The Painted Lie

Chapter 2: The Empty Frame

Morning light slanted through the tall windows of Lorenzo's studio and fell across an empty easel, and Michele stood before it with his hands on his hips, waiting for inspiration to arrive.

It did not.

The room was too fine for work. Everything in it gleamed: the polished walnut table, the jars of pigment ground so fine they seemed to glow from within, the brushes laid out in a row like soldiers awaiting orders. Michele had painted in cellars, in courtyards, on a scaffold beside a church wall with pigeons shitting on his shoulders. He had never worked in a room with a view of the Arno.

He picked up a stick of charcoal, rolled it between his fingers, and set it down again.

"Something wrong with the charcoal?" said a voice behind him.

Michele turned. A servant boy stood in the doorway, the same one who had flinched the day before. He was perhaps fourteen, thin as a reed, with a bowl-cut of black hair and eyes that moved constantly, as if cataloguing exits.

"No," Michele said. "The charcoal is perfect. That's the problem."

The boy frowned.

"Never mind," Michele said. "I'm supposed to paint a woman I've never seen. Tell me your name."

"Pietro."

"Pietro. Have you seen her? The bride?"

The boy's face did something complicated. It closed, the way a door closes when the wind changes direction.

"I bring the water," Pietro said. "And the rags. For the brushes." He was already backing out of the room.

"Wait—"

But the boy was gone, and Michele was alone with the empty easel and the too-good charcoal and the ridiculous view.

He turned back to the description.

It was written on a single sheet of paper, in a neat, clerkly hand that Michele doubted was Lorenzo's. *Hair the color of chestnut in autumn. Eyes gray as the sea before a storm. A small scar above the left eyebrow, from a childhood fall. Fond of music. Laughs easily.*

That was all. No portrait, no miniature, no sketch. A diplomat's household, stuffed to the rafters with gold and tapestries and Murano glass, and no one could produce a single image of the woman he was engaged to marry.

Michele pinned the paper to the wall and began a first sketch.

He worked with the faintest possible lines, the way he always did—not drawing a face but circling it, approaching it from four directions at once, coaxing it out of the paper. He sketched the oval of the jaw, then the height of the brow, then the way the hair would fall from a center part, framing the cheekbones. He gave her a long neck. He gave her a slight tilt to the head, as though she were listening to something pleasant.

By midmorning the sketch had a kind of life to it. He stood back and looked at the woman he had invented.

She was beautiful. She was completely imaginary.

"Michele."

Lorenzo stood in the doorway. He had changed since the day before—or rather, Michele had changed the way he saw him. Yesterday, the diplomat had been a patron, a benefactor, a man in a fine coat. Today, standing in the strong light, Lorenzo looked tired. There was a gray thread in his hair that Michele hadn't noticed, and the skin beneath his eyes had a fragile, papery look, as if sleep had given him up as a bad bargain.

"You've begun," Lorenzo said, crossing to the easel.

He studied the sketch for a long time. Michele watched his face and saw nothing in it—no flicker of recognition, no satisfaction, no disappointment. That, more than anything, struck him as odd. A man should recognize his own bride.

"She's lovely," Lorenzo said at last.

"Is she?" Michele said. "I made her up."

Lorenzo smiled. "Then you'll be glad of a few corrections."

He sat down at the table and described her. He described her chin, which was rounder than Michele had drawn. He described the bow of her mouth. He described a small, dark mole on the right side of her throat, just below the jaw.

Michele listened. He made the corrections. And all the while, something itched at the back of his mind, because Lorenzo's descriptions came too easily, as though he were describing not a woman but a picture he had seen a hundred times.

When Lorenzo left, Michele sat on the stool and stared at the door for a full minute.

Then he went looking for the household.

It took him less than an hour.

The cook had never seen her. The grooms had never seen her. The old manservant who polished the silver and somehow managed to be everywhere and nowhere at once had never seen her, and when Michele asked, the man polished the same spoon for a very long time and then asked whether the young master found the wine to his liking.

Michele found the maid Lucrezia in the garden, airing out linens. She was perhaps forty, tall, with hands red from lye and the flat, patient expression of a woman who had spent a lifetime not saying things.

"A moment of your time," Michele said.

She looked at him. "You're the painter."

"I am."

"You've come to ask about her."

Michele stopped. "Yes."

"And if I tell you that she's in the city and you'll meet her soon enough?"

"I'd know you were lying," Michele said. "You're not a good liar. That's a compliment."

Lucrezia smiled, but only for a moment, and then the expression left her face like water draining from a basin. She looked over her shoulder at the house. The windows along the ground floor were shut, even in the warm season.

"Listen to me," she said. Her voice was low. "The master is a good man. He's been good to this household, and he's been good to me, and I'll not have him harmed. But there are things in this house that aren't my business to understand, and they aren't yours either. You paint the portrait. You take the money. You go home."

"Who is she?"

"Stop."

"I only want to know—"

"I said stop." Her hands had stopped moving in the linens. "You want to know about the bride. Fine. Here is what I know. A month ago a courier arrived at the back gate. Before sunrise. He was let in by no one, and no one let him out. Two days later, the master called the whole staff into the hall and told us he was to be married. He told us her name, and he told us her family, and he told us a story about how they had met. And every word of it was a story. Do you understand? Every word was a story."

"Then who is she?"

"That," Lucrezia said, "is the question you should not ask."

She gathered the linens and went inside.

Michele stood a while in the garden, listening to the bees. Then he went back to the studio and bolted the door.

He sat down, took out a fresh sheet of paper, and began to write.

If he were going to be lied to—and he had established that beyond reasonable doubt—then he was going to keep an account of it. He wrote down everything he had learned, in a small hand, in the corner of the sheet, where no one would see it unless they were looking for it. The cook, the groom, the old manservant, Lucrezia's refusal to name the courier. He sketched a rough map of the villa. He wrote down the date.

Then he tucked the paper inside his satchel, beneath the folded spectacles he never wore and the stub of a red chalk he'd carried since he was a boy.

He returned to the sketch.

He had made her chin rounder. He had made her mouth bow-shaped. He had drawn the mole below her jaw. It was, by any standard he could measure, a better likeness than the first one—and yet he found that he liked it less. It was not a woman he had invented anymore. It was a woman someone had handed him, piece by piece, the way you hand a witness a set of facts.

Michele looked at the empty frame hanging on the wall above the table—the frame Lorenzo had already purchased, gold leaf and carved walnut, waiting for a painting that did not yet exist.

*You take the money. You go home.*

He picked up the charcoal and made her eyes a little wider. A little grayer. A little more like the sea before a storm.

He was beginning to suspect that before he finished this portrait, he would need to find out whose face it really was.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 2: The Empty Frame · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads