The Painted Lie

Chapter 3: The First Lie

The miniature lay in Lorenzo's open palm like something alive.

Michele had been summoned at midmorning, when the light in the studio was at its truest, and he had come expecting to work. He had come with his charcoals sharpened and his board propped, ready to add flesh to the mouth he had sketched from description two days before. Instead Lorenzo stood at the window with his back to the room, and when he turned, he held out his hand.

"She is in Rome," Lorenzo said. "Her father's household. These past months the roads have been unsafe for a woman traveling with a dowry, so she waits, and I wait, and the wedding waits."

"That is unfortunate," Michele said.

"It is practical." Lorenzo's fingers closed over the small oval. "Or it was. But you cannot paint a woman from my words forever, and I will not have you guessing at what she looks like. So. A likeness was made before she left. Her family had it done by a man in Rome."

He set the thing down on the worktable between them and stepped back, as though to give it room to speak for itself. Michele looked.

It was exquisite, at least in its craftsmanship — an ivory oval the size of his thumb, the paint laid on so thinly that light seemed to come from behind the face rather than fall upon it. A young woman looked out. Dark hair bound back. A long nose, a narrow chin, the faint asymmetry of a mouth that had been trained to hold its peace. Somebody had painted her well. That was the first thing Michele noticed, and the second was that whoever had painted her had not liked her much.

"You have it," Lorenzo said. "Paint from it."

Michele reached for the miniature. Lorenzo's hand came down over his.

"Careful with it."

"I have held paintings before."

"Not this one."

The pressure lasted a heartbeat longer than it needed to, and then Lorenzo lifted his hand away. Michele picked up the ivory. It was warm from Lorenzo's palm, and smaller even than he had thought, and it weighed almost nothing.

"Rome," Michele said.

"Rome."

"Which street?"

Lorenzo smiled. "Does it matter?"

"It might. For the light in the painting. If she sat near a window that faced north or south, the flesh tones would—"

"She sat where she was told to sit." Lorenzo walked to the window and put his back to him again. "The portrait was commissioned by her father. I did not supervise it. What I know is that she is fair-complexioned, that her hair is black, and that the mouth is too small. That last part is the painter's fault, not hers. She does not have a small mouth."

Michele turned the miniature toward the light. "If the mouth is wrong, I should not use it at all."

"Then use your judgment. That is what I am paying you for."

There it was again. The fluency. In the studio, with the tracing paper and the chalks, Lorenzo could not describe his own betrothed's mouth without contradicting himself. But he could construct an alibi for her absence — roads, dowry, a father's caution — as smoothly as if he had rehearsed it. Perhaps he had. Men in his position rehearsed everything.

"Her name," Michele said, not looking up.

"You know her name."

"I would like to hear you say it."

Silence. Four counts of it, maybe five. Long enough for a man in the garden below to cross the gravel and go out through the gate; long enough for a woman's voice in the kitchen to break off mid-sentence.

"Camilla," Lorenzo said at last. He said it carefully, the way one handles an unfamiliar word in a foreign language, making sure of each syllable. "Camilla Strozzi."

It was a good name. It belonged to a real family. That proved nothing at all.

"May I keep it?" Michele asked. "For the duration of the work. I would return it when the panel is finished."

Lorenzo turned. His face had gone smooth the way a pond goes smooth after the stone has sunk. "No."

"I cannot work from a single viewing. Every painter needs to return to the source."

"Look at it now. Study it as long as you like. Then give it back to me."

"You could leave it in my keeping. Locked in the studio. Lucrezia has the key as well as I do."

"I said no." Lorenzo took a step toward him. "Do not make me repeat myself on so small a thing, Michele. It is hers. It stays with me."

Michele nodded, as a servant nods. He carried the miniature to the window where the north light fell clean and flat across his board. For a quarter of an hour he studied it, turning it, holding his own hand beside it for scale, dimming his eyes to see only the values. Lorenzo watched him from the doorway. Michele could feel the watching, and he painted nothing, because he had not been asked to paint. He was being trusted with a viewing, and he had already decided what he would do with it.

At the end of the quarter hour he gave the miniature back. Lorenzo's fingers closed over it the way a miser's fingers close over coin. He smiled, said the panel should be blocked in by the end of the week, and left.

Michele stood still until the sound of his footsteps had faded down the stair. Then he took his satchel from the hook beside the door and opened it on the worktable, and from beneath the loose sheet of studies he drew out what he had smuggled from the kitchen the night before: a scrap of the thin Roman paper the steward used for accounts, and a stub of red chalk, stolen.

He sketched fast. He had looked long enough that the face was still behind his eyes, and the trick was not to think about it, only to let the hand remember. Hair from the temple. The line of the nose, which was the truest thing in the painting. The brow, which was not. Whoever had made the miniature had raised the brow above the eyes and smoothed the space between them, softening a woman who had not been soft, and had given her a mouth she did not have. Two lies in one small ivory oval. Michele did not know why the lies had been told or who had asked for them, but he knew them the way a physician knows a fever — by the heat coming off the skin of the work.

He drew the face exact as the painter had set it down, and then, beneath it, small and faint, he drew the face as the painter had corrected it away — the lowered brow, the true mouth, the patient hardness around the eyes. If the original woman was ever to be found, those two drawings together would be the map.

He could hear footsteps in the corridor. He folded the paper and slid it down inside the satchel, past the lining, where he had sewn a seam loose on purpose in the first week. It lay flat against the leather like a worm in an apple. He heard the inner door of the studio open.

Lucrezia stood with a basket of charcoal on her hip. She looked at the satchel. Then she looked at him.

"You are working," she said.

"I am starting."

"You have a smudge of red on your thumb."

Michele looked. There was. He wiped it against the rag on his belt, and his heart went about its business a little too loudly.

"Notes," he said. "For the underpainting."

Lucrezia set the basket down. She was a small woman with a plain face and the flat gray eyes of someone who had been frightened young and had stopped being frightened by learning to watch instead. She went to the worktable and picked up the stick of red chalk and turned it over, once, and set it back down precisely as it had been.

"Red chalk for flesh tones," she said. "Yes. That is how it is done."

"You know about painting?"

"I know about the house." She took up her basket again. At the door she stopped, and did not turn. "The courier who came on the first morning — the one who stayed inside. His horse was Roman-shod."

Michele kept his voice level. "How would you know that from a horse?"

"Because I grew up on the road to Siena and I have shod horses all my life." She did turn now. Her eyes were not gray at all; they were the color of wet slate, and they held him. "He rode from Rome. He did not bring a bride with him. But he did not come empty-handed either. A man does not stay three hours in a locked room for nothing."

"Lucrezia—"

"I told you to stop asking questions."

"You keep answering them."

"Because you keep asking the wrong ones." She shifted the basket. "Ask not where the bride is. Ask what the courier carried back with him when he left. Draw that, if you can draw such a thing. And keep your smudges to yourself."

She went out. The door closed with a soft, final click, and Michele stood in the north light with his red chalk and his pulse, and then he opened the satchel again, took out the folded paper, and flattened it on the board to look at what he had made. Two faces. The one he had been given, and the one beneath it.

The one beneath it, he noticed now, had the strong flat line of the jaw that ran in the Strozzi blood, as any Florentine would know who had ever seen a Strozzi in the street.

Lorenzo had said the miniature came from Rome.

But the woman in the ivory had never sat for it in Rome, or anywhere else. She had sat for it in Florence, from memory of a face the painter knew, and Michele was almost certain he had seen that face before — at the market, perhaps, or in the crowd at the Piazza della Signoria, raising its chin above the level of the other heads the way they all did, all of them Strozzi, the whole proud, ruined, exiled house of them.

He folded the paper small and pushed it back behind the lining. Then he reached for his board and began, at last, to block in the woman he was being paid to paint — the woman with the small corrected mouth and the raised brow, who did not exist, whose name was his patron's invention the way the road to Rome was his patron's convenience, and whose face, somewhere under all of it, belonged to somebody who had a reason to be hidden.

That night he did not sleep well, and he told himself it was the smell of the linseed oil.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 3: The First Lie · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads