The Painted Lie

Chapter 46: The Secret Plan

Michele found the satchel under the loose floorboard at the foot of the bed, and for a long moment he simply stood there holding it, listening to Lorenzo breathe in the next room.

It was not a heavy thing. That was the first wrongness. Their archive—Michele's copies, the ledger leaves, the transcriptions he had labored over in candlelight for weeks—filled a case the size of a wine crate. This was small, light as a folded shirt. He opened it.

Bread. A wedge of the hard country cheese. Two shirts rolled tight. A knife with the handle wrapped in twine, and beneath the clothes, folded flat, a single sheet of Michele's own paper—the sketching paper he had bought in Florence with money he did not have, paper he had rationed sheet by sheet because it cost more than wine.

On it, in Michele's charcoal, was a map.

The road from the villa down through Fiesole to the Florence gate. Then the Ponte Rubaconte, the Oltrarno, the narrow lane behind Santa Croce where the Certosa's brothers came to buy fish—Guardi's route, the one he'd recited at the villa two nights ago while Beatrice's maidservant poured him wine and watched him the way a cat watches a bird.

And at the bottom, in the corner, small and careful: a second line, going the other way. South. Not to Livorno.

He was still holding it when Lorenzo came in from the garden with his good hand full of rosemary, and stopped.

The silence went on long enough that Michele heard the bees working the lavender outside, heard a horse on the lower road, heard everything except the thing he needed to hear.

"You went through my things," Lorenzo said at last. Not angry. Worse than angry—tired, the way he got when the shoulder was bad, except his shoulder was mending well enough now that he could walk to the garden and back without sitting down.

"I went looking for the second ledger," Michele said. "You said it was in your coat. It was not in your coat."

"It is in the chapel, behind the—"

"Lorenzo."

Lorenzo set the rosemary down on the table and sat, carefully, on the edge of the bed. In the flat afternoon light his face had the look of a man doing sums he had already done a hundred times and hoped not to do again.

"South," Michele said. "Not Livorno. Why is there a road south?"

"Because I drew it before Beatrice named the ship."

"That is a lie, and you are bad at them, which is one of the reasons I—" He stopped. Put the paper on the bed between them. "The ink is dry. This is two days dry at least. You drew it the night Guardi came."

Lorenzo looked at the map for a while, as if it might say something different if he looked hard enough.

"Yes," he said.

"So."

"So I am going to the Certosa," Lorenzo said. "And you are going to Livorno, and on the ninth you will be on the water, and by the twentieth you will be in Lyon wondering who gave you that paper you cannot afford."

The room did not move. Michele was aware, distantly, of his own hands, which had gone cold.

"You decided this," he said. "Alone. Without one word to me."

"You would have argued."

"Yes."

"And you would have won the argument," Lorenzo said, "because you always win the argument, and then we would both be in a condemned cell by the bell tower, which helps Alessandro not at all. This way one of us survives and the ledger reaches France and Beatrice gets what she paid for. It is arithmetic, Michele. It is not even difficult arithmetic."

"Say the rest of it."

"There is no rest."

"There is always the rest with you, you are a diplomat's son, you have never said a plain thing in your life." Michele crossed the room—three steps, the floorboards complaining under him—and stood over Lorenzo with the satchel in his fist. "Say it. You mean to walk into Borgia's own house and trade your life for Alessandro's, and you mean to do it without my being there to stop you, and you mean to have me hear of it from a ship's rail."

Lorenzo's jaw worked. The good hand tightened on his knee.

"He is in the cell because of me," he said. "I brought the archive out of the villa. I put his name in the ledger's margin in my own hand. Ricci did not guess, Michele—he was told, and the telling has my shape on it. Alessandro has been eating bread and water in a stone room for eleven days while I have been sleeping in a doctor's loft with my head on your shoulder."

"And that is your debt to pay, so you pay it, and I am to be packed off with the luggage."

"You are to be alive."

"I have been alive my whole life," Michele said. "It is not as agreeable as you make it sound."

He heard his own voice shake, and hated it, and did not take it back. He sat down on the bed, not close, a hand's breadth between them, and made himself breathe.

"Tell me the whole plan," he said. "Not the part you think I can bear. All of it."

Lorenzo was quiet.

"The friar at Santa Croce," he said finally, "takes cartloads into the Certosa three mornings a week—fish, wine, wax. I was a purchased clerk at the Palazzo della Signoria; I know three of the men who keep the Certosa's books. I go in in the wax cart. Guardi says the condemned cells by the bell tower are opened at sext for the sweep, and the sweep-boy is nine years old and can be bought with a knife he thinks is a gift. Alessandro walks out with the sweep's basket. I do not."

"You do not."

"Someone must hold the door that side."

"They will hang you, Lorenzo. They have a warrant with your name and the wax is still soft on it."

"Then they hang me," Lorenzo said, and for the first time his voice was not steady either. "And you are in Lyon, and you paint, and in forty years some fat prior pays you good money for a ceiling, and you have forgotten a man who had the poor sense to love you in a marsh."

Michele hit him.

Not hard—an open hand, flat against the bad shoulder, which was a cruel thing to do and he knew it as he did it and could not help it. Lorenzo grunted and went white and curled away, and Michele was already gripping his arm, appalled.

"I am sorry," Michele said. "I am sorry. Sit—"

"I am sitting."

"For God's sake, let me—" He got the wine from the table, made Lorenzo drink, held the cup while he did it. His hands had stopped being cold. They were doing something, which was better than not doing anything, which was how he had survived every bad thing that had ever happened to him.

"You think I am a thing to be carried," he said, when Lorenzo could breathe properly again. "A painting to be wrapped in straw and shipped ahead. Because I am younger, because I am not brave in the way you are brave, because I make pictures all day like a child with a stick in the dirt."

"That is not—"

"You have never once asked me what I want."

"I know what you want. You have told me every night for a week. Lyon, a shop with a blue door, a window over the river—"

"I want *that*," Michele said. "I want that with you in it. The blue door is nothing. The door is a *door*, Lorenzo."

Lorenzo stared at him. For a heartbeat he looked much younger than he was—the way he had looked in the marsh when the horse died, before he had learned to make his face a wall.

"I cannot be the reason you die," he said.

"You are already the reason I am alive," Michele said. "That is the bargain. You do not get to take it back because the arithmetic is inconvenient."

He stood. Went to the window. The lower road was empty; the contessa's garden went down in terraces toward the olive rows, and beyond them the hills were the soft blue of bad weather coming up from the coast. Three days to the ninth. A ship at Livorno. A boy with a basket at the bell tower.

He turned around.

"Here is what happens," he said. "We go to the Certosa together. But not the way you planned it—we do not walk in and hang ourselves for the pleasure of it. You know the ledger-men. I know faces—I have drawn the whole court of Florence, Lorenzo, I have sat in corners and put every fat signore on paper while they talked about me as if I were furniture. There is a man at the Certosa, the cellarer; I drew him at a wedding two years ago and he wept at the picture, he is vain as a peacock. I can make him open a door."

"That does not mean—"

"It means we need a fourth day," Michele said. "We send word to Beatrice that the ship waits, and we go up the hill to Alessandro first, and *then* Livorno, all three of us, or none of us at all."

Lorenzo opened his mouth, and closed it, and something in his face changed that Michele had not seen there before—not hope exactly, but the dismantling of a wall he had spent a week building.

"Beatrice will never permit it," he said.

"Then we do not tell her," said Michele, and picked up the satchel from the bed, and began, methodically, to unpack it.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 46: The Secret Plan · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads