The Missing Seat

Chapter 2: The Key and the Silence

Felix's staircase smelled of wet stone and old cigarettes, the same way it had smelled in October when Theo had climbed it to borrow a Loeb and stayed three hours arguing about whether Achilles ever really chooses his death. The porter's lodge had given him the key without a flicker—graduate students came and went, and grief made everyone incurious. He had told himself he was only fetching books Felix would want.

The room was a box of cold air. The college had emptied it of anything that mattered, or someone had. The bed was stripped to a mattress, the desk swept clean of papers, the pinboard holding nothing but four pale rectangles where photographs had hung. The wardrobe door stood open on a row of wire hangers. Theo had expected mess; he had not expected this surgical vacuum, and the expectation curdled into something closer to anger. Someone had been thorough.

He started with the desk anyway. Three drawers, all empty but for a dried-up fountain pen, a set of keys to nothing, and a folded-over receipt from the Covered Market. He sorted through them twice, then sat back on the bare mattress and looked at the room the way he'd been trained to look at a corrupt manuscript—not for what it said, but for what had been scraped away and written over.

The bookshelf was where they'd left him something. A row of paperbacks, spines cracked, and behind them, wedged flat against the wall where a hand reaching in would never feel it, a green cloth volume. Theo worked it free. Chapman's Homer, the old Everyman edition, the one Felix had carried around for a term like a talisman and refused to lend anyone, even him. The boards were warped with damp, and the pages had the sweet dusty smell of a room that had stood closed for years, though Felix had been gone less than two.

He opened it to the marked page and something slid out and rang softly against the floorboards.

A key. Brass, small, warm-colored, with a bow shaped like a trefoil and a shaft worn smooth as if turned many times. Theo picked it up and turned it over. There was no number, no tag, only a faint stamp along the shoulder he couldn't read in the grey light. He'd seen keys like this once, at the end of a tour of the Bodleian he'd been given as an undergraduate—the older reading rooms, the ones behind the door where you signed in three times and surrendered your bag and your phone and, it seemed, your name.

But there was more in the book. Folded between pages 224 and 225, in among the death of Patroclus, a scrap of paper torn from a notebook and folded twice. Theo sat down on the floor with his back to the stripped bed and unfolded it.

The handwriting was Felix's, small and fast, the letters leaning forward as if hurrying on ahead. It was not a letter. It was one line, underscored twice:

Don't trust the silver spoon.

Theo read it four times. It had been written with something blunt, a pencil or a dead pen, the graphite pressing pale and uneven into the paper. He turned the scrap over. Nothing. He held it up and the window light came through it and still nothing—no watermark, no second message, no address. Just Felix's voice, compressed into six words, warning someone, maybe warning him, about something that had eaten him.

Silver spoon. A phrase people used for birth and fortune, for boys who had never had to earn a thing. At the Divinity School there had been a great deal of silver. He saw it again: the rows of cutlery gleaming under the candles, Voss's cufflinks, the pearl handle of the letter opener, the way the whole room had glittered while Theo sat very still and tried to look like he belonged in it.

Someone in the corridor went past with a dragging step, and Theo caught himself with the scrap cupped in his hand like a man caught stealing. Which, he supposed, he was. Whatever was in this room had been cleared by people who wanted it cleared. The key, the note—they'd missed them, or they'd left them, and he did not know yet which possibility frightened him more.

He stood, tucked the note inside the key's page, and slid the Homer back into the shelf against the wall where he'd found it. Then he thought about that for a moment: why hide it? If the room was being watched, an empty space on the shelf would say more than a book. He left it and closed the wardrobe door and made the bed—no, that was absurd—and stood in the middle of the floor with the key in his fist, doing the arithmetic.

He could take it to the lodge. He could take it, along with the note and the invitation he still hadn't shown anyone, to the police, who would take a statement and type it up and file it and ask, in the way they had asked in December, whether Felix had been prone to dramatics, whether he had debts, whether there was a girl. He could hand the key over and be finished with it and go back to his Greek prose composition and the polite erasure of his own name.

Or.

Or four o'clock tomorrow at the Old Schools, where a man who had once taken everything from him was waiting with information Theo could not get anywhere else.

He put the key in his coat pocket. It was lighter than it should have been, and he could feel it there all the way down the stairs and across the quad, and he knew he was not going to hand it to anyone.

His own room in the newer building smelled of toast and wet wool and was, at least, alive. He locked the door, which he never did, and drew the curtains, which he also never did, and sat at his desk with the key under the lamp. There was still a small cold pinch of pale material under the handle—he had looked at the letter opener twice since the dinner—but the key had no chip, no flaw, only that faint unreadable stamp he could now see properly: not letters, he decided, but the worn-away impression of a crest, a shape he would have to look up.

Where to keep it. Not in the drawer, which a stranger with a master key could open in nine seconds. He looked at his desk: a hundred-year-old thing, bought from a house sale in Jericho, with a back panel that had never sat flush. He worked the panel loose with the letter opener—the pearl handle was good for something—and looked into the narrow space between the desk's skin and the wall. Tight, dark, dry. He folded Felix's note flat and slid it in, then the key, and pressed the panel back until the old glue gripped. From the front, from any angle, the desk was a desk. He put Chapman's Homer on the shelf face-out, spine in line with the others, and only afterward wondered whether that, too, was a signal he'd just sent.

His phone buzzed. A message from Priya, his one remaining friend in the faculty: Have you eaten anything that wasn't toast this week. He typed back, Working.

Three dots. Then: You were at the Voss dinner. People saw. Are you all right.

He looked at the desk. He thought about what he could tell her—a man offered me a job I don't understand, and a friend who vanished left me a key to a room I'm not allowed into and a warning I can't read, and I've decided to keep both, and I can't say why. He typed, I'm fine. Tell you tomorrow.

He did not tell her tomorrow.

He spent the evening on the Bodleian's public catalogue instead, learning what he could without asking anyone. The older reading rooms had their own system, their own sign-in sheets, their own handwritten ledgers that the public catalogue did not index; the restriction was not a lock so much as a set of names, and if your name was not on the list you did not exist. He found one reference in a graduate handbook to "the Weston Room, by application to the Keeper"—Keeper of what, of which, the handbook declined to say. He found nothing at all about a trefoil key.

Near midnight, he lay on his bed with the lights off and did the other arithmetic, the older one. Michaelmas term, two years ago, the seminar on the reception of Homer where he had first properly spoken to Felix; the essay competition neither of them was supposed to enter; the way Felix had looked at him afterward, sideways, like a man checking whether an ally was real. Then the thing with Voss, the accusation, the committee, the quiet word from his supervisor suggesting he might sit out the rest of the year, and the way Felix had closed his door to him in Lent and never opened it again, and then February, and then gone.

Don't trust the silver spoon. He had spent three months learning to trust no one at all. The note wanted him to go further, and he didn't know whose warning it was—Felix's, or the room's, or something the people who cleared the room had left for whoever came looking.

At some point he slept. At some point it was morning, and there was a brown envelope under his door, no stamp, no name on it but his own, written in an unfamiliar hand. Inside was a single page, a photocopy of a form, and highlighted in yellow: the line where Theo's name appeared as guarantor, and the figure beside it—one thousand two hundred pounds—and the words, in the administrator's flat type, now in default.

He sat on the edge of the bed with the paper in both hands and the desk behind him holding its secrets, and he understood, with a clarity that felt almost like relief, that he was not going to be allowed to walk away from any of it.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 2: The Key and the Silence · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads