The Painted Lie

Chapter 19: The Locked Chest

The figure on the stairs stopped halfway up. Michele heard the creak of a boot on the third step, then nothing. Beside him, Lorenzo had already slid a knife from his sleeve. Alessandro lay on the pallet with his eyes half open, fever-bright, one hand pressed to the stitched wound at his side.

A voice came through the door, low and female. "Lorenzo. It's me. Put the knife away."

Lorenzo exhaled and opened the door. A woman in a dark cloak stepped in, carrying the lantern low so the light wouldn't show at the window. Grey hair, a jaw like a hatchet — Maddalena's aunt, the one who kept the dye works below. She looked at Alessandro, then at the blood on Michele's hands, and said nothing about any of it.

"He needs fresh linen," she said. "Boiled, not the rags you've got there. I'll bring it before the bells. And you" — she pointed at Lorenzo — "don't stand in my yard again in daylight. The whole quarter saw you come in."

She left the way she came. Lorenzo barred the door and stood with his back against it for a moment, and Michele watched him and thought: she knows exactly who he is, and she isn't afraid of him, which means she has seen worse than him.

"They'll be hunting the streets by now," Lorenzo said. "Tommaso will have raised the alarm the moment he found the cell empty."

"He was at the door when we left. He saw us."

"He saw two guards in the dark. He'll guess. Guessing and proving are different things." Lorenzo crossed to the pallet and knelt, checking the bandage at Alessandro's side. Alessandro's breathing had gone shallow and even. "He'll sleep now. That's good."

"Lorenzo." Michele kept his voice low. "There's blood on my sleeves, my hands, my boots. We can't go back to the studio tonight."

"No. We go at first light, before the market, when everyone is carrying something and no one looks at anyone. You'll clean up at the well behind Santa Croce. I'll say I was called out to a patron and you were with me."

"And the guard, Ottavio? He's still waiting for money that isn't coming."

Lorenzo's face didn't change. "Ottavio will talk. It's only a question of when and to whom."

They sat the rest of the night in the dark, not talking, listening to Alessandro's breathing and the occasional drip from the dye vats below. Michele tried not to look at Lorenzo, which meant he looked at Lorenzo constantly. At dawn the aunt returned with the boiled linen and a pot of thin broth, and by the time the sun cleared the roofs they were moving — separate streets, same destination.

The studio smelled of turpentine and cold ash. Michele washed at the basin until the water ran pink, then grey, then clear. He changed his shirt and burned the old one in the small brazier, and the smoke smelled of iron.

Lorenzo locked the street door and drew the shutters. "We sleep in shifts today. Tonight I'll go to the Volognana landing and find Cecco. He wasn't at the second bell — I need to know why."

"You think he was followed."

"I think he wasn't there, which is either cowardice or danger, and both matter."

Michele nodded toward the inner room. "Alessandro needs a proper physician. The stitch will hold, but if the wound turns—"

"No physician. Not yet. Every physician in Florence is a man who talks." Lorenzo pulled off his doublet and hung it on the stand. "Find the bandages in the chest by the window. The aunt's linen is good but we'll want more."

So Michele went to the chest by the window. It was plain, unremarkable, half hidden under a folded drape. He lifted the lid — and it didn't open. Not stuck. Locked. A small iron lock, new, without a scratch on it, set into wood that looked older than the lock by a century.

He pulled the chest out into the light. Bandages, needle, thread — all the things the studio needed daily — and it was the only chest in the room besides the paint cabinet, which stood open. He tried the lid again. Solid.

Behind him, Lorenzo's voice: "Not that one."

Michele turned. Lorenzo had come to the doorway of the inner room and was looking at the chest, and then at Michele, and his face had gone very still in a way Michele was beginning to recognize — the face of a man deciding which lie to tell.

"Where do you keep the bandages, then?"

"The cabinet. Bottom shelf. I forgot."

Michele didn't move. "You forgot that the chest where you keep your bandages is locked?"

"I keep rags in there, not bandages." Lorenzo crossed the room, took Michele by the elbow — not roughly, but with purpose — and steered him to the paint cabinet. "Here."

Michele took the bandages. He did not stop looking at the chest.

"What's in it?"

"Old commissions. Things I don't want ruined."

"There's nothing ruined about a locked chest, Lorenzo. Ruined things you'd keep in the open and forget. Locked things you keep locked because someone might look."

Lorenzo's jaw tightened. "You've known me three weeks and you've already decided what I am."

"I've decided nothing. I'm asking you a question."

"And I'm telling you it's none of your business."

There it was. Michele set the bandages down on the table, slowly, and wiped his hands on the cloth. The studio was quiet except for a cart passing somewhere in the street below.

"I broke into a prison for you last night," Michele said. "I put my hands inside a dying man for you. I let you tell a cardinal I'm your creature. But a chest in your own study is none of my business."

"It's not the same."

"No. It's smaller, and you still won't answer." Michele walked to the chest and crouched beside it. The lock was small but well made, the kind that came from a locksmith on the Via dei Calzaiuoli who charged more than Michele earned in a month. "Who has the key?"

"Me."

"And when you sleep?"

"I don't sleep much."

"Convenient." Michele stood. His voice had gone flat without his meaning it to. "You know what I keep thinking? I keep thinking about the letter. The one with the bishop's seal. It was so good that the man who reads it would have to be a fool to doubt it. And I keep thinking that a man who can arrange for a document like that, and a key like that, and a woman in a dye yard who isn't afraid of him — that man has practice. That man has done this before. And I don't know what 'this' is."

Lorenzo looked at him for a long moment. Something moved behind his eyes — a flicker, the barest crack in the surface — and for one second Michele thought he was about to answer.

Then Lorenzo said, "Get some sleep. I'll take the first watch."

He turned and walked to the window and stood there with his back to the room, looking out through the shutter slats at the street, and Michele knew the conversation was over.

He slept badly, in fits, on the studio cot, and woke in the afternoon to find Lorenzo gone and a note on the table in his cramped hand: *Volognana. Back by dark. Keep the door barred.*

Michele barred the door. Then he stood in the middle of the studio and looked at the chest.

He could break it. A chisel and two minutes. But Lorenzo would know the moment he came back, and whatever was inside would matter less than the breaking of it, and Michele was not ready to spend that. Not yet. He was not sure he could afford Lorenzo as an enemy. He was not sure, if it came to it, that he wanted Lorenzo as one either.

So he did what he could. He went to Alessandro, changed the bandage while he slept, and found the wound edges clean, no angry red spreading under the skin. The old man's breathing had steadied. That was something. That was one thing in this house that didn't lie to him.

When Lorenzo returned at dusk, the first thing he did — before he took off his cloak, before he spoke — was glance at the chest. It hadn't moved. Michele had put it back exactly.

"Cecco?" Michele asked.

"Gone to Pisa. Two days ago, before we even sent word." Lorenzo hung up his cloak. "Which means my letter never reached him, or it reached someone else."

"Then who took the boat?"

"A man named Ricci. A friend. He's owed me a while." Lorenzo sat down heavily. "It's worse than Cecco. On my way back I passed the Bargello. There's a notice posted. A reward for information on two men seen leaving the prison with a prisoner. Guards' livery. One of them taller, one who left a smear of blood on the cell door."

Michele's mouth went dry. "Blood."

"The wound bled before we moved him. I didn't see it." Lorenzo's voice was level, and that was somehow worse than if it had shaken. "They have a description of us. And they have Tommaso, who saw us in the corridor, and who now has every reason to put names to those descriptions."

"Then we have to move Alessandro tonight."

"We can't. He can't be carried through streets that are already being watched. The dye works is safe for now — it's a cellar of a cellar, and Maddalena's kin lie for a living." Lorenzo rubbed his eyes. "But there's something else. I need to see a man about you. Tomorrow."

"About me."

"You asked what I do. What all of this is." Lorenzo looked up at him, and for the first time since the chest, his eyes were open the whole way. "I can't tell you in a locked room with a locked chest in it. You'd be right not to believe me. So tomorrow I'll show you. There are others. People who believe what Alessandro believes, that the Donation is a forgery and the Church is built on a lie, and who have been paying for that belief with their lives for longer than you've been drawing."

Michele said nothing. The studio felt smaller than it had that morning.

"Come with me tomorrow," Lorenzo said. "And when you've seen them, you can ask me about the chest again. I'll answer then. I give you my word."

"You gave the Cardinal your word about me, too," Michele said. "You gave me a lie and called it protection."

Lorenzo flinched. Almost nothing — a tightening at the corner of the eye — but Michele saw it, and filed it away, and hated himself a little for filing it away.

"Tomorrow," Lorenzo said.

Michele looked at the locked chest in the corner, and at the man who wouldn't open it, and at the reward notice he could picture hanging on the wall of the Bargello with a smear of his own blood described in a clerk's handwriting.

"Tomorrow," he said. "And you'd better be right about them. Because if you're not" — he picked up his cloak — "I'm not the only thing you'll have lied to."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 19: The Locked Chest · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads