The Missing Seat

Chapter 1: The Empty Chair

The Divinity School had been built for the glory of God and was now, on this particular evening, being used for the glory of dinner. Theo Mercer stood at the edge of the long table, checking the name cards with the furtive diligence of a man who had done nothing wrong and expected to be caught at it anyway.

He had been here before — not this room exactly, not this dinner — but places like it. Oak-panelled halls that smelled of wax and old varnish, long tables where you could count the centuries in the crockery. The high windows held the last of the day's light, and the chandeliers had just been lit, so the room existed twice over, once in the glass and once below it. Someone's shoe scraped tile. Someone else laughed the small, contained laugh of a person who had learned exactly how much merriment was acceptable.

His name card was not where he expected it. He had checked the seating plan twice on the way in. He was supposed to be down at the far end, among the second-year postgraduates and the visiting Danish philologist, a seat as forgettable as his own face. But the card on the table in front of him said *T. Mercer* in copperplate, and the card whispered to him from the place setting across the table said *A. Voss*.

Theo did not sit immediately. He stood with his hands on the back of the chair and looked at the plate, the three glasses, the arrangement of silver — every fork in its place, every knife clean enough to see the ceiling in — and understood that he had been moved. He understood it the way you understand a warning in a dream: without evidence, without proof, and with the cold certainty of fact.

"You're hovering," said a voice behind him. "It's a chair, not a decision."

He turned. The man who had spoken was not much older than Theo — perhaps two or three years — and was composed in a way that suggested effort was not required. His black dinner suit fit too well to be rented, and his hair, dark and slightly too long, was pushed back from a face that looked as if it had never once been sunburned. He held a glass of something pale. He looked at Theo the way a chess player looks at a board just before the game.

"You must be Mercer," he said.

"I must be." Theo offered his hand, because his mother had raised him properly, and because he wanted to see what the man would do with it. "I'm afraid you have the advantage."

"Adrian Voss." The handshake was brief and entirely correct. "I'm this evening's host. I moved your card."

"I noticed."

"You were expected. By me, I mean. Not by the Danish gentleman."

They sat. Around them, the table filled with the slow, civilised noise of thirty people settling into their places, the unfolding of napkins, the small orchestra of cutlery. Theo kept his hands still on his knees and his eyes on the room. He had a talent for this — for sitting in a place he did not belong and giving no sign of it. It was the one inheritance his father's side of the family had given him, along with the surname and the habit of silence.

On his left, a woman with grey hair was discussing Darwin's letters with a bishop's widow. On his right, a young man was explaining, at length, the correct way to decant a twenty-year-old port, to a girl who was plainly not listening. Across the table, Adrian Voss cut his first course into pieces of exactly equal size and ate them one by one, and watched Theo do the same.

"You're a classicist," Adrian said, when the soup was cleared.

"I am."

"Felix said you were the best of them."

The name went through Theo like a wire pulled tight. He set down his glass carefully, precisely in the ring its base had already made.

"Felix talked about me," he said.

"Felix talked about everyone. He had a charity of attention. It was one of his more annoying qualities." Adrian's voice was pleasant, and pitched low enough that the bishop's widow could not hear. "He talked about you more than most, though. He said you'd read Chapman's Homer before you were eighteen."

"I had a good school."

"He said you corrected the Greek in the King James Version for fun."

"Everyone corrects the Greek in the King James Version for fun. There isn't much else to do on a wet Sunday."

"Ah," said Adrian, and smiled, and said no more about it. The smile was not a warm one. It was the smile of a man who had found a piece of a puzzle he liked and had no intention of telling anyone where he was going to put it.

The next course arrived: lamb, with rosemary, and a red wine that Theo did not recognise and did not ask about. He ate. He made conversation. The woman on his left turned out to be a historian of medicine, and they talked for a while about the strange licensing laws of the sixteenth-century Royal College of Physicians, which was safe ground, and which kept him from thinking about the empty space at the table where Felix's card would have been, three seats down on the far side, if Felix had been alive to use it.

He was aware — in the way he was aware of his own pulse — of being watched. Not constantly. In pieces. He would look up and find Adrian's eyes on him and the eyes would be doing something else, looking at the wine, or at the clock, or at the woman on the far side of the table who had begun to laugh too loudly. But the attention was there, a hand on the back of his neck, and it did not go away.

He turned it over while the table talked. Felix had vanished six weeks ago. The police had asked their questions and written their notes, and the college had sent its emails, and the posters had come down from the lamp-posts one by one, and the whole thing had settled into the soft, damp silence that Oxford reserved for unfinished business. Felix's room had been emptied of him without being emptied. His sister had come for the plants. Nobody said the word *suicide* because nobody knew, and nobody said the word *murder* because this was Oxford and one did not.

But there was a dinner. Felix had been coming to a dinner like this one. He had mentioned it exactly once, in the way he mentioned everything not exactly once — in fragments, over bad coffee, in the small hours. A society. A slate. *Not the kind you write on.* And then nothing, as if he'd said too much and been sorry, and then the silence.

Theo had spent six weeks asking people who did not know and reading files that did not say. And then, three days ago, a printed invitation had arrived in his pigeonhole, heavier than any letter he had received in his life, with his name in copperplate and no explanation.

He had not told the police about it. He was not certain why.

Under the table, something touched his shoe. He looked down. Shook his head. Looked up.

Adrian Voss had pushed his plate away and was talking to the man on his left about the college's new boathouse roof, which had cost more than the boathouse. He looked relaxed. He looked, in fact, almost bored. His right hand lay on the table, and under his fingers, resting against the yellow tablecloth, was a letter opener.

It was not like the others. The others were heavy, blunt-headed things, like the whole room. This one was small, with a blade of some dark metal and a handle of mother-of-pearl that took the candlelight and made it water. It looked like the kind of object that had been bought for someone as a gift, and never used, and kept.

Adrian's fingers moved. He slid the letter opener across the tablecloth without looking down, and it came to rest against Theo's plate, soundless, a foot away from his hand.

Theo looked at it. Then at him.

"Take it," Adrian said, still not looking at him, still answering a question about drainage.

Theo did not move.

"You'll need it tomorrow," Adrian said. "The reading room is badly lit."

There was no sense in pretending not to understand. Theo picked the letter opener up. It was heavier than it looked. He turned it over once, saw no maker's mark, and slid it, still warm from the other man's hand, into the inside pocket of his dinner jacket.

"What reading room?" he said.

"Come to the Old Schools at four," said Adrian Voss. "Come alone. Don't tell your supervisor. Don't tell the police. Don't tell anyone you were invited here tonight." He looked up at last, and the candlelight caught his face at an angle that made him older than he had looked before, and tired. "You want to know where Felix went. So do I."

Theo's hand closed over the shape in his pocket. It was a small, cool weight against his ribs, and it made the whole room feel like it was happening at one remove, behind glass.

"Why me?" he said.

Adrian smiled his cold smile. "Because you loved him," he said. "And because you'll come anyway."

The dinner ended at ten. There was sherry, and there was the ritual by the fire in the smaller room, and Theo stood with a glass he did not drink and watched the room fill and empty and fill. People spoke to him. He answered. He had no memory of what he said.

At the door, one of the porters took his coat, and the night outside was cold and smelled of the river. He walked back toward the college on his own, past the Radcliffe Camera with its floodlights on, past the trees in their green cages, and stopped twice, and looked back once, and saw nobody.

At his own front door he stood a long moment with his keys in his hand. Then he took the letter opener out, and looked at it under the porch light — pearl, dark steel, a small chip of something pale caught under the handle's edge, like a fragment of nail — and he thought about Felix, who had been the best of them, and who had trusted him.

He put it in his pocket again.

The door creaked as he closed it.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 1: The Empty Chair · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads