The Loud Room

Chapter 67: Weller Sues

The email sat in Lena's inbox for two hours before she opened it. She read it twice standing at the studio desk, the monitors powered down, the room eerily silent.

*Kessler Reinhardt Partners. Representation of Mr. Anton Weller and Weller Artist Management GmbH.*

She had been expecting it, in the way she had been expecting a bill she couldn't pay. Now it had a number. The number was not small.

She called Finn on the walk to the meeting and told him to bring the letter. She didn't tell him what it said. He figured it out from her voice.

The lawyer's office was on Chausseestraße, four floors up, all glass and pale wood and a receptionist who offered water in glasses Lena suspected were rinsed for that exact purpose. Their lawyer was named Behrens, a woman in her fifties with reading glasses pushed up into gray hair and the patient expression of someone who had watched smarter people than this lose worse cases.

The public letter had gone out three weeks ago. Lena had signed it. So had Finn, the eleven crew from the festival, three independent promoters, and a sound equipment manufacturer whose name nobody expected. It had been carefully, brutally factual. That was the problem.

"Breach of the management agreement," Behrens said, sliding the filing across the table. "And defamation. He's claiming false statements of fact. He's claiming the letter cost the agency eleven tour commitments and forty percent of its forward bookings."

"On what basis?" Finn asked. He had not sat down yet. He was standing at the window with his hands in his pockets, looking at the street.

"On the basis that the letter says he concealed a hearing loss in the headliner of an act he managed, and that he pressured a crew to sign non-disclosure agreements covering it. He says those statements are false."

Finn turned. "They're documented."

"Some are. The NDAs are documented, because Lena kept them. The pressure is harder. The hearing loss is—" Behrens paused, choosing her word. "Private. Unless you're willing to waive medical privacy in open court, you're arguing around it. And if you do waive it, that's the rest of your career as a topic of conversation."

"He can't sue me for telling the truth," Finn said.

"He's not suing you for telling the truth. He's suing you for telling *some* of it. He's going to argue that the letter implied causation it can't prove—that his concealment caused the tour cancellation, that the tour cancellation caused harm. He only needs a jury to think it's partly unfair."

"That's—" Finn stopped. He looked at Lena. "Tell her."

Lena kept her hands flat on the table. "The letter is accurate. Every line is sourced. I vetted it against the label's amended records before it went out."

"Accurate isn't the standard," Behrens said. "Accurate is the floor."

The settlement number was on the fourth page. It was survivable. Barely. Finn's tour earnings had gone into the canceled crew payouts and the studio acquisition; the label's amendment had restored the crew's money but not his. He had maybe six figures left liquid, and the album budget was a fraction of that, and Lena's studio balance was still four figures and no deposit.

"He'll drop it to less if you take the letter down," Behrens said. "Correct and apologize for the implication, keep the factual claims, no retraction of the records amendment. That's a real offer. He wants his name protected and his bookings back. He doesn't want a trial either."

Finn sat down.

"I'm not taking the letter down," he said.

"Then he'll push the deposition. He'll take Lena's testimony, he'll take the crew's. This goes six to nine months minimum. Your album doesn't get made in that window, or if it does, every session is subpoenaable. Your collaborators get dragged in."

"Tomas is already dragged in," Lena said.

"He'll be *more* dragged in. And Jule's post stays up, which the other side will use. Her comments section is part of the discovery if they want it."

Finn's jaw worked. Lena watched him do the math she had already done: no label, no distributor who wanted a lawsuit's logo on their spine, no venue that wanted a defendant in the room.

"Then we don't take the album out through the usual channels," Finn said. "We make it and we sell it ourselves."

"That's an option," Behrens said, in the tone of a woman writing down *delusional*.

"It's how I started," he said.

"It's how you started at nineteen with no assets to take. You have assets now. He'll come for the assets."

They went out into the cold on Chausseestraße and stood by the tram stop without moving toward it.

"He's doing this because he's scared," Finn said.

"He's doing this because it's profitable," Lena said. "It's not a feeling. It's a calculation."

"Same thing."

"No. It's not the same thing and if you run this on the theory that he's scared, you'll be off by exactly the amount that loses."

Finn looked at her. She hated this part. The part where she had to be the one who killed the good version.

"You want to settle," he said.

"I want to know what fighting costs before I decide. Behrens gave us the number. It's nine months. It's your cash down to nothing. It's Jule subpoenaed over a post she already refused to delete. It's Tomas's name in a court file six more times."

"And?"

"And I want to fight."

Finn blinked. "You just said—"

"I said I want to know the cost. I know it. I still want to fight." She pushed her hands into her coat pockets. "He came after the letter because the letter worked. The bookings dropped. That's not damage. That's consequence."

They walked back to the studio because the studio had the only heat they weren't paying for by the hour. Jule and Tomas were already there, which Lena had not arranged and which meant someone had texted someone.

Jule had her feet on the console, which Lena allowed, and a phone in her hand.

"It's on the music blogs," she said. "They've got the filing. They've got the eleven-million number, which is bullshit, and they've got your name in a headline that says *Folk Singer Sued Over Hearing Cover-Up*."

"Folk singer," Finn said. "That's new."

"Your lawyer calls?"

"Just left her."

Tomas had the contract folder open on his knee. He was reading the collaborator agreement with the air of a man checking whether his own signature had been used against him. It hadn't. Lena had made sure of that.

"If this goes to deposition," Tomas said, "they'll ask me what I knew. When I knew it. Whether I was paid to stay quiet."

"Were you?" Lena asked.

"No. I found out from you." He closed the folder. "But I found out at the same time the amendment landed. They'll use the timing. They'll say I retrofitted my story to match the payout."

"Then we document the timeline now," Lena said. "Before they frame it. Every date. Every email. Yours, mine, the crew's."

"That's what a lawyer does," Tomas said.

"That's what I do," she said. "He can't reframe a thing that already has a timestamp."

They worked it until eleven. Jule took the crew-side chronology, because she had receipts and she liked being annoying about it. Tomas took the label's correspondence, which made him quiet and gray-faced but he did it without stopping. Finn wrote his own account of what he had known and when, which was the hardest document in the room, and he wrote it without asking Lena to check a single line.

She read it anyway when he wasn't looking. It was better than she expected. It left things out about her, which she noticed, and which she decided not to mention.

At eleven-twenty the deposit alert hit her phone.

She stared at it. Two thousand five hundred euros, from a band she had mixed at a club four years ago and hadn't spoken to since March, who had heard she was back open and wanted an EP.

*Deposit: Bergmann Trio — 3 tracks.*

She put the phone face-down.

"What," Finn said, not looking up.

"Nothing."

He looked up.

"Someone booked the room."

He watched her for a beat, and then went back to his document, and the way he didn't say anything about it was, she thought, the single most useful thing he had learned in a year.

At eleven-forty Tomas stopped writing.

"There's a name on the filing I didn't expect."

Lena came around the desk. He turned the page.

*Counsel for plaintiffs: Rechtsanwalt D. Engelhardt.*

"Engelhardt," Tomas said. "He represented the label in 2019. He was in the room when the crew signed the NDAs. He wrote them."

Lena read the name twice.

"So Weller's lawyer is the man who wrote the paperwork that covered it up," she said.

"So Weller's lawyer knows exactly what's in the paperwork that covered it up," Tomas said.

Finn set down his pen.

"Meaning what."

Tomas looked up at both of them, and his voice was flat and careful.

"Meaning he doesn't have to prove we're wrong. He only has to prove we knew he was wrong before we said it. He was there. He knows what we kept."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 67: Weller Sues · The Loud Room · Lumen Reads