The Painted Lie

Chapter 30: The Harbor

They smelled Livorno before they saw it — salt and tar and the rot of fish guts, a smell so foreign to Michele's lungs that he stopped on the crest of the last hill and simply breathed.

Below them, the sea.

He had painted it a hundred times from memory, from the descriptions of sailors and the fragments in Maestro Paolo's sketchbooks, but he had never understood until now how it moved — that restless gray breathing, that endless shrug against the shore.

"Keep walking," Lorenzo said at his shoulder. "The gate closes at dusk."

They had walked three days. Slept in hayricks and under bridges, stolen bread and watered wine, kept to the cart roads and away from the posting inns where the cardinal's men would be watching. Lorenzo's boots had split at the sole; he'd bound them with strips torn from his own shirt and never once complained. Michele's hands, which had held nothing heavier than a brush for years, had blistered and healed and blistered again.

The forged list still rode against his ribs, rolled tight inside a waxed leather tube that never left his body. Some nights he woke with his hand already closed around it.

They came down through the olive terraces and into the town. Livorno was not Florence. Florence was a jewel set in a ring of hills; Livorno was a working mouth, gaping at the sea, chewing ships and swallowing men from a dozen nations. Genoese and Catalans and Greeks and Turks jostled along the quay. Michele heard four languages before he heard Italian.

"No one will find us here," Lorenzo said. "That is exactly why the French keep their agents here."

They found the harbor office down a crooked lane that stank of pitch. Lorenzo went in alone. Michele waited outside, watching the ships, and tried to feel something other than the cold knot in his chest.

He had left Florence. He had left Paolo in a cell beneath the Bargello. He had left the studio where he had learned to grind lapis into blue, the window where the morning light fell just so across a fresh panel, the little church where his mother was buried. He had left everything he had ever known, and he had done it running, with a warrant at his back, and there had been no time to say goodbye to any of it.

He was not sure he had truly chosen it. He was not sure choice entered into it at all.

"Signor Michele."

He turned. Lorenzo stood in the doorway, and for once the careful mask had slipped — there was something unguarded in his face, some boyish brightness that Michele had never seen on the diplomat's polished features.

"Come. I want you to see."

—

The ship was called *Sainte-Claire*, a French brigantine riding low in the water at the far end of the quay, its hull swollen with cargo and its deck swarming with men. Lorenzo spoke to a bearded man in a coat too fine for a sailor, and there was money, and there was a low exchange in French that Michele followed only in fragments — *Livorno, Marseille, three days if the wind holds, no names on the manifest.*

"They'll take us," Lorenzo said when the man had gone below. "All of us. The refugees from the reading, whoever the friar can send down the coast road. And us."

Michele looked up at the rigging. "And Galvani? Is this his ship?"

"His brother-in-law's. Galvani will meet us in Marseille with what the cardinal's ledger has been hiding." Lorenzo's voice dropped. "Michele. We did it. We have the testimony, we have the countersign, we have the list. The French will pay to see the cardinal ruined, and when they do, Paolo walks free. We only have to stay alive three more days."

"And if the wind does not hold?"

"Then we swim." Lorenzo smiled, and the smile was so unexpected that Michele laughed, once, a raw sound that scraped his throat. It was the first time he had laughed in weeks.

They walked the quay together as the light went gold. Gulls wheeled and screamed. A boy ran past with a basket of sardines, silver tails flashing. Michele watched a man mend a net with his teeth and a wooden shuttle, watched a woman gut fish in six strokes without looking, and thought that these were things he would paint, if he ever painted again — the ordinary machinery of a world he had never known existed.

"You are thinking about the light," Lorenzo said.

"I am always thinking about the light."

"It is good light."

"It is the best light I have ever seen." Michele stopped and looked at him. "That is what I cannot bear, Lorenzo. That I am leaving my home and the first thing that stirs me — the first true thing I have felt in three days — is this place. This sky. The way the sun lies on the water. I should be grieving. And instead I am already painting."

Lorenzo was quiet for a moment. Then he said, "Then paint it."

"That is not an answer."

"It is the only one I have." Lorenzo turned to face him fully, and the mask was gone, and what was underneath was tired and frightened and unaccountably gentle. "Michele. When I was fifteen my father sent me to Lyon to learn the silk trade. I did not want to go. I wept, I think. I do not remember weeping, but my mother said I did. And I spent the first month in that city hating it, and the second month unable to sleep for homesickness, and by the third month I had understood something — that home is not the place you leave. Home is the thing you choose to keep."

"That is a diplomat's answer."

"It is the only kind I have." He reached out, and his hand closed around Michele's wrist, careful, the way you would hold something that might break. "We will start again. Not in Florence. Perhaps never in Florence. But we will start. I have money at Marseille, and Galvani's protection, and you have your hands. You will paint, and I will — I will find work that does not require me to lie to you, which is the only work I want."

Michele looked down at the hand on his wrist. There was a callus on Lorenzo's palm now, from the walking. It had not been there in Florence.

"You lied to me for a year," he said.

"Yes."

"You took a room across the canal and made me think you were a silk merchant's son."

"Yes."

"You watched me paint your portrait and let me think it was for your wedding."

"I did."

Michele lifted his eyes. "And I am supposed to believe that three days of walking makes you a different man?"

"No," Lorenzo said. "You are supposed to believe that three days of walking has shown you the man who was always there, underneath the lie. The lie was the job, Michele. The man was never the job."

The gulls screamed. The tide slapped at the pilings. Michele was aware of his own breath, of his own pulse, of the leather tube against his ribs, and of the terrible fact that he believed him.

He was still working out how to say so when a shout went up from the far end of the quay.

They both turned. A knot of men had gathered at the harbor gate — half a dozen at least, and now more, spilling through the archway with the unhurried confidence of men who knew the exits were covered. Sunlight caught the steel at their belts. And at the front, walking with a slight limp that Michele knew from the archive, from the moment they had heard his boots on the stairs —

Tommaso.

"Down," Lorenzo breathed. "*Down*."

He dragged Michele behind a stack of crates. Through a gap in the boards Michele watched the papal courier stop in the middle of the quay and turn, slowly, scanning the crowd. His eyes passed over the French ship. Passed over the crates. Passed over the place where the two of them were crouched with their breath held.

Then he raised a hand and pointed — not at them.

At the *Sainte-Claire*.

"By order of His Eminence the Cardinal," Tommaso called, in Italian, in a voice built to reach the rigging, "that vessel is forbidden to sail. Any man who leaves this port under French colors this night will answer to the Holy Office."

The deck of the brigantine went still.

Lorenzo's hand closed hard on Michele's arm. When he spoke, his voice was very quiet, and for the first time since Florence, it shook.

"Galvani is aboard that ship."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 30: The Harbor · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads