The Missing Seat

Chapter 83: The Viva

The Old Clarendon's staircase smelled of floor polish and old paper, the same smell as the Lower Reading Room, and Theo took it two steps at a time because stopping would have let the morning catch up with him.

Adrian was already at the top, leaning against the wall with two paper cups.

"You're early," Theo said.

"You're vibrating." Adrian handed him a coffee. "Drink that. You've got two hours."

"I know how long a viva is."

"You know how long a *thesis* viva is. You don't know how long *yours* will feel." Adrian straightened Theo's collar with two fingers, a gesture so casual and so intimate that Theo almost missed the door opening behind him.

Dr. Whitcombe, the internal examiner, was a small woman in a cardigan with a fountain pen clipped to it. She looked at the two of them, at the coffee, at Adrian, and said, "Mr. Mercer. We're ready for you."

"Wait outside," Theo said to Adrian.

"I've been waiting outside for you for two years," Adrian said. "One more hour won't kill me."

The room was a seminar room with a long table and three chairs on the far side. Dr. Whitcombe sat at the left. In the middle sat a man Theo had never met, bald, with reading glasses pushed up into his forehead and a copy of the thesis so thoroughly annotated that the margins looked like a second manuscript. The external, then. UCL, Edgerton had said. Professor something.

And in the third chair, the right-hand chair, sat a woman with silver hair and a small blue notebook.

Theo stopped walking.

"Sit down, Mr. Mercer," said Professor whoever-he-was. "We've read your work closely. That's the good news. The rest of this morning you'll have to earn."

Theo sat. He kept his eyes on the table because looking at the notebook would have been worse. The woman wrote something. He could hear the pen.

They started with the commentary tradition, which he could have done in his sleep — Marsilio Ficino's marginalia, the sixteenth-century practice of annotating inherited texts until the annotation was itself the object of study. He answered the first three questions before they finished asking them, which he knew was a mistake halfway through the second one, because Professor UCL's eyebrows went up and stayed up.

"You're fast," he said. "I don't like fast. It usually means the student has rehearsed. Slow down. Tell me why Ficino's method isn't simply plagiarism with better handwriting."

Theo slowed down.

He talked about transmission and authority, about how a commentarium could preserve a text or bury it, about the difference between citation and custody. Professor UCL leaned back. Dr. Whitcombe wrote something.

Then the silver-haired woman spoke for the first time.

"Your fourth chapter," she said. Her voice was low and unhurried and had an accent he couldn't place — not quite Oxford, not quite anything. "You construct an ethics of commentary from the Vesalius affair. That is a case in which a scholar's notes were used, without consent, to build an experiment. You argue that the ethics of annotation are therefore inseparable from the ethics of what the annotation is *for*." She turned a page. "That's a strong claim. It is not, however, the claim the historical record supports."

Theo's mouth went dry.

"The historical record," he said, "supports that Vesalius's marginalia on the Ellsworth manuscript were transferred to a second repository under a filing code that does not appear in any public catalogue, and that four names were withheld from the subsequent publication. That is not a claim. That is what the archive shows."

"The archive shows what survived in the archive," she said. "You're aware that in 1972 a quantity of material was removed from special collections for cleaning and never returned."

"Yes."

"And yet your chapter proceeds as though the surviving record is the whole record."

"Yes," Theo said. "I say so. Page two hundred and eleven, second paragraph. I say that any ethics built on an incomplete archive has to be an ethics of acknowledged incompleteness, or it's just another way of pretending the gap isn't there."

There was a silence.

Dr. Whitcombe looked up. Professor UCL looked at the woman. The woman looked at Theo for what felt like a long time, and then wrote one line in the blue notebook and closed it.

"That," she said, "is the correct answer."

The rest of it was grinding. Professor UCL went after his dating of the second manuscript hand, which Theo had hedged in a footnote and now had to defend out loud; he defended it badly and then, when pushed, said he wasn't sure, which seemed to cost him something. Dr. Whitcombe asked what the thesis would look like if he were wrong, and he said it would look shorter and worse. She wrote that down too.

Somewhere past the hour mark his coffee went cold and he stopped noticing. He heard himself talk about Felix — carefully, without naming him, the way the thesis itself did, "a colleague" — and about the difference between a document that records and a document that *keeps*, and when he was done Professor UCL took off his glasses and rubbed his eyes.

"Minor corrections," he said.

Theo didn't understand him.

"Minor corrections to chapters two and four. Tighten the dating, expand the incompleteness argument, list of errata by the end of the month. Then it's a pass." He held out his hand. "Congratulations, Dr. Mercer."

Dr. Whitcombe shook his hand too. The silver-haired woman closed her copy of the thesis and stood, and Theo, standing, was close enough to see what she had written in the notebook.

It was a date. The twenty-third of something. And four initials, which were not the initials of anyone in the thesis.

"Congratulations," she said. "I'll be reading your errata." And then she walked out, and the door closed, and Theo was alone with two examiners who were already packing their bags.

Adrian was sitting on the floor of the corridor with his back to the wall and both cups empty.

"Well?" he said.

"Minor corrections."

Adrian's face did something complicated and then settled. He stood up and hugged Theo so hard that a passing porter had to walk around them, and Theo, who had not cried in the corridor of the Old Clarendon, pressed his face into Adrian's shoulder and did not say anything for a while.

"I knew," Adrian said, into his hair. "I have always known. It's very annoying, being right about you constantly."

"Don't start."

"I'm not starting anything. I'm finishing a thesis." He pulled back. "There's a pub at the bottom of the street. It's eleven in the morning and you're a doctor. We're going to sit in it."

Walking down the stairs, Theo said, "The third examiner."

"The woman with the notebook."

"She wrote a date in it. Twenty-three. And four initials that don't appear anywhere in the thesis."

Adrian stopped on the landing. "You looked in her notebook."

"She closed it, I didn't *read* it — it was facing me." Theo kept going. "The initials were J, C, M, B. Which means nothing to me. But she came specifically to the viva. UCL was the external I was told about. Two externals is not normal."

Adrian caught up with him at the bottom of the stairs, and his voice had changed. "Edgerton never mentioned a third examiner."

"No."

"Do you think she's — Theo, the note-taker. From the Isis panel. The elderly one in the front row who nobody identified."

"I think," Theo said, pushing the street door open into grey Oxford light, "she wrote a date down and closed the book and called me correct. Which usually means I've just handed her something."

Adrian was quiet for half a block. Then he said, "The twenty-third of what?"

"I don't know yet."

"Find out before you drink. Because if that's an anniversary of something, and she came to your viva to hear you say the archive is incomplete—"

"—then someone else is still keeping the fourth child," Theo said. "And she wanted to know whether I'd notice."

They stood in front of the pub. Adrian took his phone out. "I'm texting Edgerton."

"Don't. Not yet." Theo looked back at the Old Clarendon, where the third chair's occupant was no longer visible in any window. "Twenty-third. That's a Saturday this month. And the blue notebook is in the Lower Reading Room archive box, which means it's catalogued, which means there's a name on the card."

"You said you'd stop working the day after your viva."

"I said I'd stop writing." Theo pulled the door open. "I didn't say I'd stop reading. Two pints, and then we go and find out who M. B. is."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 83: The Viva · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads