The Painted Lie

Chapter 21: The Revelation

The house rose four stories above a wool dyer's yard, its uppermost room hung with sheets that had been boiled white and now dried in the weak morning sun. Contessa Beatrice's woman had brought Michele here by a route he could not have retraced: across the Ponte alla Carraia, through two courtyards, up a stair that smelled of lye and stale indigo.

Inside, six people waited around a trestle table. Lorenzo stood at the window with his back to the room. A notary Michele recognized from the Mercato Vecchio sat with his hands folded. Two men in workmen's aprons whispered together. And in the far corner, half in shadow, sat a Dominican in a patched habit, a book open on his knees.

"—Fra' Domenico has been with us three weeks," Beatrice was saying. "He came out of Bologna with nothing but his breviary and a copy of Valla. The Signoria would hang him for the Valla alone."

The friar looked up.

Michele stopped walking.

It was the face. Older, thinner, silvered at the temples, but the face was the same one he had seen across the refectory of Santa Maria Novella eleven years before, when he was fourteen and his master's hands were still steady enough to grind their own colors. He remembered the voice most clearly: calm, courteous, and merciless, reciting the articles of accusation while Maestro Paolo stood against the wall and did not defend himself.

"You," Michele said.

The room went quiet.

Fra' Domenico closed the book. "You have the advantage of me, young man."

"You testified at Santa Maria Novella. In the year 'ninety-four. Against Maestro Paolo di Gherardo, who kept a workshop on Via dei Servi and taught me to mix vermilion when I was nine years old."

The friar's expression did not change, and that was the worst of it. He inclined his head. "I remember the case."

"You remember the case." Michele's voice came out flat and strange. "He was sixty-two years old. He never wrote a word against the Church in his life. He painted altar panels for San Marco. And you stood up and said he had spoken against the Donation, that he kept books, that he had called the Pope's authority a forgery—"

"I said what he said."

"He was old and half-deaf and you were his confessor—"

"I was his confessor," Fra' Domenico said quietly, "and he told me in the sacrament what he believed. I did not report it. Another did. What I said at the tribunal, I said under summons, in the plainest terms I could manage, and I said it because if I had refused, they would have taken the whole convent, and every man in it."

"He died in the Stinche."

"He died in the Stinche," the friar agreed. "I have prayed for him every day since. It has not brought him back."

Michele turned to Lorenzo. "You brought me here to meet him."

"I brought you here to meet the network."

"You knew who he was."

Lorenzo's face was careful. "I knew there was a Domenico who had given evidence once. I did not know it was the man from your master's case until the contessa told me yesterday, and by then it was too late to keep you away without telling you why, and I—" He stopped. "I thought you should judge him yourself."

"That's generous." Michele laughed, one short ugly sound. "You thought I should sit in a room and be told to paint for him."

"Sit down, both of you," Beatrice said. Her voice carried no particular warmth. "This is not a chapel and we do not have time for the sacrament of the dying."

Michele did not sit. He looked at the friar. "What do you want painted?"

Fra' Domenico set the book aside and rose. He was tall, and moved like a man who had spent his life in cloisters where every movement was observed. "A portrait of a woman who never existed. She is to be the widow of a Venetian merchant, and she must have a face that a customs officer will accept on a safe-conduct, and a look that will not be remembered. I am told you can do this."

"You are told."

"I am told you are good."

"Maestro Paolo was good." Michele heard his own voice rise and did not care. "Maestro Paolo was good, and you said eleven words about him in a court, and the eleven words were enough. You and I are not going to make a painting together."

"Michele." Lorenzo had come away from the window. "Three people die in Ferrara next month if that document doesn't cross the border."

"Then find another hand."

"There is no other hand."

"Then let it be a bad painting. Let it be caught."

The notary shifted at the table and looked away. One of the workmen muttered something to his neighbor. Michele felt the room tilt against him—these were not enemies, he knew that, these were people who had lost as much as he had, and still the sight of the friar's calm face made his chest hot and tight.

Fra' Domenico crossed the room. Up close he smelled of wool and old paper. "Maestro Paolo," he said, "asked me to hear his confession in the last week of his life. I went. I was not permitted to give him absolution, because I was the witness against him. I sat with him in the cell and we prayed the Paternoster and he told me he forgave me, and I did not want to be forgiven. That is the whole of what I can offer you. It is not a defense."

"No," Michele said. "It is not."

He walked down the stair. On the third landing Lorenzo caught his sleeve.

"Michele—"

"Don't." Michele pulled free, not hard, but enough. "You have a locked chest in the studio that you won't open. You told me I was your spy and then I wasn't. You owe Maddalena and her kin for something you won't name. And now there's a man in that room who killed my master, and you want me to sit down with a board and paint for him like it's a commission from a rich widow."

Lorenzo did not answer for a moment. Then, quietly: "If I told you everything, you would have to choose between keeping it and doing the work. I would rather you do the work."

"Because the work matters."

"Because people die."

"People died before," Michele said. "Maestro Paolo died. It didn't seem to bother anyone's cause." He started down again.

Behind him, Lorenzo said, "The chest has letters in it. From Alessandro's brother. If they are found, three more men hang." A pause. "Now you know. And now you have to carry it."

Michele stopped on the stair. He did not turn around.

"Come back up," Lorenzo said. "Not for me. For the woman in Ferrara."

Michele stood there, hand on the damp stone, listening to the sheets snap in the yard below and the far-off sound of a bell ringing the hour at Santo Spirito. From the room above, he could hear the friar's voice, low and unhurried, saying something about the border road. He thought about his master's hands, palm-stained with madder, folding themselves in his lap while the friar recited the articles.

He thought about a woman in Ferrara whose name he did not know.

"I'll paint your widow," he said, to the stairs. "But not for him. He can leave the room while I work, and he can leave the city when it's done, and if I ever see his face again I will say so out loud in the street."

He heard Lorenzo exhale. "It can be arranged."

"Then it's arranged." Michele climbed the last step and stopped in the doorway. Fra' Domenico was standing with the breviary open again, not reading. The notary was already pulling paper toward him, and someone had set a board and a stick of charcoal on the trestle and cleared a space beside it, as if they had known all along he would come back up.

Which, Michele thought, was probably exactly what they had known.

"One more thing," he said. "The reward notice at the Bargello. Two men in guards' livery." He looked at Beatrice. "How long before someone in this room is offered money to remember seeing them?"

The contessa did not blink. "It has already begun. That is why we are meeting here, and not in the shop where you slept last night."

Michele looked at Lorenzo, who had gone very still.

"The strap of Alessandro's satchel was found in the drain," Beatrice said. "And a man in the Bargello has been asking, since dawn, which painter in Florence mixes his greens so light."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 21: The Revelation · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads