The Painted Lie

Chapter 32: The Safe House

The fisherman's cottage smelled of tar and old rope, and the single window was a square of grey that let in the sound of the sea and nothing else. Michele sat on the floor with his back against the cold hearth, knees drawn up, watching Lorenzo pace the three steps the room allowed him.

"Stop," Michele said.

Lorenzo stopped. He stood over the coiled net in the corner, hands open at his sides, the way a man stands when he knows he is being weighed.

"Say it," he said.

"Which part?" Michele's voice came out flat, and that frightened him more than shouting would have. "That they were waiting for us, or that they knew which ship, or that Tommaso said our names like he'd read them off a page?"

"They knew the ship," Lorenzo said. "That was mine. I sent the passage request through Ricci's agents in Pisa. Three days ago. I told you that in the marsh."

"You told me he *might* have," Michele said. "You said it the way you'd say a man might catch a chill. Not like this. Not like you knew it in your bones and said it soft so I wouldn't look too hard."

Lorenzo's jaw worked. He reached for words and did not find them quickly, and that hesitation was an answer in itself.

"Alessandro's in their hands," Michele said. "He put himself between us and the bargello so we could row. And Marinella — she was coming by the coast road with the children. Do you understand what's walking into that harbor right now? They'll round them up like sheep at a fair. She trusted me. I told her — "

"I know what you told her."

"You don't know anything." Michele got to his feet. The waxed tube pressed against his ribs under his shirt, and he pressed back, as if it might anchor him. "The only thing that's kept me standing since the piazza is that I thought at least we were running the same direction. But every time I turn, there's a door behind us that someone shut first. First the monastery. Then the road. Now the harbor itself. That isn't bad luck, Lorenzo. Luck doesn't close doors that neatly."

"It isn't luck," Lorenzo said quietly. "I told you it wasn't."

"Then say the rest of it."

Lorenzo looked at the window, at the small grey light, the way a man looks at a thing he means to remember before he loses it.

"Ricci is not my friend," he said. "I never told you he was. He's my ambassador and my superior and I've served him four years, and in four years I've never once caught him in a lie. That's why I trusted him. That's what I mistook for loyalty." He turned back. "But two months before I came to your workshop, he called me into his study and asked who else in Florence knew about the trade agreements. I gave him three names. Within a fortnight, all three were dead — one by fever, one by a fall, one who simply vanished. I told myself it was Florence in summer. I told myself that often."

Michele felt the room tilt very slightly, like a boat.

"You *knew*."

"I suspected. There's a difference, and I told myself it mattered." Lorenzo's voice cracked and did not hide it. "I wanted the painting. Gallo's commission — the counterfeit wedding portrait. He said it was the opening. He said if I could find out who was buying silence, who owned the cardinal's secrets, I could take it to France and end him. And I thought — if it's real, I'll be right. And if it's wrong, no one will ever know I suspected my own master."

"Someone knows," Michele said. "They knew the ship. They knew our road. They knew we'd be on that quay before we did."

"Which means Ricci sent word," Lorenzo said. "To Tommaso, directly. The guard would never have the wit to find us three times in one week without a hand guiding it."

Michele laughed, one short, ugly sound. "You've been carrying that since the start. And you let me stand in San Marco's garden and tell you I'd go to Livorno with you."

"You said yes before I could talk you out of it." Lorenzo's eyes were bright and terrible. "I've talked myself out of nothing. I should have sent you back to Florence that first night. I should have taken the portrait, said the work was done, and gone home to whatever country would have me. But I wanted — " He stopped. "I wanted the painting finished. Because you were finishing it. Because it was the first thing I'd wanted in years that wasn't ordered."

The sentence landed between them and stayed there.

Michele stared at him. "So the only honest thing you've said all week is that you were using me."

"No." Lorenzo stepped close, and Michele did not step back, and that was its own kind of mistake. "Using you would have been easy. I've used men for this work before, and afterward I slept soundly. But I told you about Galvani when I did not have to. I told you about the refugees when I did not have to. I told you *how* I lied — my hands, the way I hold my chin, everything — because I wanted you to be able to tell when I was lying. I've never done that. I've never given anyone the key."

"Then what does that make me? Your accomplice? Your conscience?"

"Someone I would rather be caught by than lie to." Lorenzo's voice came out low and raw. "And it didn't matter. You're right. It didn't matter — I brought you here to be killed."

Michele turned away. He couldn't look at him and think at the same time.

Outside, gulls. Nets. A boy shouting to someone on the strand. Ordinary Livorno evening, twenty steps from a door that would be kicked in if anyone thought to look.

"Your ambassador," Michele said at last. "If he's the one who sold our route — then Tommaso isn't the head. He's a hand. Cutting off the hand won't stop the arm."

"That's what I've been trying to tell you since the marsh."

"Then stop telling me and *say it plainly*." Michele wheeled on him. "What is Ricci to us? An enemy? A traitor? You served him for four years. Four years of watching men die and calling it summer. Tell me why he did it. Tell me why a man with robes and an embassy and a post under the French crown would sell his own people into a cardinal's pockets."

Lorenzo was quiet a moment.

"Because the cardinal isn't paying him in coin," he said. "The cardinal has something. Something Ricci wants, or fears. He's tangled with Rome in a line I can't see from the outside. I've tried to see it. For two years I've watched his letters and his guests and his temper — and there's a name he won't write down. Something he swore never to say aloud." He looked at Michele. "And whatever it is, Tommaso knows it. That's why they hold him high. That's why you and I are nothing to them but paper to be burned."

Michele put his hand flat over the tube at his chest. Paper to be burned.

"Then it isn't burned yet," he said.

"It's the only thing we have, and they know it. Which means we cannot let anyone read it but the right ears. In Florence we read it in a piazza and it lit a fire under half the city. Here, if Tommaso gets one word of it moving, he'll bury every hand that touched it. Including Alessandro's. Including mine."

He said it quietly, and Michele heard the real thing underneath: *and I am not sure I have deserved better.*

The anger in Michele had nowhere to go. It sat like a stone. He wanted to keep it, because it was the only thing that felt like armor. But armor doesn't stop a bargello.

"Say it again," Michele said. "About wanting the painting finished."

Lorenzo blinked. "Why?"

"Because my mother used to say you can tell a man by the names he gives his wishes. If you can stand there and tell me which of yours was true, I'll listen. If you can't, I'll take the tube and walk out of here and we'll both be alone on the docks by morning."

The room was very still. The window greyed toward dusk.

Lorenzo drew a breath.

"No," he said finally. "I can't tell you which of them was true. Not yet. Because I don't know."

"Then you're telling me the truth about your lie."

"Yes."

Michele let out a breath he hadn't known he was holding. It didn't fix anything. But it was the first square stone under a wall he could maybe build.

He moved to the window and looked out through the salt-grimed pane. The quay curved north, and along it, three lamps were lit early at the customs house — earlier than any customs house lights its lamps unless it fears a ship.

"They've posted the harbor," he said. "Not just the Sainte-Claire. The whole quay. Tommaso isn't hunting us anymore. He's holding the entire mouth of the port shut. He means to wait us out."

Lorenzo came to stand beside him, and they looked out together, shoulder to shoulder, two men who had run out of ground.

Then a knock sounded at the cottage door — not loud, not a soldier's. Two quick, two slow. A signal Michele did not know.

And Lorenzo went very pale.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 32: The Safe House · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads