on the tripod at the end of the table, framed Sorcha in the middle third with the window behind her — too much sky, she brought the frame down, letting the barometer and the cupboard edge hold the corner — and clipped the lavalier to Sorcha's collar and ran the cable under the table.

"You'll hear yourself," Fenn said. "It'll be inside your skull the whole time. Ignore it. Talk to the paper, not to me."

"Right."

"Say your name and the date first."

Sorcha swallowed. Fenn pressed record and stepped back out of frame and stood against the sink, arms folded.

"My name is Sorcha MacLennan," Sorcha said. "It's the twenty-fourth of November." Her voice was thin at the edges, and then it wasn't. She looked down at the letter and started to write.

Fenn kept her eyes off the page and on Sorcha's face, because that was the shot, and because watching the pen would have felt like reading over her shoulder.

Dear Mr Trask, Sorcha said aloud, as she wrote. Thank you for your letter of the eighteenth. I am writing to decline the scholarship. She stopped, and her hand stayed where it was, and the pause went long enough that Fenn's stomach tightened.

"Don't help me," Sorcha said, not looking up.

"I wasn't going to."

Sorcha wrote. I am grateful to be considered, and I have thought about it properly, and I am declining because I will not have my education paid for by the company that is poisoning the bay my family has fished for six generations. She said the words flat, and her pen didn't stop for any of them. If that is a foolish thing to do, I would rather be foolish on my own account than clever on yours.

The pen lifted. Sorcha breathed out.

Yours sincerely, Sorcha MacLennan.

She sat back, and the chair creaked, and she looked up at the lens with an expression Fenn couldn't name, and then past it at Fenn herself.

"Is that it?"

"Cut," Fenn said, and stopped recording.

Sorcha put the pen down. For a moment neither of them moved. Then Sorcha folded the letter into its own creases, exactly the way Fenn had folded it on the pier an hour before, and got up and opened the kitchen drawer and put it in a biscuit tin at the back, under the deeds and the boat's registration and a set of keys to a door that no longer existed.

"It goes in the post at eleven," she said. "Mairi's got the van."

"Mairi'll read it."

"Mairi'll read it," Sorcha agreed. "Good."

Fenn began packing the camera down. She was working the tripod catch when she noticed the fire in the grate — a heap of grey ash with a curl of unburnt paper at its edge, white, with the ghost of a printed line still legible across it. She didn't touch it. But she'd been a documentarian too long not to read what was in front of her, and what was in front of her was the corner of a MacVane page, and the only words that had survived the burning were for the attention of.

Sorcha caught her looking.

"That's my father's," she said quietly. "It came yesterday too. His is a different letter."

Fenn said, "What does it say?"

"It says they'll be reviewing the quota allocation in the spring." Sorcha picked up the kettle and set it on the stove, matter-of-fact, like she was reporting the weather. "It says the review will take into account the community's willingness to work with the company's development plans."

Fenn stood with the tripod half-collapsed in her hand.

"So he burns his and I keep mine," Sorcha said. "There's the two of us in this house. You want to know why I needed the camera."

She turned the gas on and the ring lit blue.

"Fenn," she said, over the noise of it. "You've got a screening tomorrow. You'd better put me in it."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 62: Sorcha's Answer · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads