The conference room on the fourth floor of Engelhardt & Partner smelled of burnt coffee and new carpet. Lena had been in enough studios to know a dead room when she sat in one. No reverb. Every word she said would land flat and be recorded that way.
She took the chair opposite the court reporter, put her hands flat on the table, and waited.
Engelhardt himself had come down for this one, flanked by a younger associate and a videographer. He was in his sixties, silver at the temples, and he smiled at her the way people did at funerals.
"Ms. Roth. Thank you for coming in voluntarily."
"I was subpoenaed."
"Also true." He sorted his papers. "You understand this is a deposition in the matter of Weller v. Ahrend and Roth. You'll be under oath."
"I understand."
"You've been deposed before?"
"In a copyright matter in 2021. I answered questions about a recording I made. It took forty minutes."
Engelhardt's mouth twitched. He had the look of a man who had not expected the file to be read.
The first hour was housekeeping. Her CV. The studio. The tour contract. He walked her through the dates slowly, and she answered them slowly, because he was building a timeline he already knew and she had no reason to help him build it faster.
Then he shifted.
"Ms. Roth, when did you first notice Mr. Ahrend's hearing difficulty?"
Lena let two seconds pass. Not long enough to look coached. Long enough to be honest.
"In the fall, during the European leg. I noticed inconsistency in his pitch referencing. It was intermittent."
"Did you discuss it with him?"
"I raised it professionally, as I would with any vocalist. I asked him to check his in-ear mix."
"That's not what I asked. Did you discuss his *hearing*?"
"He told me he'd had an audiogram."
"When?"
"I don't recall the exact date."
"You don't recall." Engelhardt leaned back. "Ms. Roth, you produce records of everything. Stem folders, session logs, cue sheets. You're telling this room you don't remember when the defendant confided in you about his hearing?"
"I'm telling this room I don't recall the date," she said. "I'm not his doctor and I'm not his diary. I didn't open a file on it."
The associate slid a page across the table. Engelhardt looked at it, then at her.
"We have a text message from you to Mr. Ahrend on the fourteenth of October. Quote: 'Your left is drifting again. Get it seen.' Unquote."
"Then I noticed it on the fourteenth of October."
"And he answered?"
"You'd have the answer if you have the message."
"I'd like you to tell me, in your own words."
Lena folded her hands. "He said he'd had it checked. That's all I'll say about that conversation."
"Ms. Roth—"
"It's his medical information. He hasn't waived it. I've answered what's in the record. If you want the rest, ask him."
Engelhardt's smile thinned. "You understand that your refusal to answer could be construed as withholding relevant evidence in a case where you are a named party."
"I understand you're welcome to move to compel. I understand the standard. I'm not going to sit here and describe my partner's auditory function in front of your camera because you sent a subpoena to a woman who signed an NDA with your office in 2019."
The room went quiet. The court reporter's fingers kept moving.
Engelhardt didn't look at his associate. He looked at Lena the way a man looked at a door he'd assumed was unlocked.
"Let's talk about 2019," he said.
"Gladly."
"You signed a confidentiality agreement with Weller Artist Management on the ninth of June, 2019."
"I did."
"You understood its terms."
"I understood I was being asked to give up credit for work I performed, in exchange for continued employment, on a tour that could not have run without me. I understood it because your associate read it aloud to me in a trailer at Tempelhof and told me the alternative was being sent home."
Engelhardt's associate looked at the table.
"Nobody coerced you."
"I didn't say coerced. I said sent home. There's a difference and you know it."
"You're a sophisticated professional. You could have refused."
"I could have. I didn't." Lena kept her voice level. "And then the festival happened, and my stems went out under another engineer's name, and I spent six years trying to prove something I could prove in ten minutes if anyone had let me open the drive."
"And now they have."
"Now they have."
Engelhardt changed tack. He was quick, she gave him that. "Ms. Roth, is it your testimony that in 2019 you were an employee of Weller Artist Management?"
"I was a freelancer under a contract."
"A contract that assigned your work product to the agency."
"A contract I signed at twenty-eight, in a trailer, after being told my career depended on it. Yes."
"And isn't it true that you continued to work with Mr. Ahrend after 2019, repeatedly, by choice?"
"Yes."
"And that you and Mr. Ahrend are now in a personal relationship?"
"Yes."
"So the witness who is telling this court that the agency silenced her is currently living and working with the man whose career that silencing was designed to protect."
"That's one way to put it."
"Is it inaccurate?"
"It's incomplete." Lena leaned forward, hands still flat. "The silencing wasn't designed to protect him. It was designed to protect the *asset*. Finn didn't know. He was twenty-three and he was told the festival mix was fine and I was thanked in a hallway. He found out what happened in the spring, on tour, from a folder of documentation I'd been keeping for six years, and then he wrote a public letter about it and got sued for defamation by the same agency that did it to both of us."
"Nobody is suing him for defamation over your credits. The claim is over statements about Mr. Weller personally."
"Then ask him about the statements. I'm the engineer."
Engelhardt sat back and let the associate take a run at her, and the associate was worse at it because he was nervous, and Lena answered him in the same flat, recorded voice until he ran out of questions and Engelhardt took it back.
"One more area, Ms. Roth. The studio protocol."
"Which protocol?"
"The one Mr. Ahrend signed at the start of the album sessions, requiring visual pitch reference and limiting session length."
"He signed a studio protocol. Yes."
"Was that protocol a condition of your producing the record?"
"It was a condition of my recording him safely. I won't run a session where a singer is guessing at pitch because his ears are failing and nobody wants to say so."
"And you documented that."
"Of course."
"And circulated it."
"To him, to the players, to the label attorney. Because if a take is unusable because of a hearing event, I want it on paper that I stopped, not that I pushed him through it for the master."
Engelhardt was quiet for a moment. Then: "Ms. Roth, are you aware that the 2019 NDA you signed contains a mutual-remedies clause?"
"I am."
"Are you aware that under its terms, discussing the agreement's existence with third parties was itself a breach?"
"I am. I've read it many times."
"And yet you discussed it with Mr. Ahrend."
"I discussed it with the person whose name was on the door of the room where I signed it. Yes."
"You're admitting breach."
"I'm admitting that I told a man what had been done to me in his name. If that's a breach, it's a breach." She looked at the camera. "And it's on the record now, which is the whole point."
Engelhardt stared at her. Then he said, quite quietly, "No further questions."
The court reporter read back the last line for confirmation. Lena signed the errata sheet, collected her bag, and walked out into the corridor, where Finn was sitting on a plastic chair by the elevators with his hands between his knees and no jacket, in March, in Berlin.
"How bad?" he said.
"You're not supposed to talk to me before you're deposed."
"I don't care."
She sat down next to him.
"Engelhardt's going to come at you with the medical thing," she said. "He knows. He's had the file since 2019. He'll try to make the hearing loss look like a story you invented to cover the letter."
Finn nodded slowly.
"Second thing." She turned to face him. "I gave them nothing about your ears. Not one word past what's already in the texts. But that means the record now says a lot about the NDA, and about who was in that trailer, and it names Engelhardt. He was *in the room*, Finn. He wrote those contracts and he watched me sign one."
"I know."
"Which means the other side can argue that you and I both knew what was covered up years ago and said nothing, and that the letter was retaliation, not disclosure."
The elevator arrived. Neither of them got in.
"Then we need someone who *did* say something," Finn said. "At the time. On paper."
Lena opened her phone and scrolled to the drafts folder she'd kept since the tour, to a message thread that had gone quiet after three replies.
"Sasha's statement is still undelivered," she said. "She was the engineer before me. If she testifies to the pattern, we don't have to argue about what we knew. We argue about what the agency did and kept doing."
She looked up at him.
"I'll call her tonight."