The Painted Lie

Chapter 16: The Cardinal's Shadow

The knock came again — slow, deliberate, four knuckles on oak, spaced like a heartbeat. Lorenzo crossed the studio in three strides and put his shoulder to the door before Michele could stop him.

"Step back," Michele hissed, but Lorenzo was already lifting the latch.

The man in the doorway looked like a servant. Grey wool, no weapon showing, hands folded inside his sleeves. But servants did not have that stillness. Servants shifted their weight, glanced past your shoulder, measured the room. This one simply stood and waited to be admitted.

"His Eminence sends his regards," the man said. "Friar Tommaso. I'm to assist you in the Cardinal's affairs here in Florence." He smiled. It was a small, neat expression, like a coin laid flat on a table. "Perhaps I might come in. It's cold on the step."

Lorenzo's jaw tightened, but he opened the door. "Brother Tommaso. Of course. I wasn't expecting — "

"I know."

Tommaso stepped inside and stood in the middle of the studio as though he had been there a hundred times before. He took in the canvases propped against the wall, the easel, the unfinished sketch pinned above it, the ink-stained table where Michele had been practicing Ottavio's signature until his hand cramped. His gaze rested there a moment longer than it should have.

"You are the painter," he said to Michele.

"Michele."

"You work for the Signore." Not a question.

"I work for whoever pays."

"A practical arrangement." Tommaso turned back to Lorenzo. "His Eminence wishes me to be useful to you. To carry messages, keep your books, sit with you at your table. In his words, 'so that my friend Lorenzo is never alone in his labors.' " The friar's mouth flickered. "He is very solicitous of your welfare."

"I'm grateful for his care," Lorenzo said.

"You should be."

Michele watched Tommaso's hands. They stayed folded. His eyes did not. They moved across the room the way a water rat moves along a bank — quietly, and always toward the same hole. When they settled on the wardrobe where Lorenzo kept his letters, Michele felt the small cold drop of certainty in his stomach.

Tommaso intended to stay.

"Sit, then," Lorenzo said, and gestured to the bench. "You'll want wine."

"No wine. I keep my rule." Tommaso sat at the table, unhurried. "You might continue with your work. I would not want to interrupt a man's livelihood."

They worked. Or pretended to. Michele added a wash of umber to the dried underpainting of a Madonna he would never finish, and Lorenzo wrote letters that meant nothing to anyone, and Tommaso sat between them like a stone dropped in a well, reading nothing, saying nothing, and watching everything. Twice Michele looked up and found the friar's eyes already on him.

It went on like that for two hours.

When Tommaso at last excused himself to attend his prayers — at the chapel of Santa Croce, he said, an easy walk, and did not say when he would return — Lorenzo waited a full count of thirty before he spoke.

"He's an inquisitor," Michele said first.

"He's Borgia's man."

"Which is the same thing." Michele threw his brush down, hard enough that it spattered. "You saw him. He didn't look at the painting. He didn't look at the letters. He looked at the ink."

"Everyone looks at your ink. You make a mess."

"Do not make this into a joke, Lorenzo." Michele crossed to the wardrobe and pulled the forged letter out from beneath the folded linen where it lay. He held it up. "This was four feet from his hand. If he had opened this wardrobe, we would both be in the Bargello by Vespers."

Lorenzo took the letter from him with fingers that were not quite steady, and Michele noticed that, and was afraid in a new way.

"He won't open it tonight," Lorenzo said. "He's new. He'll establish himself first, then go through my effects. He has to report to Borgia in three days. He'll want something worth reporting."

"And tomorrow night is the escape."

"Tomorrow night is the escape."

Michele sat down on the edge of the workbench and put his head in his hands. "Lorenzo. The change of the watch. Ottavio. We have one attempt at this and it's tomorrow, and now the Cardinal has planted a man at your table with an ear for everything you say."

"I know."

"If he sleeps here — "

"He will not. He's under a rule; he'll lodge at Santa Croce and come to me each day." Lorenzo was quiet a moment. "Which means I know when I have him, and when I don't. That is something."

"That is nothing."

"It is not nothing. It means the escape still works. We do it tomorrow, and by the time Tommaso attends me in the morning, Alessandro is already out through the infirmary and onto Cecco's boat, and I am at my table with clean hands and a face of stone, and there is nothing for him or Borgia or Cosimo to find." He said it the way he said everything — flat, certain, as though certainty itself were a kind of armor.

Michele looked at him. "And me?"

"You don't touch the prison. You never set foot near Santa Maria Nuova. If it goes wrong, you were in this room with a brush in your hand all night, and I will swear to it."

"If it goes wrong, they'll have us both."

"Then we go through together, and I will hold the door." Lorenzo almost smiled. "I am told I am difficult to move."

Michele should have answered that with something dry. Instead he stood, crossed the small space between them, and took hold of Lorenzo's sleeve — a small, foolish thing, the way a man grips a rope on a bridge, not because it will hold him but because he has to hold something.

"Be careful with him," Michele said. "That one."

"I intend to be."

At compline, Tommaso returned. And at dawn, he was on the step again, before the bell rang, and let himself in when Lorenzo unbarred the door, and took his seat at the table as though the seat belonged to him. For three days he was there. He walked with Lorenzo to the Signoria. He waited outside while Lorenzo sat with the Cardinal's clerks. He ate bread and figs and left the wine untouched. And each evening he said his prayers at Santa Croce and returned to a bench in the corner of the studio, and sat, and watched, and said nothing, so that the silence itself began to feel like a room filling with water.

On the second evening, Michele caught Tommaso in the little passage behind the plaster furnace, holding the damp, discarded secco sketch Michele had drawn of the prison gate — a scribbled thing from memory, the row of windows, the guard's box, the way the crowd stood. Michele had put it in the fire and the fire had not been hot enough.

Tommaso looked at him over the edge of the paper. "You draw very well."

"It's nothing. A study of the leather market."

"The market has no bars." Tommaso folded the sketch neatly and put it in the breast of his habit. "I'll keep it. It's a handsome piece."

Michele did not kill him. He wanted to. He stood in the passage after Tommaso had gone and pressed his fists against the plaster until the grit cut his knuckles, and understood that the plan was already half-dead and they had not yet begun.

He told Lorenzo that night, in the corner, close, mouths near ears.

"He has the sketch."

"I know. I saw him take it."

"And you did nothing."

"There was nothing to do that would not make it worse." Lorenzo's voice was very quiet. "He will send it to Borgia. Borgia will look at it. That buys us — nothing, or nearly nothing. Borgia does not know my brother is in that prison. Not yet. The sketch alone is a coincidence, a painter's study of a street. But if Tommaso puts the letter-of-passage in that same packet, then it is over."

"He'll find the letter. It's in your wardrobe."

"Then it will not be in my wardrobe by morning." Lorenzo straightened, and Michele saw the decision land in him, like a bird coming down on a branch. "We move tonight."

"Tonight is a day early. Ottavio expects us tomorrow — the bribe, the quiet gate — "

"Then we will not use Ottavio." Lorenzo was already crossing to the wardrobe, drawing out the forged episcopal letter, the wax, the seal. "There is a second way. Brother Anselmo's key opens the chapel passage through the friary wall. I have kept it this whole time and never let myself spend it. We go in from the east, through the chapel, into the lower cells. There is no guard in that passage — only night soil and the friars' drains. It stinks, and it will ruin your coat, and it comes out below the Volognana, and Cecco waits there at the second bell." He paused. "I sent Cecco a word this morning. It was for tomorrow. He is a boatman; a boatman sleeps where his boat sleeps. He will be there."

"And Alessandro? He cannot walk far."

"Then I carry him."

"Lorenzo — "

"Get your things." Lorenzo turned, and there was something in his face Michele had not seen before — not resolve, not fear, but the look of a man throwing the last coin he owns onto the table. "Tonight, Michele. Before Tommaso's next report reaches Cosimo. Before Thursday. Tonight, or we do not get another chance in our lives."

Above them, from the street, came the creak of the outer gate.

Both of them went still. The friar's bench in the corner was empty. The hour was late; Tommaso had said his prayers two hours past and should have been at Santa Croce.

Footsteps crossed the courtyard. Measured. Unhurried. And then at the street door, the knock came — slow, deliberate, four knuckles on oak.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 16: The Cardinal's Shadow · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads