The Painted Lie

Chapter 15: Lorenzo's Secret

The Cardinal came with eleven men.

Michele counted them from the studio window as they crossed the courtyard below—a knot of black cassocks and oiled leather, the great seal-carriage of the Borgia livery rolling behind them on the cobbles. Cardinal Borgia himself rode in a curtained litter, and Michele did not see him step out. Only, a moment later, the bells of the household began to ring, and Lorenzo's voice came up through the floor, quick and level, giving orders.

By the time Michele was dressed and in the antechamber with a clean brush and a prepared sketchbook, the Cardinal was already seated in the great hall, and Lorenzo was bowing to him as if nothing in the world were wrong.

"His Eminence wished to see how the Venetian commissions progress," Lorenzo murmured to the room at large, then turned back. "I am honored."

"Are you?" Borgia's voice was low and pleasant, the voice of a man who never had to raise it. He was younger than Michele had expected—forty, perhaps, with a beautiful, bloodless face and hands that lay on his lap like folded silk. "Show me."

Michele was led forward with his book, and he showed the Cardinal what he was meant to show: the studies for the palace altarpiece, the martyrdoms and the Ascensions, all of them lifeless. Borgia looked for a long time at one sheet and said, "You have good hands. Where did you train?"

"Here and there, Eminence."

"He is modest," Lorenzo said. "He is also mine. I keep his hands for my own work."

The Cardinal's eyes moved from the drawings to Lorenzo's face, and stayed there. "Yes," he said. "You keep a great many things."

Michele had been taught, in the years when he was younger and hungrier, to make himself invisible in rooms where the powerful talked. He stood at the edge of the light, turned his book sideways as if studying it, and listened.

For an hour the talk was of pigments and patens, of the Pope's health and the new tax on alum. Then the Cardinal rose and said, "I would see the garden," and the household scattered to make the garden ready, and Michele found himself in an alcove off the long gallery, half-hidden by a hanging, with Lorenzo and Borgia a few paces away and clearly believing themselves alone.

"You are too calm," Borgia said.

"Should I not be?"

"Alessandro." The name was dropped like a stone in water. Michele felt his stomach turn over. "Two of my men watched the leather quarter for six days. They report a young painter asking questions of a bookbinder. They report that he came to the prison gate and stood in a crowd of relatives, and did not get in, and did not leave for a quarter of an hour. And that same painter sleeps in your house and touches up your altarpiece. What am I to make of that?"

"Nothing," Lorenzo said. "He is a boy who buys vellum from Niccolò. As to the prison—I send him out to sketch the market for a background. He is a fool who likes faces. That is all."

"Is it."

"Your Eminence has my word."

"Your word." Borgia's voice did not change, but something underneath it did, some wire drawn tight. "You will forgive me, Lorenzo, if I find your word a somewhat elastic commodity. You have a great capacity for holding things back. A capacity for arrangement. Do you know the arrangement I have spent months imagining? I imagine a man whose brother is officially dead, and who keeps that particular resurrection up his sleeve, in case a bishop's ring should ever be dangled before him."

The silence went on long enough that Michele thought Borgia had won. Then Lorenzo laughed—low, easy, exactly the laugh he used with creditors.

"Eminence, if I had such a brother I would have sold him to you the first week. I am not a man of patience."

"No?"

"No. If I had anything against you, you would have seen it already. I am, unfortunately, too transparent."

"Perhaps." Borgia's tone shifted, mildly. "Then tell me something transparent. The painter. Who is he?"

And here Lorenzo paused. Michele heard the pause, and understood it instantly: Lorenzo was deciding, in the space of two heartbeats, how to make Michele small.

"He is a spy I keep," Lorenzo said.

Michele's hand closed on the edge of the hanging.

"One of mine," Lorenzo went on, easily, the words rolling out of him as if they had all been written the night before. "A little creature, nothing—he came to me from a workshop in San Frediano, and I let him stay because he is useful and cheap and does what he is told. I put him in the studios of two men I wished to know about. I put him in the brothels where certain of your rivals drink. I let him carry drawings to the leather quarter, and I let him stand outside the prison gate, because I wished to learn who else is watching it, and how they are watched. He reports to me on Sundays. You cannot be surprised, Eminence. You keep spies. Every man of any weight in this city keeps spies. I merely keep a poor one, because I cannot afford a better."

Michele stood in the alcove and felt his face go hot and then cold. He did not move.

Borgia laughed. It was a colder sound than Lorenzo's, and apparently genuine. "You keep a spy and you tell me so. How honest of you."

"Honesty is a tax I pay to be left alone."

"And what do you feed him? The painter."

"Whatever is left in the kitchen. He is grateful."

"Then he is a good investment. See that he is not a bad one. If I hear of this painter at any gate that interests me, I will conclude that he is a spy, and I will conclude that you are not, and I will deal with him instead. You understand the difference."

"I understand it very well."

They walked on, and their voices faded into the garden door, and Michele stood behind the hanging for a long, nauseous minute before he moved.

He found his way out by the kitchen stair. In the passage he passed two of the Cardinal's men, who looked at him the way one looks at a chair. He went to the studio and stood with his back against the door, and waited.

Lorenzo came after midnight.

Michele had lit one lamp and set it in the middle of the table, and had the inkstone out, and had pretended for two hours to be cleaning brushes that did not need cleaning. He did not look up when the door opened.

"That was quick," Michele said. "Your Eminence."

Lorenzo shut the door. He stood on the other side of the table, and did not sit. In the lamplight his face was gray with something Michele had never seen on him—not fear, but exhaustion, the kind that comes after a lie has been held in the mouth too long.

"You heard."

"I was behind the hangings. You know I was behind the hangings. You put me there."

"I did not—" Lorenzo stopped himself. He put both hands flat on the table, and looked at them. "No. I knew where you would be. Yes. I did. But I did not know what I would have to say."

"You called me a spy. A poor one. You said you feed me from the kitchen."

"To keep you alive."

"To keep *you* alive."

"Yes." Lorenzo looked up. There was no apology in his face, and that, somehow, was worse than if there had been. "That is what I did. Borgia came to test whether you were mine. If I had said you were a guest—a student—a friend—he would have had you in the Bargello by Thursday. He would have put the question to you in a room with a rope in it. And you would have answered, Michele, because everyone answers. So I made you useless. I made you a spy who answers to me, so that anything you have done points back at me and not at Alessandro, because a man is allowed to be careless with a spy. A man is not allowed to be careless with a brother."

"I stood in the courtyard of your own house and was called a farm animal."

"You stood in the courtyard of my own house and the Cardinal of Monreale did not look at you twice. That was the point."

"So it was a lie."

"Everything I said tonight was a lie."

Michele set the brush down. The handle clicked on the wood. "Then the kiss was a lie too."

The silence that followed was different from the earlier one. Lorenzo did not answer quickly. He came around the table, and stopped within a hand's width, and looked at Michele with an expression that was almost anger.

"The kiss was an error," he said quietly. "You know that. I told you that. But it was not the kind of error you think. It was not a mistake of the body." His voice dropped. "It was a mistake of a man who has spent three years telling lies to keep one person breathing, and who briefly, in a kitchen at night, forgot which lies he was holding."

"Which am I," Michele said. "A lie you are holding, or a person?"

"Both," Lorenzo said. "There is no third thing in my life."

He turned away and went to the window. Down in the courtyard, the Cardinal's livery men were still posted at the gate, torches burning in their hands. The seal-carriage had not been drawn away.

Michele understood, looking at them, what had actually happened in the hall. Borgia had not been bluffed. He had been given a gift—a name, a face, a small crooked painter with ink on his fingers—and he had taken it, and left men behind to see whether the gift was real.

"He left someone," Michele said.

"Four men. Friar Tommaso to attend me in the mornings, so he says. He rides back to Rome in three days."

"Then the escape is not tomorrow at the change of the watch."

Lorenzo turned. "It cannot be. If I move tomorrow, the friar moves with me."

Michele looked at the lamp, at the little circle of light it threw on the table, at the inkstone, at the half-prepared sheets of paper that were meant to save Alessandro's life. And then, quietly, he heard himself say the thing that had been forming in him since he stood behind the hanging.

"Then it has to be tonight. Or it has to be before he rides." He looked up. "And you have to decide which of your lies is true, Lorenzo. Because if I am your spy, then the Cardinal's men are watching me, and I cannot walk into Santa Maria Nuova. And if I am not your spy—"

"If you are not my spy," Lorenzo said, very low, "then you are the only true thing I have, and I have just put you in the mouth of the wolf."

The knock came then, from the street door. Twelve strikes, slow, in a rhythm Michele now knew too well.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 15: Lorenzo's Secret · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads