The cottage smelled of tar and old fish, and the wind off the harbor rattled the shutters like a man trying to get in.
Michele sat with his back against the door, the waxed tube pressed flat under his shirt, and watched Lorenzo sleep. If sleep was the word. Lorenzo had folded himself into the corner like a man who'd forgotten how to lie down, one hand still open on the floor as though he'd fallen asleep reaching for something.
The lamp had burned out an hour before. Michele had counted the bells from the harbor chapel—two, then three—and each one felt like a nail.
He had accused him. In this same room, with the same reek of salt in his nose, he had said *you led them to us*, and Lorenzo had not shouted back. That was the part Michele couldn't put down. He had wanted a fight, wanted Lorenzo to be guilty in some simple, satisfying way, and instead Lorenzo had gone quiet, the way a man goes quiet when he's been hit somewhere he'd already been bruised.
The sky over the harbor was beginning to gray. Michele rose, careful of the loose board by the door, and went to the window.
The Sainte-Claire still stood at anchor, sails furled, hull dark against the paling water. Two bargello boats sat between her and the open sea, lanterns swinging at their prows. No one was going anywhere.
Behind him, Lorenzo stirred.
"You haven't slept," he said. His voice was raw.
"No."
Lorenzo sat up, pressed the heels of his hands into his eyes. "Michele—"
"Don't." Michele turned from the window. "If you're going to tell me again that you understand why I blamed you, I'd rather you didn't."
"I wasn't going to say that."
"Then what?"
Lorenzo looked at him a long moment. In the gray light his face was thinner than it had been in Florence, the diplomat's polish worn down to the wood. "I was going to ask what you want to do."
The question landed oddly. Michele had been braced for apology, for excuse, for the soft careful voice Lorenzo used when he was managing a room. This was none of those.
"You'd follow me?" Michele said.
"I'd listen to you. There's a difference, and I've learned it the hard way." Lorenzo got to his feet, stiff with cold. "I spent four years in Florence telling people what they wanted to hear. I told Ricci where we'd sail before I told you. I told Galvani's people the route and didn't tell the man beside me until the last night. That's the habit. That's what it *is*, Michele—not a betrayal, a habit. And it nearly got you killed on that quay."
Michele said nothing.
"So no," Lorenzo went on. "I'm not asking you to forgive me. I'm asking what you want to do, because I'm done deciding alone."
There was a scratch at the door.
Both of them froze. Michele's hand went to the knife at his belt; Lorenzo slid sideways into the shadow of the wall, reaching for the boat hook.
The scratch came again—three quick, then one. A signal.
Michele cracked the door. A boy stood there, no more than twelve, barefoot in the wet, holding a piece of fried dough in one hand as though he'd been sent on an errand between meals.
"Man said to tell the painters," the boy recited, bored, "that the fat one is at the villa on the Via del Giardino. He's not dead. Man said you'd pay."
"Who is the man?"
"Didn't say. He gave me the dough." The boy held it up as evidence, then held out his other hand.
Michele found a copper in his purse and put it in the boy's palm. The boy bit the dough, considered him, and added, "There's soldiers there. At the gate. Six at least." Then he was gone, running barefoot along the seawall.
Michele shut the door and turned to Lorenzo.
"Alessandro," he said. "That's Alessandro. Via del Giardino—do you know it?"
Lorenzo's face had changed. The tiredness was gone off it like water off stone.
"I know it," he said quietly. "It's Ricci's villa."
The name went through the room like a draft.
"Your ambassador."
"My ambassador." Lorenzo set the boat hook down and stood very still. "He keeps a house in Livorno for the summer. He lends it to the Legation when there's"—a small, humorless pause—"delicate work."
"So Tommaso takes Alessandro there. Not to the fortress. Not to a cell. To the house of the man who sold us."
"To the house of the man who may have sold us." Lorenzo met his eyes. "We don't know yet. But it's a strange place to hold a prisoner unless—"
"Unless the prisoner is a message. To you." Michele sat down on the crate by the window. "He wants you to come and ask."
"Yes."
"And Ricci? If he's the one who wrote Tommaso our route—"
"Then he's the one who decided Alessandro was worth more alive to us than dead to him." Lorenzo's jaw worked. "Which tells us something. It tells us he doesn't want the affair public either. If he did, Alessandro would be in the fortress with the refugees and we'd be reading his confession in the Piazza della Signoria by Easter."
Michele turned the waxed tube over in his fingers. The list. The countersign. The testimony. The only weight he had in the world, and it was worth less than the paper it was written on if no one would carry it.
"Then we don't have to run," he said slowly. "We have to make him need to talk to us."
Lorenzo looked up.
"You're a better liar than I am," Michele said. "You've told me so. So tell me—what does Ricci want more than he wants Alessandro?"
"To be clean," Lorenzo said at once. "To be seen to have done his duty, and to have no fingerprints on the mess. He's spent thirty years perfecting that."
"Then he'll want the testimony. He'll want it in his hand, not Tommaso's."
Now Lorenzo was the one to sit down. He pulled the crate over and faced Michele across the narrow boards of the floor, close enough that the cold stopped mattering.
"You're not proposing we give it to him."
"I'm proposing we walk in the front door." Michele spread his hands. "I'm a painter. The boy told you—six soldiers at the gate. Six soldiers don't stop a painter with a commission in his satchel and a face like a church altarpiece. I go in to paint. I find Alessandro. I find what Ricci keeps in that house." He stopped. "And you stay outside with the boats."
"No."
"You're the one they know. You're the one Tommaso is looking at." Michele leaned forward. "Lorenzo. I spent a year in that workshop copying the masters because my master said I'd never be more than a copyist. Then I forged a wedding portrait for a diplomat, and I lied to a cardinal's men in a monastery garden, and I read Paolo's innocence into the teeth of a piazza. I have not stayed outside the door yet. Don't ask me to start now."
Lorenzo was silent.
Then, unexpectedly, he laughed—one short, broken breath of it, more surprise than joy.
"Four years," he said. "Four years of that room and those men and I never once heard anyone say a true thing out loud until you." He put out his hand. "All right. All right. But we do this properly, or we don't do it at all. A commission. A name he can verify. If I'm going to put you inside that house, I'm going to make you the most convincing painter in Livorno."
Michele took his hand. It was cold, and it held hard.
"What name?" he said.
Lorenzo's thumb moved once across his knuckles, and then he let go and was all business again, straightening on the crate, thinking out loud the way he must have thought in the Legation, quick and level.
"Ricci collects. He collects old men who can't paint and young men who can. It's his one vanity—he's never harmed a reputation for a painting. If a Florentine workshop sends a young master south with a letter of introduction from a name he respects, he'll take it. He'll take it himself, in the garden, with wine, and he'll want to be told he has a good eye."
"Can you write the letter?"
"I can write the letter, the seal, and the name." Lorenzo paused. "We'll need a sitter. Something he'd want hanging in that villa where Tommaso is holding our friend. Something he can't refuse."
Michele looked past him, through the salt-blurred window, at the Sainte-Claire riding at anchor with her lanterns dark and her cargo of hope blockaded behind two bargello boats.
"There's a portrait in the Uffizi," he said, very quietly, "of Ricci's first wife. The one who died. I copied it three years ago for a merchant who couldn't afford the original." He turned back. "I could paint her again. From memory. And I could make her better than the real one."
Lorenzo stared at him.
"You could," he said. "God help us, you could."
Outside, the harbor bell struck four. The bargello boats had not moved. Somewhere across the water, in a guarded villa on the Via del Giardino, Alessandro was alive because someone wanted him alive—and that wanting, Michele thought, was the first door that had opened for them since Florence.
"We go today," Lorenzo said. "Before Tommaso decides a hostage is worth more than a message."
Michele nodded. Then he took the tube from under his shirt and held it out.
"Here," he said. "If I'm painted into that house and I don't come out, this is yours. Don't let Ricci have it. Don't let the cardinal have it. Get it to the French."
Lorenzo did not reach for it.
"I'm not carrying the reason you might die out of that house without you," he said. "Put it back. We'll both walk out, or neither of us will."
Michele looked at him for a long moment, then tucked the tube away again against his chest, where it had been all along.
Outside, a gull screamed over the blockaded water, and the sky went full gray, and somewhere in the villa on the Via del Giardino, a man who collected painters was opening his shutters to the morning he did not yet know was coming.