The Painted Lie

Chapter 1: The Commission

The light in the bottega was the color of old honey, and it was wrong for everything.

Michele had known this since dawn. He had ground his lapis lazuli to a powder the texture of dust from a butterfly's wing, mixed it with the last of his linseed oil, and laid it down on the panel where the Virgin's mantle should have been blue as a summer sea. It had dried gray. He had sat back on his heels and looked at it for a long while, and the Virgin had looked back at him with her flat, chalky eyes, and he had thought, I am going to starve.

"Not that bad," said Tommaso from the doorway, though he could not possibly see the panel from there, and his voice was the voice of a man who had already begun to calculate what he might get for the brushes when the rent came due.

"It is that bad." Michele wiped his fingers on the rag at his belt. His fingers were stained a dozen colors and never came clean, which was its own kind of signature; he left fingerprints on bread, on doorframes, on the cheeks of women he kissed. "It's the oil. It's gone foul. It was probably foul when the man sold it to me, and I paid him anyway, because I am a fool with an appetite."

"You're a fool who can paint."

"A fool who could paint. Past tense."

Tommaso came in and stood over him, a stocky man with a cooper's shoulders and a face that had never once been surprised by anything. He looked at the gray Virgin, then at the gray window, then at Michele, and said, "There's a man downstairs asking for you."

"Tell him I'm dead."

"He says he's from the Medici."

Michele looked up. The gray light made everything in the room look like it was underwater, and Tommaso's face was no different. "Which Medici? Say the name carefully."

"He didn't give it. He gave a paper." Tommaso produced a folded square from his sleeve, creased brown with handling, and held it out. "He says you'll want to read it before you decide whether to be dead."

Michele took the paper. He did not unfold it at once. He was aware, in the way a man is aware of a change in the weather before the first cold touches his neck, that the day had stopped being an ordinary day, and that whatever was written in the fold would be the reason.

He opened it.

It was short. A name, an address across the river, and a sum of gold that was not a sum so much as an announcement. Michele read the number twice, and both times it was the same number, and both times it was more money than he had earned in the last three years together, laid end to end.

"Tommaso," he said. "What does a man do to deserve this?"

"Nothing," Tommaso said. "That's what worries me."

The villa stood on the far side of the Arno, up the slope where the air turned cool and smelled of cypress and rain, and the street that led to it was so quiet that Michele could hear his own boots and, under them, the faint grind of gravel that some gardener had raked that very morning. There was a wall, and a gate, and a servant at the gate who took the paper from Michele's hand without looking at his face and opened the way.

Inside, the garden was the kind of garden that existed to remind a visitor of his station. Michele walked through it and felt his cheap wool jacket grow cheaper with every step. Lemon trees in pots, their fruit luminous; a fountain whose water fell in a thin, precise sheet; a peacock on the balustrade that did not turn its head when he passed, as though it had already been told he was unimportant.

He was kept waiting in a room with a ceiling painted by somebody very good. He did not sit. He studied the ceiling instead and found, in the corner where a plasterer's seam had been disguised by two fat cherubs, the telltale wobble of a hand that had been rushed. Even here, he thought. Even here, someone had a deadline and a bad back and a candle that guttered.

A door opened behind him. He turned.

The man who came in was younger than Michele had expected and more careful than his reputation suggested. Lorenzo di Pierfrancesco de' Medici was of medium height, dressed in a plain dark velvet that would have cost more than the ceiling, and he moved like someone who had learned long ago that the less you seemed to want from a room, the more the room gave you. His hair was the brown of wet earth. His eyes were a color Michele could not name — they were not gray and they were not green, and when he looked at Michele, Michele had the sudden, unwelcome sense of being looked at in a way no one had looked at him in years: as if he were worth examining.

"You're a painter," Lorenzo said.

"I'm told so. Some mornings."

"You're Michele di Bartolomeo. You apprenticed under Filippo, who drank himself into an early grave, and you've taken no commissions above twelve florins in four years, and you paint like a man who is angry at the panel." Lorenzo crossed to a chair and sat, gesturing at the one opposite. "Sit."

Michele sat. Anger at the panel, he thought. He files me away like a sketch. "You've had me investigated."

"Of course." Lorenzo studied him without apology. "I commission no one without knowing what they are. You are proud, you are poor, and you have a hand for faces that is better than your circumstances deserve. That is precisely what I need."

"What do you need?"

"A wedding portrait," Lorenzo said. "Mine."

Michele did not move. "You're to be married."

"I am. The contract is settled; the ceremony is set for spring. My betrothed is of a family in Ferrara, and she has not yet come south. The portrait is due at the ceremony. Her family wishes to see that the man their daughter is given to cuts a proper figure, and my own family wishes to see that I appear"—he paused, and the pause was so precise that Michele noticed it—"content."

"So you need her painted before she arrives."

"I need her painted as she should be," Lorenzo said. "From description."

Michele let the silence stretch long enough to be honest. "You mean from invention."

"I mean from description," Lorenzo said again, evenly. "You will be given her height, her coloring, the cut of her hair, the family features that matter. You will paint a woman who could be her. When she arrives, if the painting requires correction, we will correct it. Before the ceremony, no one will know the difference."

"No one except the woman herself."

"She will never see it. It goes to Ferrara and hangs in the family's hall, and she will see it the day she is married, when it is far too late to quarrel with it."

Michele looked at his own hands. The blue stain was still under his left thumbnail. "This is not a portrait," he said. "It's a lie in a gilt frame. You understand that."

"Yes," Lorenzo said. And then, quietly: "You understand that I am paying you four times what any lie is worth."

There it was, named. Michele felt the number in the room like heat from a hearth. Rent. Oil that was not foul. A winter without the particular arithmetic of hunger. He thought of the gray Virgin sitting on its easel in the honey-colored light, and he thought of the peacock in the garden that did not turn its head, and he thought: I have been unimportant for a very long time, and this man is offering to be the first person in years who insists I matter.

"I'll need to see the villa," he said. "Where I'll work. The light there."

"Of course."

"And I'll need more than a description. I'll need whatever you have. Letters, if there are any. A miniature, if one exists. Anything her family has sent. I can't paint a face off a rumor."

Lorenzo smiled for the first time, and it was a good smile — warm, almost grateful — and that was the moment Michele should have distrusted, and knew it, and went on. "You'll have all of it," Lorenzo said, rising. "Come. You should see where you'll work before you decide."

The studio was on the western corner of the villa, high up, and it had the light that every painter prays for and almost no one is given: a wall of windows, cool and even, with a view down the slope to the yellow thread of the river. There was an easel already positioned. There was a table set with clean brushes, twelve of them, and a rack of pigments in jars whose labels Michele recognized and whose price he did not want to know. Someone had been told to prepare this room for a worker, and whoever had arranged it had done so with an unnerving, almost tender exactness.

"Who set this up?" Michele asked.

"My steward. Matteo." Lorenzo moved to the window, his back to the room. "You'll deal with him in most things. He is discreet."

Michele walked the room. He noted the way the pigment jars had been ordered by color and not by use, which was the ordering of a man who did not paint. He noted the chair by the easel, worn on the left arm where a sitter's hand would rest for hours, and felt a flicker of something — the chair was old. Someone had sat here many times for someone else. He was not the first painter in this room, which should have comforted him and instead sharpened him.

A servant brought wine: a boy of perhaps fifteen, thin-wristed, who set down the tray and would not look up. Michele caught him at the door. "Your lady," he said, pleasantly. "The bride. She's from Ferrara, I hear. Have you seen her?"

The boy's eyes went sideways, toward Lorenzo at the window, and then to the floor. "No, signore."

"Not even a likeness? Not a sketch you've been shown?"

"No, signore." The boy's voice had dropped almost below hearing. "Nobody has."

"Enough," said Lorenzo, from the window, without turning. The boy fled. Lorenzo turned and looked at Michele with the careful nothing-face of a man who had practiced it. "The household is instructed not to gossip about the marriage until it's announced. You will find that no one here is forthcoming about my betrothed. That is not evasion. It is discipline."

"Of course," Michele said. "Discipline."

He drank the wine, which was very good. He looked at the window wall and the clean brushes and the worn chair, and he felt the whole house settle around him like water closing over his head. Somewhere below, in the garden, the fountain fell in its thin, precise sheet.

Lorenzo drew a paper from inside his jacket — the contract, already written, already inked — and laid it on the table beside the pigment jars. He set a quill beside it.

"The advance is on the table in the next room," he said. "You may take it with you whether you sign or not, for the trouble of the walk. But if you sign, I'll expect you here Monday morning, and I'll expect the first sketch a week from Sunday."

Michele thought of the number. He thought of the boy's eyes, sideways. He thought of the phrase that would not leave him: nobody has.

He picked up the quill. The nib was new and cut clean. He signed his name, and the ink went down black and wet, and he watched his own hand do it and understood he was watching a man step off a ledge.

Lorenzo folded the contract and slid it inside his jacket, and there was that smile again, warm and grateful, and this time Michele saw what it cost.

"Monday, then," Lorenzo said.

"Monday," said Michele.

He went down through the garden, past the fountain and the lemon trees and the peacock that did not turn its head, and the gold of the advance sat in his coat like a small, warm animal, and the whole way home he could not decide whether the fluttering in his chest was hunger finally answered or a warning he had chosen not to hear.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 1: The Commission · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads