The store room smelled of cold iron and old rope. Fenn held the torch in her teeth while she worked the padlock, and when it gave, the door swung in on a wall of dark that her beam cut into strips.
Shelves. Six of them, floor to ceiling, running the length of the room. Buoys in the corner, three of them, painted and repainted so many times the original colours had become geology. Coils of hemp. A tin of brass polish gone solid. Ledgers — she saw the ledgers first and her heart moved, but they were the visitor books and the maintenance logs, all of them recent, all of them Callum's upright hand.
"Top shelf," she said aloud, for the company of her own voice. The torch beam climbed.
The old keeper's records were up there, yellow-spined, thick as bibles. Tide tables. Weather journals. She pulled them down one at a time and stacked them on the floor, and the dust came off them in soft grey skins. 1954. 1961. 1968. Each one closed and complete, each one a hand that had stopped mid-year because the man had died or retired or the light had gone automatic and no one had needed to write anything down any more.
There was a gap.
She saw it before she understood it. Between 1972 and 1974 a rectangle of clean shelf, the wood pale where a book had sat and protected it, the dust around it thick and grey. She put her palm flat against the pale patch. It was cool and smooth, and there was no grit on it at all.
Someone had taken a book off this shelf recently. Recently enough that the dust hadn't come back.
"Fenn."
She didn't turn round fast. She had learned that much about him — that if you flinched, he closed. She kept her hand on the shelf and turned her head, and Callum was in the doorway with the torchlight catching the side of his face, and he was not surprised to find her there. That was the thing. He was not surprised.
"You said I could have the tower," she said.
"I said the tower. This is the store."
"It's off the stairwell."
"It's the store."
She took her hand off the shelf and let it hang. "There's a gap."
He looked at the gap. He had to; she was standing in front of it. His jaw worked once, the way it did when he was translating something from inside his head into the shape of a sentence that would survive being spoken.
"Water damage," he said.
"Which year?"
"Seventy-three." He said it without hesitation, which meant he had said it before, or rehearsed it. "The roof went that winter. Half the top shelf soaked. That one was pulp by the time I got to it. I burned it."
"Which one was it?"
"Tidal log."
"You burned a tidal log."
"I burned a book that had turned to mush." He came one step into the room, and the room was small enough that one step mattered. "What are you looking for?"
Fenn thought about the ledger Moira wouldn't show her. Thought about the subsidy form with her own name on it in someone else's handwriting. Thought about what Morag had said — *the light is the only thing he has that his mother's name is on* — and how a thing is only worth guarding if there is something inside it worth finding.
"Your mother kept the records before you," she said.
The silence went on a beat too long. "She did."
"So between seventy-two and whenever she took over—"
"She took over in eighty-one."
"—there's a nine-year gap and one book missing off this shelf, and you want me to believe the sea came through the roof and ate exactly one volume and left the other twenty untouched."
Callum's face did nothing. It was worse than anger. It was the door closing, politely, from the inside.
"I want you to finish your film," he said. "That's what I want."
And then Ewan spoke from the stairwell.
"The book was blue."
They both turned. Ewan was on the third step down, half in shadow, his oilskin notebook hugged against his chest with both arms, and he was looking at the shelf, not at either of them, in the fixed way he looked at things that were not people.
"Ewan," Callum said. Not loud. Careful.
"It was blue," Ewan said again. "Bright blue. Like the paint on the Roche buoy. I put it back on the shelf in April because it was on the floor and things on the floor get stood on." He paused. "It was not burned. Burned things are grey and they smell. I would have smelled it. I have a good nose. Mum said so."
Nobody said anything.
Fenn listened to the sea against the tower base, four metres down and patient.
"April," she said. "This April."
"The twelfth," Ewan said. "It was raining. I came up to close the vent because the barometer was dropping and Callum was at the mainland and the vent bangs and I don't like the banging." He shifted his weight, and the stair creaked, and he looked at his brother for the first time. "You said it was on the floor. You said it shouldn't be on the floor. I did what you said."
"I know," Callum said. His voice had gone thin. "You did right."
"Then it was on the shelf. Not on the floor. And now it is not on the shelf and it is not on the floor."
"Go down," Callum said. "Please. Get the lamp lit and put the kettle on."
Ewan went. His footsteps counted down the spiral, one-two-three, and stopped, and then continued, and then the door at the bottom opened and shut, and the tower was quiet except for Fenn and Callum and the shape of a lie standing between them.
"April twelfth," Fenn said.
"Fenn."
"You told me water damage. You told me seventy-three. You told me you burned it."
"I did burn it."
"Ewan put it back on this shelf in April."
Callum turned away and put both hands flat on the shelf above the gap, the way a man leans on a fence to look at a field he doesn't own. His shoulders had come up around his ears. In the torchlight the back of his neck was red.
"There's a way this goes," he said, to the shelf. "You get the book. You photograph it. It's got the subsidy paperwork clipped inside it, because that's where she kept it, that's where she kept everything she didn't want anyone at the council to see. And it's got my name on a form in her handwriting and your name on the same form in her handwriting, and once that's on a camera it doesn't come off. Not for me. Not for the light. Not for anyone on this island who's been signing the same form for thirty years because it was that or watch the whole thing go dark."
"So it exists."
"It existed."
"You burned it in April."
"I burned it," Callum said, and turned, and his eyes were wet and furious, "because you were coming. Because Moira wrote to me in March and said a director had applied for the permit and I knew — I knew — that if you came and looked properly, that book was the first thing you'd find. So I took it off the shelf and I burned it in the stove and I scattered the ash off the west landing. And then I wrote to the trust and said there was a fiancée, because a man with a fiancée has a reason to be at the light, and you'd have a reason to be here, and I thought—" He stopped. He pressed the heel of his hand into his eye. "I thought you'd film the lighthouse and go."
Fenn stood very still.
"I don't have the book," Callum said. "Whatever you're planning. Whatever you've got in that sample jar and whatever Moira's going to do. The book is ash. That's the truth, and it's the only one you're getting tonight."
The torch in her hand clicked and dimmed. The battery was going.
"Then why," Fenn said, "did you look at the gap like you already knew it was there?"
Callum didn't answer.
From the stairwell, four floors down, the brass bell by the cottage door rang once for supper.
Neither of them moved.