The Painted Lie

Chapter 31: The Betrayal

Tommaso's men came out of the fish market.

Michele saw them a half breath before Lorenzo did — six of them, no livery, moving between the stalls with the unhurried purpose of men who had already counted their exits. One of them was pulling a barra di ferro from beneath a crate of sardines. The others had their hands inside their coats.

"Lorenzo."

"I see them."

Behind them the Sainte-Claire sat fat and idle at the quay, her sails furled, her gangway up. Ahead of them the harbor curved toward the customs house, where a pair of guards had stopped pretending not to watch and had begun to walk. The cardinal's warrant had done its work overnight. The whole port had closed around them like a fist.

"Back the way we came," Michele said.

"Through the market. Go."

They went. Not running yet — running would have started it — but walking fast, shoulder to shoulder, and the crowd swallowed them for twenty paces before someone shouted behind and the market erupted. A stall of lemons went over. Michele heard the barra di ferro hit cobblestone and skid. He grabbed Lorenzo's sleeve and cut left down an alley barely wide enough for the two of them, and behind them boots struck the stones in a rhythm that was no longer walking.

The alley bent. They came out into the cooper's yard, and there was Alessandro.

He was coming up from the coast road with the first of the refugees — a knot of maybe a dozen, women and children and two old men, their bundles on their backs, their faces already the color of people who had walked three days on bad bread. He saw Michele and stopped.

"You're supposed to be on the ship," Alessandro said.

"There is no ship. Get them back to the road."

"What?"

"Tommaso. He's here. Get them—"

Then the cooper's yard filled with men.

Michele would remember it in pieces afterward, the way he remembered paintings he hadn't finished: the flat crack of a fist on a jaw, a woman shrieking and going down, a child pulled behind a barrel by somebody's arm, Alessandro swinging a length of stave he'd snatched up and catching one of the bargello men across the ear. Lorenzo had his knife out. Michele had no knife. He had the waxed tube, pressed to his ribs under his shirt, and he had his hands, and he used them — drove his shoulder into a man's chest and felt the air go out of him, stumbled, caught himself on the rim of a barrel.

"Up the wall!" Alessandro shouted. "Both of you — the wall!"

There was a low wall on the yard's seaward side, no higher than a man's chest, built of old stone and topped with broken bottles. Beyond it: the back of the customs house, a strip of mud, the water.

"We're not leaving them," Michele said.

"You are leaving them," Alessandro said, and shoved him. "Go. I'll hold."

"Alessandro—"

The man was already turning, already putting his back to the wall and his stave between them and the six, and Michele saw his face then and understood that Alessandro had known, from the moment Tommaso's men had come into the yard, exactly how this would end, and had made his peace with it at a run.

Lorenzo's hand closed on Michele's wrist and hauled.

They went over the wall.

Michele hit the mud on his knees and came up with his palm cut and his ears full of the sound behind them — a stave clattering on stone, a man's grunt, and then Alessandro's voice, loud and level, saying, "He's not here. You're wasting your time with me." Then the wet punch of a fist, and nothing.

Lorenzo dragged him along the mud strip, bent double, keeping the customs house between them and the yard. A fishing boat was tied at a ring near the water gate, rocking, empty, its oars shipped. Lorenzo cut the line with his knife and was in it before Michele had understood what he meant to do.

"Get in."

"They'll see us on the water."

"They'll see us anywhere. In."

Michele got in. Lorenzo took the oars and pulled, and the boat slid out from the customs house into the gray chop of the harbor, and from the water they could see it all: the cooper's yard, the little crowd of refugees pressed against the far wall with bargello men around them like hounds at a pen, and Alessandro on his knees in the middle of it, his hands behind his head, his mouth bloody, and Tommaso standing over him, not touching him, only looking down the way a man looks at a fish he has already decided to buy.

Lorenzo rowed. His face had gone entirely still, which Michele had learned by now was worse than shouting.

They went along the seawall, keeping the moored hulls between them and the quay, and came in again half a mile down at a stretch of shingle where a few boats were drawn up and no one was doing anything but mending nets. They beached the boat and walked, fast, heads down, into the warren of fishermen's lanes behind the harbor — and then into a cottage, hardly more than a shed, that stood at the end of a lane with its door half off its hinges. Lorenzo shouldered in first, checked the single room, and let Michele follow.

Michele got the waxed tube out of his shirt and set it on the table, and stood looking at it. It was all still there. The testimony. The countersign. The list of names paid for silence. Everything they had risked the archive for, everything they had lost Florence for, everything Alessandro had just knelt in the mud for.

All of it. And not one of the refugees.

Michele sat down on the edge of a net-mender's bench and put his face in his hands and did not cry, which surprised him. When he looked up, Lorenzo was standing with his back against the door, watching the lane through the gap.

"You knew," Michele said.

Lorenzo didn't turn. "Knew what."

"You knew they'd be at the yard."

"I knew they'd be somewhere."

"Then why did you walk us into it?"

Now Lorenzo turned. "I didn't walk us into anything. We came out of the alley and they were already there. Alessandro brought them there. He brought the refugees in past three of Tommaso's men, and they followed him home. That's not a trap. That's a man who couldn't see he was being followed, because he'd never had to look."

"He held the wall for us. Don't you dare."

"I know what he did." Lorenzo's voice was flat. "I'll spend the rest of my life knowing it."

Michele stood. The bench scraped back. He was aware, distantly, of his own voice rising and unable to stop it. "Then tell me how they knew the yard. Tell me how they knew the harbor was closed before we did. Tell me how Tommaso walked into Livorno on the exact morning the Sainte-Claire was meant to take us and knew which alley we'd run down."

Silence.

"Tell me, Lorenzo."

Lorenzo looked at him for a long moment. Then he crossed the room and sat down on the floor with his back to the wall, which put him lower than Michele, and this — Michele understood, even furious — was deliberate. It was a man making himself small so he could say a large thing.

"In Florence," Lorenzo said, "I sent word to Livorno. To make the arrangements. Passage, papers, the names of the refugees who'd board. The man who carried that word was Ricci's man. I've used him four years. He was the only channel I had."

Michele went cold from the crown of his head down.

"Ricci knew our route," Lorenzo said. "Ricci knew the harbor. Ricci knew the morning. All of it, everything Tommaso needed to close the port and set his men in the right place — I gave to Ricci's man with my own hand, in my own cipher, because Ricci is my ambassador and I have spent four years obeying him, and until this week I would have sworn on the Sacrament that the man was loyal to France and not to Rome."

"You're saying your own ambassador sold us."

"I'm saying I can't rule it out." Lorenzo's hands were loose on his knees; his voice had not risen once. "I'm saying the only person who knew the yard before Alessandro did was me, and the only person who knew Alessandro would be in it was me. And I'm saying that when Tommaso stood over him, he didn't ask a single question about the ledger or the testimony. He didn't need to. He already had the name he wanted."

Michele heard the quay outside, gulls and a woman shouting fish prices, the ordinary noise of a port doing its ordinary business while Alessandro knelt in a yard a mile away under the cardinal's seal.

"Then you brought this down on all of them."

"Yes."

"You told me, on the quay — believe the man beneath the lie." Michele's throat hurt. "Which man am I supposed to believe? The one who gave you the truth in the cell at San Marco, or the one who wrote our route in a cipher and handed it to your ambassador?"

Lorenzo didn't answer that. His eyes had gone to the door-gap, to the lane.

"Michele," he said quietly. "Pack the tube."

"Why?"

"Because there were six men at the market and six in the yard, and Tommaso was standing in the middle of them with his hands empty. He wanted us taken publicly, on the quay, with the refugees watching. He didn't get that." Lorenzo was already on his feet. "So he's kept Alessandro alive. Which means he means to trade him, and he can't trade him to nobody. He's going to search these lanes house by house, and he'll start with the ones nearest the water, and we are the third house from the shingle."

Michele grabbed the tube off the table and shoved it back down his shirt.

Then, in the lane, a door banged open. Not theirs. Nearer the harbor.

And a voice called out, clear and pleased and much too close, "Check the sheds at the end. He'll have gone to ground by the water, he's a painter, he always goes to the water."

Michele froze. He knew the voice.

It was Signor Guardi, their landlord, who had rented them the attic in Florence and never once asked why they paid in silver, and who had known, this whole time, exactly what he was renting to.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 31: The Betrayal · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads