They climbed the stairs in the dark, and Michele counted them — fourteen, the same fourteen as the night before, when he had stitched Alessandro's side by candlelight and thought the worst of it was behind them.
Lorenzo set the lamp on the bench. Below, through the floorboards, came the slow knock of the dyer's paddle in its vat, steady as a heartbeat.
"Say it," Michele said.
"Say what?"
"You knew." Michele had kept it banked all through the rest of the meeting — Contessa Beatrice's careful voice, the agenda of names and alms and grain routes, Fra' Domenico sitting with his hands folded like a man at prayer. Now it came up his throat like bile. "You knew who he was before you led me into that room. You knew what he did to Paolo."
Lorenzo sat down on the edge of the pallet and put his hands on his knees. He did not look away, which was somehow worse.
"Yes," he said.
"Then don't dress it up."
"I won't."
"Good." Michele heard his own voice go thin. "Because I've had enough dressing-up this month to last me."
Lorenzo nodded slowly, as though agreeing with a verdict, and that nod — calm, reasonable, unafraid — was the thing that finally lit the fuse.
"How long?"
"A year. Perhaps more. Since the first time he came north."
"A year." Michele laughed, and it came out wrong, a raw scrape of sound. "You've been using him a year."
"Using is your word."
"It's the true one. He informed on Paolo in front of men who would have burned him, and now he sits at your table and says grace, and you pass him bread." Michele took a step forward. "Do you know what Paolo taught me? I was eleven years old. I had no father worth the name. He took me in for the price of sweeping his floor, and he told me the difference between a true line and a flattering one, and he said —" His voice cracked and he pushed on through it. "He said the only sin in paint is to make a thing look better than God made it."
"That's a fine creed for a workshop," Lorenzo said.
"Don't."
"I mean it as praise."
"I know what you mean it as." Michele turned away, then turned back; he could not hold still. The lamp guttered between them. "He's why I'm here. Not this room, not the prison — this. The whole of it. I came into your hands because a friar decided my master was a heretic for drawing a woman's shoulder honestly."
Lorenzo's jaw worked once. "And if I told you it wasn't so simple?"
"Then be simple for once in your life."
"All right." Lorenzo stood. He was taller than Michele, and when he stopped slouching he used it. "Domenico testified. He testified badly, and he testified for money, and the money went to a cardinal's nephew who wanted Paolo's commission. Paolo lost his workshop, his name, and — yes — his life, though it took him six years to finish dying. Do you think I don't know that?"
"You just said it. Now tell me why he's welcome under this roof."
"Because he came back." Lorenzo's voice stayed level, which was its own kind of cruelty. "Eighteen months ago, weeping, at the door of a man he had never met, offering everything he knew about the men who bought him. He has given us the names of four informers, the courier system out of Bologna, and the fact that the Duke's secretary keeps a copy of every letter he burns. He gave us Alessandro's cell block."
"And Paolo is still dead."
"He is."
"So the ledger balances, does it?" Michele felt heat behind his eyes and refused it. "You weighed a dead man against four live ones and called it justice."
"I called it arithmetic. Justice is a thing you do with what you have."
"That's what every man says who has nothing left to do with."
There was a silence. Below, the paddle knocked. Somewhere over the roofs a bell struck the quarter-hour, and Michele heard, absurdly, the exact note of it.
"You should have told me," he said, quieter.
"Yes."
"When? On the stairs? In the yard? Or were you going to let me find out when he asked me to hold the brush?"
"I thought—" Lorenzo stopped. Started again. "I thought you'd understand."
The words landed like a slap.
"You thought I'd understand."
"Yes."
"Understand what, exactly?" Michele heard his voice climb and did not stop it. "That the men who ruined my master are useful now? That I'm meant to sit in a room full of assassins and widows and noblewomen playing at charity and smile at the one who signed the paper? That because I paint your forgeries I've forfeited the right to grieve?"
"Nobody said you'd forfeited—"
"You did. Every time you didn't tell me." Michele flung a hand at the locked chest under the bench. "You kept that from me too. Alessandro's brother's letters, three men on the gallows, and I hear it only when it's dropped on me like a stone. There's a pattern here, Lorenzo. You decide what I'm fit to know, and you decide it for my own good, and every time it costs me something and you keep your face like a locked door."
Lorenzo's mouth tightened. "That's not—"
"It is exactly that. You've made me a liar for a cause I believe in, and now you want me to be a liar for a man who killed my father."
"He isn't your father."
"He's the closest thing I had, and you didn't even have the courtesy to warn me." Michele pressed both palms to his eyes, hard, until the room went red and grainy, then dropped them. "The Contessa has me painting a dead woman's face onto a living stranger's passport, and the friar who hanged Paolo is going to stand in the corner while I do it. Do you see it? Do you see what you've built me into?"
"I see a man who can move four people out of Florence on a brushstroke," Lorenzo said. "That's not nothing. That's—"
"It's the same thing, only prettier." Michele laughed again, short. "You're a Borgia man through and through and I never saw it until tonight. You don't save people. You spend them."
Lorenzo's hand closed on the bench edge. For one heartbeat something moved under his face that Michele had never seen there — not anger, something colder and more frightened — and then it was gone, and his voice came out very even.
"You think I don't pay? You think I don't know what I've signed my name to?" He took a step. "I took an oath at nineteen in a cellar with four candles and a man who is now charcoal in the Piazza. I have spent eight years being the hand that moves the pieces. Do you imagine I like it?"
"I imagine you're good at it."
"Yes," Lorenzo said. "God forgive me. Yes."
The candor should have disarmed him. Instead it made Michele furious all over again, because it was the first honest sentence Lorenzo had offered in weeks and it cost him nothing.
"So be good at it," Michele said. "But don't ask me to be glad."
"I'm not asking you to be glad. I'm asking you to hold."
"Hold."
"Five days. Maybe six. The portrait, the passage, the letters out of the city, and then the whole thing collapses into a boat at Livorno and you never have to look at Domenico again."
"And if I say no?"
Lorenzo looked at him for a long moment. The lamp was low now; the room had gone the color of old bronze.
"Then I'll find another painter," he said. "There are four in Florence who could get the green right. I'd lose a week. I'd likely lose Alessandro. And I would not blame you."
Michele waited for the threat to arrive. It didn't. That, he realized, was the worst thing Lorenzo had done all night — because it meant Lorenzo understood precisely what he was asking, and was asking it anyway, and there was no knife he could put to Michele's ribs half so effective as leaving him free.
"You'd let him die for it."
"I'd let him die for it," Lorenzo agreed. "And I'd sit with him while he did, and I'd tell him the truth about why. Which is more than anyone in this city has ever done for you."
Michele turned and looked at the locked chest under the bench, small and iron-banded, and at his own hands hanging at his sides — painter's hands, honest hands, small green-stained knuckles, hands that had that afternoon sketched a bride who did not exist.
The bell went the half-hour.
"Tomorrow," Michele said.
"Tomorrow what?"
"I'll finish the panel." He heard how flat he sounded, like a man reading off a list. "Not for you. Not for her. For Alessandro, and for the nine hundred who'll come after, and if I damned well have to paint the Devil's own face to move one man out of a Borgia cell, then I'll do it and hate every hour of it."
Lorenzo exhaled, and only then did Michele see how tightly he'd been holding the bench.
"Thank you."
"Don't." Michele picked up the lamp, which threw both their shadows huge against the plaster. "Because now you hear the rest. When the painting's done, you and I are going to sit in a room, and you are going to open that chest, and you are going to tell me every single thing you've decided I wasn't fit to know. Beginning with Maddalena. Beginning with the boat that was never Cecco's. Beginning with whatever you think you're protecting me from that you've decided to protect me from by lying."
Lorenzo did not answer.
"And tonight," Michele said, "I'm going to sleep on the other side of the room."
He carried the lamp to the far corner and set it on the floor. Behind him Lorenzo said his name once, quiet, the way a man tests whether a door is locked. Michele did not turn around. He lay down on the boards with his coat over him and listened to the paddle in the vat, still knocking, still steady, and understood that nothing had been settled at all — only laid out on the table like instruments before a surgery.
The lamp gave up. In the dark, Lorenzo's voice came from across the room, almost too low to hear.
"The sketch you made today," he said. "Of the widow. Burn it before morning."
"Why?"
"Because a Bargello man came to the dyer's door an hour before we got back," Lorenzo said. "Asking for the Florentine painter who mixes his greens too light."