The water was cold enough to stop feeling like water and start feeling like glass, cutting at Michele's hands as he hauled on the oar. Cecco had been at the landing after all—drunk, complaining, but there. He'd taken one look at the blood soaking through Alessandro's shirt and decided not to ask questions, which Michele supposed was the closest thing to mercy a man like Cecco ever offered.
Now the boat slid under the Ponte alla Carraia and Cecco killed the lantern, and the dark came down over them like a lid.
"How is he?" Lorenzo whispered. He was bent over Alessandro in the stern, one hand pressed flat against the wound, the other braced against the gunwale. His guard's tunic was ruined, black with wet and redder than black where the blood had spread.
"Still breathing." Michele shipped the oar and crawled aft. Alessandro's face was slack, the skin around his mouth grey as tallow. A nasty slice along his ribs, from the shoulder down under the arm—the kind of wound a man took turning away from a blade. "How far to the house?"
"Volognana's behind us. We go up the Mugnone and leave the boat at the mill." Lorenzo's voice was flat with effort. "Maddalena's kin keep a room above a dyer's shop. She owes me."
"She owes you." Michele got his arms under Alessandro's shoulders. "For what?"
"For not asking what she owes me for."
They carried him up the bank with the water running off them, three men shambling through the reeds like something out of a bad play. The dyer's shop smelled of indigo and lye, and the stairs behind it were so narrow Michele's shoulders scraped both walls. The room above held a straw pallet, a table, a single horn window giving onto the dye yard. No hearth. No crucifix. The kind of room a man rented when he didn't want God or the neighbors keeping count of his visitors.
Lorenzo laid Alessandro on the pallet and stood back, and for a moment neither of them said anything. Then Michele got to work.
He cut the shirt away with Lorenzo's knife, which was still tacky with blood, and cleaned the wound with the last of the wine from Cecco's flask. Alessandro hissed through his teeth but didn't wake. The cut was long but shallow at the deepest point—the blade had skated off a rib instead of going between them. Michele pressed clean rags from his own sleeve against it and held them there, counting his own heartbeat until the bleeding slowed to a seep.
"Thread," he said.
Lorenzo produced a needle and a spool of waxed linen from inside his boot, wrapped in oilcloth. Michele looked at it a moment too long.
"You carry a surgeon's kit to a prison break."
"I carry it everywhere," Lorenzo said. "Florence is a city of blades."
Michele sewed. Four stitches, small and neat, the way his master had taught him to mend a canvas from the back. Alessandro's chest rose and fell under his hands, each breath a small animal struggling against the weight on top of it. Up close, Michele could see the ink stains on his fingers—not paint, not charcoal, but the fine blue-black of a copyist. The man had been a scholar. Everyone had said so, and Michele had pictured something like Lorenzo: fine hands, fine manners, a man who knew which fork to use at the Medici table.
He had not pictured this. He had not pictured a man whose ribs showed through his skin like the ribs of a lute.
"Michele." Lorenzo was at the window, holding the shutter barely open with two fingers. "Someone walked past the yard twice."
"Watchman?"
"Watchman walks once an hour. This man walks when he likes."
Michele tied off the last stitch and sat back on his heels. The room was very quiet. Below them, somewhere in the dark of the dye yard, water dripped steadily into a vat.
Alessandro's eyes opened.
They went wide first—the animal panic of a man who didn't know the room—and then they found Michele's face and settled by degrees, the way a dog settles when it recognizes a voice.
"You," Alessandro said.
"Lie still."
"Your name is—the painter. Lorenzo's painter." He turned his head toward the window, and something crossed his face that Michele hadn't expected: not relief, but calculation. "Both of you. Then it's real."
"It's real," Lorenzo said from the window. "Three stitches deep and a boat ride down the Mugnone real. Can you sit?"
Alessandro tried. Michele caught him when he swayed, and the man's hand closed on Michele's wrist with a strength that surprised them both.
"Listen," Alessandro said. "Before I lose the thread of it. I have to tell someone who'll remember."
"Rest—"
"No." The grip tightened. "You think they put me in the Stinche for a debt. Everyone thinks that. Sweet Christ, half the scholars think it." He laughed, and the laugh turned into a cough that brought fresh red to the rag on his side. "I was arrested for books. Three of them. A Greek Plato that Marsilio Ficino's copyist swore didn't exist. A Luther tract that came through Venice in a wine barrel. And a commentary—" He stopped, searching for the words. "A commentary on the Donation of Constantine. Anonymous. Printed in Basel."
Michele didn't understand half of it, but he understood the way Alessandro said Basel. Like the word itself was a nail.
"Books," Michele said. "They put a man in a cell for books."
"They put a man in a cell for questions." Alessandro's eyes were glassy now, going out. "The books were only the paper the questions were written on. They say—in Basel they say—that the Donation is a forgery. That the whole foundation, the whole claim that the Church was given the West to rule—a clerk's lie, written down eight hundred years ago to frighten a king." He smiled, and it was a terrible thing to see on a face that pale. "I copied it out. Fourteen pages. That's the crime. Fourteen pages, and Borgia's men knew my handwriting before I knew they had my name."
Nobody spoke. The water dripped in the yard.
"You think," Michele said slowly, "that they'd kill a man for copying a page."
"I think they'd kill a man for reading it." Alessandro's hand fell away from Michele's wrist and lay on the pallet, open. "I think they'd kill anyone who remembered it. And now you've both read my face and heard my voice, so you're in the book too."
He coughed again, smaller this time, and his eyes closed. His breathing evened out. Michele sat on the floor with the bloody rag still in his hands and listened to it until he was sure it would keep going.
Lorenzo closed the shutter and came and crouched beside him.
"He'll live," Lorenzo said. Not a question.
"He'll live if the wound doesn't turn. If nobody finds him. If he doesn't decide to be a martyr in the meantime, which he seems to have some talent for." Michele dropped the rag. "Fourteen pages."
"Michele."
"Do you know what my master used to say? That a painter's hands are cleanest when they hold nothing but paint. I thought he meant don't spill the oil. I was eleven." He looked up. "Fourteen pages, Lorenzo. That's three portraits. A man spends fourteen pages of ink and they chain him in a hole and put a fever on him for a week, and we dress up as guards and tell ourselves we're saving a scholar, and all we've really done is—"
"We've done one true thing," Lorenzo said. "In a city made of lies, one true thing a night is a good night's work."
Michele wanted to hit him. Instead he wiped his hands on his thighs and stood up, because if he stayed on the floor he was going to say more than he meant, and they didn't have the room for it.
"Bandages," he said. "He'll bleed through these by morning. Where do the Maddalena kin keep their linen?"
"Below. The shop has a chest of rags behind the vats."
"Then in the morning I'll go. Not tonight—your walker out there is still walking." He moved to the table and turned the wick of the oil lamp down to nothing, so the room fell back into the color of the window. "You take the first watch. Wake me at the third bell."
Lorenzo caught his sleeve as he passed.
"When I said you were my spy," Lorenzo said, very low, "to the Cardinal—"
"Don't." Michele pulled his arm free, gently, and lay down on the floor with his back to the wall and his eyes on the door. "Not tonight. There's a man's blood in my hands and it isn't paint."
He heard Lorenzo settle against the other wall, and then the room went quiet except for Alessandro's breathing and the drip in the yard, one, and then another, and then another, like a clock that had decided it no longer trusted the hour.
Near dawn Michele woke to the sound of the shutter banging. Lorenzo was at the window, one hand flat against the wall, head bent. The walker was gone. But there was a lantern moving in the dye yard, low, weaving between the vats—someone with a light and no hurry, checking.
"That's not a watchman," Lorenzo said. "That's a man reading the water."
The lantern stopped at the bank. Then it turned and started up the outside stairs.